PRC 1997 12 09CHANHASSEN PARK AND
RECREATION COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
DECEMBER 9, 1997
Chairwoman Lash called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m.
MEMBERS PRESENT: Jan Lash, Fred Berg, Ron Roeser, Jim Manders, Jane Meger, Rod
Franks and Mike Howe
MEMBERS ABSENT: None.
STAFF PRESENT: Todd Hoffman, Park & Rec Director; Jerry Ruegemer and Patty Dexter,
Recreation Supervisors
VISITOR PRESENTATIONS: None.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES: A motion was made and seconded to approve the Minutes of the
Park and Recreation Commission meeting dated November 25, 1997. All voted in favor and the
motion carried.
CONSIDER REQUEST TO RE-ESTABLISH THE MINNEWASHTA HEIGHTS PARK
SKATING RINK.
Jerry Ruegemer presented the staff report on this item.
Lash: Okay. We have, is that what you're here for?
Audience: Yes.
Lash: Okay. Would you like to come forward?
Cindy Hanson: I've been talking to several people in the neighborhood. We intend to monitor the
situation also by putting a log at the park asking people to sign in when they come and skate so
we can keep an eye on it and we're going to log things like ice conditions and temperature also so
if it's unreasonably cold, obviously people aren't going to be skating and we want that to be part
of the consideration.
Lash: And are you Cindy?
Cindy Hanson: Yes I am.
Lash: Okay. Can you just state your name?
Cindy Hanson: Cindy Hanson.
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Ruegemer: And Jan, we can work with Cindy on that and develop a log type of system too and a
place to put that out...
Cindy Hanson: That'd be great. We thought about some type of log that we can put in, just leave
in a Ziploc bag to keep it dry that people can take out, sign in and I realize that some of the kids
will probably need a little more prompting to get them to do that but if it's done for a while, and
makes a difference, then we know when it's being, the peak hours are being used.
Hoffman: Sue, who's?
Cindy Hanson: Sue Leitner.
Hoffman: She called and asked what I felt the base level of use would be. In response in her
voice mail... 10 people per hour each day would be kind of consider a base to justify about
$3,000.00 to $5,000.00 per year to put in one rink. And so what I could not having any, you
know we don't have any quantities or any loggings in the past so what we could say is that it was
by far the least rink out of all of our other rinks... Most times on a daily basis they flood all of the
rinks in sequence... I think when we move into our next item, we'll be able to see that, if you
would develop a service area, a halfa mile or larger, smaller, that this would be a rink that you
would want to include in that service area program to meet the needs for that particular area. It's
not like it's...
Lash: Okay, thanks.
Cindy Hanson: Thank you.
Lash: Jim, do you have any comments?
Manders: I guess Todd has kind of answered two of the questions. Even monitoring other rinks
and usage, if that would be appropriate in making this decision next year.
Lash: Okay, Ron. Fred.
Berg: No, I agree.
Lash: I do too. Frank. Rod. Sorry. Does that happen a lot?
Franks: That happens quite often. Quite often. Did the maintenance crews that flood the rink,
Todd maybe you can answer this for me. Do they keep any kind of, do they log anything when
they flood the rinks, i.e. the conditions or what they consider to be the use? They currently don't
do anything. I certainly don't want to ask them to do more than what they're doing.
Hoffman: We can do that. They log their overtime hours.
Lash: But we don't want to start adding anymore overtime hours.
2
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Roeser: I think they've been judging by the amount of cuts in the ice.
Hoffman: Cuts that are in the ice, yeah. Absolutely.
Franks: I just don't want to run into the same situation we had when they made the presentation
where we were on our information that the maintenance crews were saying that it wasn't being
used and the neighbors were saying that yes it was being used and it's like how do we deal with
that kind of discrepancy. The log idea that you brought up is a good idea but there again we're
relying on the children to fill in when we're there and that's if there's a pencil available and all this
kind of stufl~
Hoffman: Yeah, and how do you log scratch marks?
Lash: Well I can read that so just bring it in.
Hoffman: Well on the ice though.
Lash: Oh, I thought when you meant when the kids wrote.
Hoffman: No, how do you log the number of scratch marks in the ice.
Franks: Well the interest is certainly here right now, I mean with this petition so.
Hoffman: I guess we can come up with no use, minimal use, low use, moderate use, heavy use,
because they flood that thing the entire season and then you can see based on the neighborhood
log and the maintenance log, how things look. To be quite honest, you're putting.., going to be
short. If anything, it's not going to be long. It's not going to be long on your log.
Cindy Hanson made a statement from the audience.
Lash: How could the light on the post get flipped over to the side? Or can the post get turned or
not?
Cindy Hanson...
Roeser: I think we might be pushing our luck.., change the light.
Lash: Jane.
Meger: The only thing I had is I promised my son I'd ask when we start flooding.
Hoffman: There's a lot of people that ask that. Continuous. We're in the 30's and 40's. We are
flooding for, dropping water and saturate the soil so when it get hard and cold weather, that the
soil be ready to accept the additional on top of it. We have been flooding the rinks.
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Lash: Mike.
Howe: I'm fine with it. I think, I'm jumping ahead here but this chart, the colored chart. It looks
to me like we kind of do need more rinks in the northwest territories up there so I thought that
would fit and we need to monitor it and revisit it again next year but I'm fine with it.
Lash: Okay. Is there someone interested in making a motion on this?
Roeser: I'll move that we take staff's recommendation. Do you want me to read the whole
thing?
Lash: Sure.
Roeser: It is staff's recommendation that the Park and Recreation Commission approve the
pleasure rink at Minnewashta Heights Park for the 1997/98 season. It is also recommended that if
the rink does not see a lot of activity in 1997/98 skating season, that the Park and Recreation
Commission review whether or not to provide a rink in the future.
Meger: Second.
Roeser moved, Meger seconded that the Park and Recreation Commission approve the
pleasure rink at Minnewashta Heights Park for the 1997/98 season. It is also recommended
that if the rink does not see a lot of activity in 1997/98 skating season, that the Park and
Recreation Commission review whether or not to provide a rink in the future. All voted in
favor and the motion carried.
Hoffman: You should know, at least from the staff's perspective, we feel strongly that not only
having, when you have an open skating rink and combine the light, like you have with a wanning
house.., where we want to go. As long as you're making that $3,000.00 to $5,000.00
investment...
DEVELOP SKATING/HOCKEY RINK SERVICE AREA POLICY.
Jerry Ruegemer presented the staff report on this item.
Lash: Could you go over quickly which ones currently have wanning houses and which ones
currently have hockey rinks?
Ruegemer: Sure. Currently we do have three wanning houses in Chanhassen... up in this area.
Site #3, North Lotus.
Hoffman: Temporary. It's a portable trailer.
4
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Ruegemer: We also then have Site #6, City Center Park. Directly to the north of City Hall. That
is a permanent structure. Then also Site #2 out at the Chanhassen Recreation Center... Those two
sites, the Chanhassen Recreation Center and City Center Park have two hockey rinks and pleasure
skating rinks...
Lash: So none of the others have hockey?
Ruegemer: No.
Hoffman: Site #1, Roundhouse Park will have a warming house. The round house. Or at least
the potential. We also have programs as part of the master plan at... It hasn't been programmed.
Lash: Are we putting a skating rink out there this season?
Hoffman: A pleasure rink, yeah.
Lash: Are we planning on the warming house too or not? No?
Berg: What does it cost us to have somebody at the warming house for a season?
Ruegemer: Overall, I don't know what the breakdown is but overall per rink, overall it's about,
roughly about $6,000.00 for all three sites that we've been staffing.
Lash: They're all staff comparably aren't they? So roughly $2,000.00 to stafl~ And then what's
the rent on those portable ones?
Ruegemer: The rent on the portable, roughly about $1,200.00 to $1,500.00 per season. When it's
set up...
Howe: ... you say, I have a question perhaps. What does a staff do at the warming house? Just
prevent vandalism or is it just more of.
Ruegemer: Just to have a presence there. Have basically help out with any type of situation.
Help you know ice skate. Turn on lights. Make sure the heat is properly working. Just kind of
keep things in an orderly fashion. Monitor the use. They log daily reports.
Howe: Make sure people.., for example.
Lash: Right. Enforcing rules. Exactly. Any other questions for staff'?
Franks: Just one maybe. Which of the parks are amenable to having skating facilities? I'm
guessing that probably not all of them can support rinks.
Ruegemer: For parking and that type?
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Franks: Parking and ability to get the trucks to where we could put in a rink. Are there some
that are just not going to be able to support a rink?
Hoffman: ... all of them would support construction of... Pheasant Hills there's a better site for a
skating rink than Curry Farms...
Lash: Bandimere probably .... Did you get Meadow Green? Well Bandimere is just a matter of
probably time. And Sunset Ridge we already said once, you know that that's not really accessible
right now. Once that road goes through we'd consider that. I was kind of looking at Carver
Beach as being a big overlap area. Would there be a problem if we eliminated that one do you
think?
Hoffman: Yeah I think you probably...
Lash: They could go to North Lotus or Meadow Green. Or City Center.
Manders: That's pretty tough to get to, that Carver Beach area...
Lash: Yeah, but Meadow Green wouldn't be bad. Go right down Chaparral Lane or whatever
that is there.
Berg: Whatever that is.
Lash: Well is that what it is?
Berg: That's the main artery of the city, Chaparral Lane.
Lash: I was kind of leaning towards Curry Farms just because it seems like that site never gets
anything because of the soils there.
Roeser: That would not be a bad place for a rink, would it.
Lash: Is that accessible or, yeah.
Ruegemer: It might be difficult getting up and down the hill, unless you put that, there's really no
other...
Lash: Plus it's a little more easily accessible than Pheasant Hills too.
Berg: Are we talking potentially this year for this?
Lash: No. No.
Berg: I'd really like to develop a system where we can gauge how these things are being used
because we're hearing that we might be getting stuff back in terms like ice skating rinks and I'd
6
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
like to see.., organized as to how they're being used and then make some decisions based on that.
I think we...
Hoffman: We'll have good data. I'll create a log with Dale Gregory, the Park Superintendent.
That will go right into the flood trucks. We've got lwo of them and they'll log it and we'll come
up with that... Yeah, you were doing the math and as you added up $1,500.00, $2,000.00 and
three $5,000.00 in labor, and you're up to $6,000.00 or $7,000.00 per site, and then as a growing
community we're going to have 10 or a dozen sites, so you're up over $100,000.00 for a winter
skating program. So that's a significant program that will be, of your budget, you're talking, this
is not a small piece of the pie. That's about a quarter of the...
Berg: I'm in favor, I'm inclined to vote in favor of as many skating rinks as we can get simply
because we've always been proponents of let the kids go out and do something unorganized.
Have fun and play and that's what this stuff'.., so philosophically I'm strongly in favor of 100 of
them.
Hoffman: And then there's the staffing issue. As we talked about, do you have to staff these or
don't you have to staff these? As they bent my ears out west in the small town of Victoria, we
had no, it was on the honor system for turn lights on. Lights ofl~ Turn the heat on. Heat ofl~
Open the door and close the door.., so there's good and bad to that.
Roeser: If you have wanning houses, you almost have to.
Hoffman: ... wanning houses with no supervision.
Roeser: In Victoria...
Hoffman: I don't know, I was there last winter. Still going on.
Lash: The circles that you have drawn, Jerry, is that a half mile service area or one mile?
Ruegemer: Those are half miles.
Lash: Half miles.
Franks: Was there any consideration made about looking at this in terms of population density
instead of just pure distance? Are each of those circles then containing pretty equal amount of
population? No?
Hoffman: No. Very second bullet point, should the criteria for developing or maintaining the
population. At what point? If you take a look at sites, well we've heard about.., putting in
circles. Out at Galpin Boulevard Park. This is parkland here. Potential site.., number of
households.., you probably have to include some households out in this area...
7
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Lash: I think when we have obvious barriers such as Highway 5 or Highway 7, and we have
overlapping service areas, that would not bother me as much. So I would include households in
that particular case that are north of TH 5 because otherwise they have to cross. And the same
with Cathcart and Minnewashta Heights. Barriers like Lotus Lake. Things like that make it
difficult.
A comment was made at this point that was not picked up on tape.
Lash: I don't think we take it into account because if they're not in that neighborhood.
Berg: People can't use them up in the.., neighborhood.
Audience...
Hoffman: Play areas and basketball. They're two separate parks. One has play areas and tennis.
The other has play area and basketball. And in Springfield, at least as far as I know, Springfield
which is down south, north of Bandimere, they have a private park there with play areas, tennis or
basketball and...
Lash: Where is that?
Berg: Where is that private park?
Hoffman: Springfield, just north of Bandimere.
Franks: Right in the comer of Lyman Boulevard and Lake Riley.
Lash: Where were we?
Hoffman: We were here. Bandimere sits right here. It's this properly.
Lash: Is this the one with zero lot lines?
Hoffman: No.
Lash: No? Okay.
Hoffman: It's a large development. It was here, I would venture to guess almost two years
ago...
Lash: And we approved another private park in there?
Roeser: That was that high density area, right?
Lash: No. That's what I was thinking Ron.
8
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Hoffman: Yeah, you looked at the plan. I'll bring it back to you for FYI...
Lash: Okay. Just because we all look confused? Yeah, was that about the same time that we did
the Lundgren Bros. thing? No?
Hoffman: Same developer. Yeah, 3 or 4 years later. Different applicant.
Lash: I really thought after we did that we said we'd never do that again.
Berg: Is that when you brought...
Hoffman: No sir. Maybe they did.
Lash: I really can't remember that. Okay. All right. What would we like to do with this? Do
we want to try and establish a policy or do we want to wait until we have the info so we are
basing it on something?
Manders: I don't think we're in a position to establish anything. I would ask, I guess this is going
to be more of a philosophical kind of question relative to winter sports and any kind of other
sports. I mean we've got limited dollars and.., talking $100,000.00 for what? December, partly
January, February starts melting. You know it's not a very wide window that we're talking about
and I think we need to consider those dollars relative to some of our other longer seasons or
higher demand. Maybe this is the highest demand. Soccer you hear that being pushed. We need
to view this in a bigger picture.
Hoffman: We'll refine those costs for you. It's dangerous when you start taking a look at
$3,000.00 to $5,000.00 in labor per rink. The more you build, the lower that cost per rink goes
down so we'll take a look at those. Analyze the capabilities of our two water trucks as well.
How many, how long does it take to make a round? Do you have to add another vehicle and...
Lash: Well I appreciated Fred's comments as far as this being an unorganized activity for
children, and it is again developmentally appropriate for young children to be doing that type of an
activity. However, it is difficult to do without a wanning house and little kids can't stand to be
out that long. And that's a key piece we need to look at. We can put a lot of money into rinks
but if it's too cold for them to skate, it ends up being kind of a waste so there's, I would not
necessarily be in favor of putting in a lot of rinks if we weren't committed to the money to at least
put some wanning houses in too. Whether they be permanent, you know maybe in the end
permanent. You know that's a multi-use building that can be a picnic shelter type thing.
Wanning house, combination would in the long run be the most responsible way to go. I don't
know. We'd have to look at some information.
There was some discussion between commissioners that wasn't picked up on tape.
9
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Hoffman: It followed the, emulated the capital at St. Paul model where they have a park for
every neighborhood and a park building at each...
Lash: They did little daycare things in there, didn't they? You know in the summer it's your
summer programs... Okay. So is there a motion that we table this until a particular time in the
future, such as a month?
Manders: Yes...
Lash: Okay, do you want to pick a particular time?
Manders: I think staff can decide on an appropriate time when they.
Lash: Okay. Is there a second to that?
Howe: Second.
Manders moved, Howe seconded to table action on policy development for skating/hockey
rink service area. All voted in favor and the motion carried.
PROGRAM REPORTS:
A. CHANHASSEN RECREATION CENTER MONTHLY REPORT.
Mike: I'm Mike actually and Nathan did the report but when Nathan was here I did the report so
I just want to clear that up. Secondly, I want to add, pardon my cold if I have to clear my throat
or cough during my presentation here. I'm going to move down the list here to the present
programs, partially because most of them are soon to be past programs. Floor hockey, pre-school
basketball and actually our first session of dance are all ending and they're all going quite well.
I'll jump right into the upcoming programs. Actually before I do that I'm going to say, I'm sure
Jerry will say something about this also. The Breakfast with Santa went very well. We had a big
turnout and everybody seemed to have a great time. Upcoming program would be Daddy
Daughter Date Night, which is in February. We actually have two nights for it. They're filling
quite fast, which is nice to see. We're currently taking registration for Space Camp. We're
offering that again in April. It's been a very popular program at the Rec Center. A new program
that has, that goes kind of with the Space Camp is Pioneer Camp. It's run by the same company.
They'll do pioneer crafts and eat pioneer food and should be a pretty interesting program so we're
adding that one. We also have a babysitting clinic coming up. Sports Spectacular in January.
And the 3 on 3 adult basketball league which is filling up. It starts in the first of January. Self
defense.
Howe: You probably could combine those two.
Mike: Which one's that? Self defense and basketball.
10
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Commission...
Mike: Yeah, actually last year they had a 3 on 3 league as kind of an experimental thing. Jason
at the Rec Center started it and he had 8 teams and he had a tournament at the end and he had
trophies and it actually went really well. I think he's going to have a maximum of 12 teams this
year. That's filling up fast. Memory books. Photo organization are both classes that start in
February and Photo Album Workshop is also in February. Our dance program, I'm going to
jump ahead to the dance program. Last year we ended with 96 students compared to ending of
this fall we have 144 students. So we have a 48% increase in our dance program. As a result of
the increase, we added three new classes and we have a new dance instructor, Caroline Anderson
who is also teaching a couple classes. Tae Kwon Do, another ongoing program that we have.
We've added an after school class for some of the, to kind ofl~et some of the growth of the
evening classes and we've seen some good numbers in those classes also. Two new staff
members. First of all at the Rec Center we have Tom Knowles. He's our new facility supervisor.
He previously worked for Northwest Athletic Club in the gym scheduling and facility usage area.
And also Caroline Anderson is our new dance instructor as I previously said. That's all I had for
you.
Howe: A question. What's Sports Spectacular?
Mike: Sports Spectacular is like a combination program that has one week they'll play whiffle
ball. The next week they'll do volleyball. The next week they'll do kick ball.
Howe: Kids?
Mike: Yeah.
Lash: It goes for the whole month of January?
Mike: Actually I think it's a 6 week program. Once a week type of a deal.
Roeser: What's the Dance for Fun thing? Is that?
Mike: That's the actually, it's a three session, they have like a fall, winter, spring session.
Roeser: What kind of dancing? I mean is this again for kids?
Mike: Yeah. It starts with 3 year olds and works it's way up. We have Kinderdance. Ballet,
tap, jazz. All kinds of. They have a recital in the spring. It's a pretty big deal so.
Lash: How about the Santa Brunch. Any rough ideas what kind of numbers you had?
Ruegemer: Yeah, you bet. I have that. 817 were served on Sunday at the Recreation Center.
Just hear a lot of positive comments from everybody attending. The Rec Center really lends itself
11
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
very well to that event. The community set up... the staffhas always been very helpful in that...
and everything set up for that. It works out great having this vinyl floor out there for certain...
It really is a nice area. It works nice having the milk area in working with the school for their
walk-in cooler. They'll go over there ahead oftime...very good event. The tree lighting
ceremony happened last Saturday night. Had about 125 people there roughly for that. We had a
bonfire out there. Had hot cider... Santa Claus made a great entry.
Franks: Is that right by the clock tower? Is that where the lighting?
Ruegemer: Yeah. Santa made a great entrance in the aerial truck. Up in the bucket... I think
really for next year I think there's some ideas presented that maybe we should look.., or some
kind ofa...maybe closer to City Hall on main street. Maybe in the expansion area of City Hall.
Whether it's closer to West 78th Street or closer to Coulter Drive. Kind of get it more focused
more towards City Hall so we can look at that.
Lash: Away from the clock tower for the tree lighting thing? I would support a live tree.
Ruegemer: We can take a look at that....getting moved with road projects, that type of thing so
we can take a look at transplanting another tree and we'll...
Lash: Okay. Anything else on the monthly report?
B. FALL PROGRAMS.
Dexter: Thank you Chairman and the commission .... highlight some of the programs that are
going on and now, I guess part of my job is to kind of...how the programs actually. We're down
with our fall programs. We still have a few in place but the ones that are complete, I have just
jotted down the program and then the net revenue. That of course is... In all six of them that have
finished up, five did well and we have to cancel one for lack of interest. You know and
something that we think about every time when we off'er new programs quarterly is, we don't
want to just keep turning the wheels and offering programs that, feel like you have to offer
programs. We try to evaluate... Right now you can kind of see some of the programs that have
been very successful for us. And as with all the programs that we do out at the Rec Center, we do
after action reports on and a very thorough evaluation of the program and all those after action
reports are available in my... The revenue and expense report.., so if you really want to know
about the program... And then just to let you know, I may have mentioned it last month but
November was a record breaking month for us out at the Rec Center .... we have 17,500 revenue
in that.., and it came from two areas....dance and of course our pre-school sports. We have had...
Any questions?
Lash: Is this the time I should do my pre-school speech? Or should I wait until we get to the.
Hoffman: Admin.
Lash: Okay. Should we wait?
12
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Audience...
Lash: So is it just the fundamentals of how to wear skates and move? It's not floor hockey then.
Audience: No. Hanus Sports...
Lash: Make sure there's a winner.
Audience: ...yeah, of like I said. Of how to fall. How to pick yourself up...
Lash: Okay. Anything else on that? All right, let's move on.
C. SENIOR CENTER COORDINATOR'S REPORT.
Lash: Anyone have anything they'd like to comment on?
Hoffman: Kara sends her regrets. She had another commitment...
Lash: It looks like she's doing a great job.
Commissioner: It is. I think it's tremendous. I can't wait until I'm a senior. But they really just
do so much...
ADMINISTRATIVE REPORTS:
A. REFERENDUM PROJECT STATUS.
Hoffman: Thank you Chair Lash, members of the Commission. I'd like to go through in more
detail one of these to give you an idea on the schedule. I participated in a four hour meeting today
with our project consultants for the trails and.., updated information for you. Neighborhood
parks, it says there and this goes down the list. What we have received from Brower and
Associates... back to our staff and... The program, elements of the program. It was identified at
those meetings, how big do you want the field? Do you want irrigation? Do you want grass?
Gravel? How many fields? What they've done is kind of broke down all those numbers and
developed what they feel are the sizes of the elements that we would like to see, that the
community would like to see in these parks. They have submitted all that raw data to us this
morning.., comment on those. On kind of their reaction to the community's input and then take
that to the next round of...
Lash: Are you talking about neighborhood parks or community parks?
Hoffman: Oh, excuse me. I started with the wrong one. Community. Yeah, talking about the
community parks. $1.4. So we have Bandimere and City Center. Where we're at today is
developing a base plat to start from. So they want a survey of accurate information. What's out
13
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
in the field today. The surveyors have been employed. They've been working at Bandimere, or
excuse me, at City Center for the last week. I've seen the trucks and the four wheelers driving
around.., and leaving survey.., of all the trees. What elevations we have out there. Where the
buildings are. Where the existing facilities are. Where the tree is out there and where every piece
of asphalt. Every fixed amenity in that site will be surveyed. The elevation will be fixed so they
can have an accurate base.., to start improvements. And then they will move down to Bandimere
and complete the same process. So we are moving into kind of that second phase of... design and
we would most likely schedule, your first review back at the Commission with the public invited
in January. And Jeff and I will determine a date this Thursday morning. He's coming in at 8:00
to talk about the scheduling... A lot of good input from the neighbors. So far they've responded
very positively. We have one property owner at City Center which is a new homeowner kind of
right up at the comer of the existing park and the expanded area so we're kind.., with him.
Started off very, very excited back somewhat so... So any questions on community parks?
Apologize about the confusion.
Lash: You're going to bring this back to us and it will be presented to us in a public meeting at
the same time?
Hoffman: If you'd like to do a work session.
Lash: I'd prefer a work session I think. Anyone else have feelings?
Howe: Yeah, I agree.
Lash: Okay.
Hoffman: Okay. Other issues on the community park sites? City Center or Bandimere? We
continue to work with Doug Hanson, the property owner of the land north of City Center
which.., proposed expansion. We need to get a little tighter handle on budget and how much that
land costs...
Manders: So in terms of attendance by neighbors. Fair or good?
Hoffman: Yeah, from the numbers that I saw, other commissioners can comment. I was out of
town.
Lash: Yeah, we had a lot of good comments. But I guess I'm interested in when I said I wanted
a work session, I'm talking about earlier in January and then our normal meeting, okay. I want to
make sure you understand what I'm.
Hoffman: Yep, got it. Neighborhood parks, we will continue to work with our neighborhood
group so we have 18 improvements. 18 park sites to complete improvements. We can kick those
meetings off at the first of the year. Kind of towards the end of January. I'm currently
negotiating a contract with Hoisington-Koegler Group to perform the professional work
associated with that.., and I'll do that with Council on the 13th in January. About half of those are
14
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
what you'd classify as real significant improvements where there'd be no real change in the
neighborhood so we want to keep those people in those neighborhood meetings with.., and then
bring them in for a Park Commission meeting. Present to you what has been completed as far as
background investigation. Design. Product selection. Those type of things and then present that
to you...
Lash: How are you planning on doing that and getting all of those in this winter yet so that we
can? Are we planning on moving forward with these in the summer, correct?
Hoffman: Yep. Absolutely. January, February, and March.
Lash: So more than one neighborhood a meeting, right?
Hoffman: More than one. And you would, as a commission you'll need to let me know,
traditionally what we're doing on the playgrounds is they're selecting their playgrounds and
meeting as a neighborhood and then it comes back to the commission. IF you want to do anything
differently, but that's about the only thing. You know are you applying asphalt, playgrounds,
basketball pad, park trails. If there's anything of real interest that you want involved in up front,
kind of before you turn that over to the neighborhoods and you need to let me know.
Lash: I think with the playground equipment, rather than just giving each neighborhood total free
rein, I think economically we'd be better off if we, not that I want to make each play experience a
cookie cutter experience, but I think we would probably be better if we dealt with one vendor,
wouldn't we? As far as sending out, getting a bid.
Hoffman: All the new equipment.
Lash: Right, right.
Hoffman: Most of these are adds. We're adding to an existing piece of equipment so we'll be
dealing with...
Lash: Okay, so we have, so we're limited there.
Hoffman: Everything we can package and bid competitively will absolutely be done.
Lash: Okay.
Hoffman: Construction of trails. We have just completed the first round of... association with the
completion of these six trail segments for really a total of about 7 miles of trails. They completed
preliminary alignment study and then proposed trail alignments for each one. Which side of the
road it would be on. Where it would be... ditch section. Those tabulated... Highway 7 is all on
the south side of State Highway 7. It does encroach into Shorewood for a small portion...
authorization from the City of Shorewood to complete that trail. For the most part the confusion
on that trail had to do with the terminus. Starting and ending point. Why did we start it at
15
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Minnewashta Parkway? End it at Washta Bay Road. Why could it not extend farther to the west?
... matter of budget .... would have to cross the grade to go... you can enter internal streets off
Washta Bay Road. A couple of areas that we're studying with the neighborhood. One has to do
with the, kind of the parkway right in front of Minnewashta Heights Park. We're proposing
moving the trail out of the ditch line, closer to the park to... put landscaping in there and the
neighborhood would actually like to work with us to replace some of the landscaping which is
now over 20 years old and grown up and... We are working with probably a dozen individual
landowners concerning... For the most part this trail is within the existing right-of-way. Have to
purchase very little permanent easements or temporary construction easements.., support for the
trail on Highway 7, really...
Lash: Trees would be the biggest issue.
Hoffman: Trees are the biggest issue in all the projects and what really the design and
presentation team, how we characterize it is, just behind the top value of building the trails as
approved by the referendum, the next value which we hold is preserving existing vegetation
wherever possible. Without jeopardizing the integrity of the alignment. Questions on Highway 7
before we move on? We'll take each one. This is kind of just an information session. I'll try to
give you as much information as I can that we've discussed as kind of work team. You will
receive that all in a packet of information which we proofed today and it has a project schedule in
there. Review schedule we'll talk about here briefly and then that will be decimated tomorrow to
the City Council and then I'll also send it to the Planning Commission and Park and Rec
Commission. So all of this will be tabulated in a written form for you. It has all the Minutes of
all the meetings which have been held to date. All of the comments from the citizens to date and
our reaction. Galpin Boulevard is one, Powers and Galpin are the two longest segments. They
also have the highest preliminary budgets. I'll talk about budget issues as we move here. We are
too high at the present time.., preliminary costs. That is due to costs of, or at least the preliminary
cost estimates on permanent and temporary easements. Never in my estimation did I fathom that
we would be at nearly a halfa million dollars in permanent for an easement for trails. Looking at
ways to reduce that. They're also taking a look at ways to reduce the overall budget.., trails. One
of those is the terminus at Galpin Boulevard trail.., pretty significant retaining walls. There's also
a narrow section.., and it's one of the least interesting as far as design. For just about this entire
segment the design approved.., right behind the driving lane, the asphalt, bituminous curb and
then...majority of that segment... Again when I talk about these, they're recommendations for
consideration...
Lash: Well there is a trail that comes south out of the park, right? There's an access because I
remember we saw that when we went and looked at the playground location and it comes out to a
cul-de-sac.
Conversation at this point was not picked up on the tape.
Lash: Can you just point out where Lake Lucy Road is right now? Because I've lost my
bearings.
16
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Hoffman: Lake Lucy's right here.
Lash: Okay. That's where we would stop. Okay. So we could get people up through the park,
down on that, and we have access to get down to the Brendon, no up. Go up to the school. Yep.
Hoffman: ...Lake Lucy...
Lash: And we'd be able to get them from the school to the street?
Hoffman: Yep.
Mayor Mancino: And then ifHighover does have...
Lash: That'd be a much more interesting route for people to take anyway than right along Galpin.
Hoffman: Other issues on Galpin which you'll be presented on January... We've got a lot of
work to do... Dave Neiberg and I will be participating in those and they're about a half hour each
so... that first Saturday to conduct those site visits. Then in order to ensure that we've satisfied
their concern, we need time to react and incorporate that into the plans and then let them fully...
crossing at Brinker Road... There is considerable permanent easement acquisition as a part of this
trail. It's a narrow right-of-way.., those costs involved with this trail... Questions on Galpin?
Lash: I know that night at the meeting, Ron you were there weren't you? We were kicking
around the idea of you know, why we're crossing and we like the Brinker crossing better anyway
but then we discussed just having the whole thing on the west side and I can't, now, did you say
that you had some terrain issues along Kling's? Was that the deal or what?
Hoffman: Along Kling's and farther to the north and we've already started on...
Lash: I think our thinking was that it's a controlled intersection. You know right at TH 5.
You've got the stop light and anyplace else is uncontrolled. So whether there's a little thousand
foot stretch and you know at this point in time we were willing to just ignore for the long term
benefit of having a controlled intersection.
Roeser: ...Galpin across TH 5...
Lash: Well, yeah. But still you've got to cross TH 5.
Roeser: Yeah, you still...
Lash: Oh, I think it's an okay place too but I know we had talked about you know overall would
it be better to just do it at, you know have the whole thing on the west side and be done with it or,
but if it's terrain things that we can't do anything about, then.
17
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Hoffman: Well yeah, there's a variety of factors. Terrain. On these two developments.., when
those were developed we took the additional right-of-way to allow the trail to go in there and so
that's a cost savings. There's a cost savings in using the first segment of trail. We abandon it
using those costs. You go to the other side of the road, we're going to have increased easement
acquisition costs and so we're driving our budget back up again.
Audience...
Hoffman: Lake Minnewashta Regional Park will be accessed from, Lake Lucy Road I think...
connector east and west in this community. That's something we lack dearly. You leave the
center of town and you want to get to Lake Minnetonka Regional Park, you either have to choose
TH 7 or TH 5 and then cut back down in. Lake Lucy Road is going to provide a very important
east/west connector, both for pedestrian... That is the single amenity currently a lot of our
residents are cut off from that they will... We have a new, very aggressive County Park Director
who has been hired and put to work a week ago so he's already chasing dollars for us for our TH
101 trail and for this underpass. Questions? Other questions on Galpin? I think we'll try to
speed it up so we can get through the segments. Powers Boulevard. The biggest.., is from these
townhomes. It has to do with the potential loss of trees.., privacy of that area.., we looked at how
the.., we just stepped out of that meeting. Took a phone call. It was a family who lived on
Willow Creek that said, just calling to say we're going to love that trail connection to the south
and take my fence and cut down my trees. People are crazy who can't understand the value of
this thing. It raises property values. And I said, well.., we're considering stopping it at Pleasant
View so we'll see what we can do.
Lash: And we should run it all the way up there but stop it about Kerber. Kidding.
Hoffman: Just can't win. So we're working very hard with those people, the residents along
Powers. I think many of you know the story about the county mandating a 30 foot clear zone
which puts the trail right out into the trees, through the fence, in the front yard. They at least, in
initial conversations have said we will support the City of Chanhassen in moving that trail within
that clear zone, that 30 foot clear zone which is intended to protect public safety from vehicles
leaving the road. They as well are people who understand existing vegetation and those type of
things. There's a balance. There's a trade-oflk So we are proposing to move that trail out into
this ditch section, just north of... north of that we have encountered a lot of support. Very little
opposition for a trail along that side of it.
Roeser: Yeah, there's no good trees... It's the evergreens that are really...
Hoffman: There was a very good comment at the meeting about residents who live right up in
here would like to access Lake Ann with a trail system. Now they're supposed to come off of
Lake Lucy, down Powers and then take.., cross here and go down the east side and then come
up... what we feel very strongly is, about as a design team, that by aligning this on the east side of
the road.., the entire Carver Beach neighborhood... Carver Beach here. Kerber Boulevard, this
sidewalk and trail system... You can shift that to the west side of Powers. Force all those people
18
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
to take, go to Powers. Cross Powers and go either north or south on this trail. We feel that this
represents over 75% of trail easement...
Audience...
Hoffman: Recreation trail use is not just about the most convenient access. It's about making
loop sections, walking one way out and the other way back and Powers will play, it already plays
a very important role if you talk to people who live along there and watch the pedestrian flow and
activity... Powers is the, with the exception of Kerber, the most populated corridor, traveled
corridor.
Howe: The most bicycles anywhere in town.
Hoffman: Between Excelsior and.
Berg: Little kids.
Hoffman: On the east side is. More questions or comments about Powers?
Manders: Yeah, I think that road alignment on, that can't be pulled back.
Hoffman: It's not going to be supported.
Manders: There's no way that that can go through.
Hoffman: Talking with Jim Carlson with NSP right now and costs of going underground with
those power poles or else going around those, it's.., so there are some other issues to iron out.
Berg: Is there any way to make it safer? Maybe we... with a stop sign for example at Kerber and
Powers. And maybe drop the speed limit so that cars aren't as fast. Make it safer. If we have to
get it closer to the road, can we get some concession from whomever to slow down the traffic.
Hoffman: Yeah, we talked about, the residents talked that at the meeting. My reaction there, my
comment back to them was, the fact that we would have to go closer to the road with this trail and
they have a design standard for the speed limits, then how close that trail can and can't be so if
you're at 50, it needs to be farther away. If you're at 40, it can be closer. 30, etc. They're not
going to support lowering the speed limit based on the presence of the trail. I encouraged those
residents to separate those two arguments and if we as a community want to engage the County in
either traffic control or speed limits on Powers, we really need to do that outside of the context of
this trail. This is their right-of-way. We are on their turf. We're building a city trail in their right-
of-way. They hold all the cards. Many, many people are concerned about the speed limits on
Powers and when you talk to them about the formula they say, well how can, on one of them,
how can the formula work in Excelsior? You're at 30 there. Then you jump to 50. Then you go
down to 45. And so how can that be? The formula says, you need to post it as fast as cars
19
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
typically drive. So you go out there and you go with the radar gun and you clock 1,000 cars.
You pick the average. That's how fast.
Berg: That's...they go 30 in Excelsior because they have a trap there every other 15 minutes. It's
not because the...
Lash: Well the speed limit was there before they... They established the speed limits before they
ever.
Roeser: ... people are driving 55 and 60. But I know when you go into Excelsior everybody
drives 30 mph because they... Now maybe if the County were out there writing tickets on Powers
Boulevard, it might slow it down... 50 times a year and I've never seen a policeman on it.
Lash: Oh I have.
Roeser: Have you?
Lash: On the south side, they've been down there like crazy this fall.
Berg: I think one of the stronger arguments on that speed thing was where they're talking on the
south side of TH 5, you've got a split highway and they've got four there...
Hoffman: As many people wanted to talk about speed on Powers as they did the trail.
Lash: Well Galpin will be as bad as Powers once it has as much housing there.
Hoffman: You know what they'll tell you at this intersection is, a stop sign has absolutely nothing
to do with speed. Stop sign has to do with traffic congestion at the intersection. So if there is not
enough, if there are not enough vehicle movements at this intersection to warrant a stop sign,
they'll never consider it. They'll tell you it will actually... Kind of in order we move onto the
Bluff Creek trail. The Bluff Creek connection trail is the last piece of the really the first segment
of the Bluff Creek trail from Highway 5... so that's our initiation point. We travel down through
park space... Bluff Creek Estates and then... There are a couple of interesting.., hot topics... The
value you place.., you told us this trail was going to be through 4 years ago...
Lash: We've been waiting 4 years.
Hoffman: 4 years so they would like to see it go in.
Lash: However there's displeasure from the resident who's subdividing the lot.
Hoffman: Oh yes. Highway 101 connection trail. Highway 101 south. Again, the most striking
design feature in this is the crossing. Starting at Chanhassen Hills. On the lake side of the road or
on the west side of the road, and going around this S curve and 90 degree curve with... The
consultants were talking about.., guardrail at least on either side of A1 Klingelhulz's driveway.
20
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
His driveway is right at the apex of that 90 degree mm. I'd like to guardrail the entire thing but
then A1 couldn't gain access to his properly so talking about at least going... 80-90% of the danger
with guardrails. And then we travel down to the crossing at Great Plains... That's where it crosses
the lake side.., back into the east side and then to the north. West 86th, the other setting in that.
Obviously if the intersection was approved there, they said we hope the sight lines... They have a
person on staff where they will charge.., leaving the report on that because that was an issue of
discussion at the public meeting.
Lash: Tremendous support for this and also show where they'd like to see it very soon connect.
Hoffman: Lots of people, including Maury Walsh who's the.., not included because of it's...
Audience...
Lash: And we discussed if the trail goes in, when this trail goes in as proposed, even if the road
does realign, it would still make a nice trail corridor that would be not right along tat. It would
be away, which would enhance its usability but what people really were very concerned with is
trying to get in in the very near future without a referendum type issue, would be to extend it
south to Lyman and then... Lyman is being redone in the next couple of years and there would be
a hunk done along there and then we need to come down tat just to connect it to the park. So the
two sections. And then people would go from this southern section up through the park, off of
tat and make the connection through the park itself.
Hoffman: That's one of the sections that Marry is taking...
Franks: What about where it crosses back over to the east side of West 86th? The stakes are like
way up into those people's yards. Were there any comments from?
Hoffman: I talked to... generally not opposed. In fact he was in favor of the trails but he was
disgruntled about all of the activity that the properly has been faced with over the years .... roads
and trees. What he manages there, and from what the neighbors tell us... world class horses. So
he has enough headaches to deal with... Moving south to the last segment, the Lake Riley trail...
Then we moved a couple of areas.., we would like to build a trail along Pioneer. They say, well
go out to that 30 foot clear zone and you can plan your trail. So we would have to take all of
those trees, so again here we are appealing to the counly. Stay inside of that 30 foot clear zone so
we can eliminate... The last issue on Lake Riley is the connection point.., existing, what I will call
kind of a formal type of an access down the road and there's a... save $50,000.00 to $80,000.00
by not having.., much more elaborate connection...
Lash: Well this would be a benefit to the city if Eden Prairie too to connect to ours. Is it
something that we can communicate with them? See if maybe down the road we could cut a little
deal and do some cost sharing measures there?
Hoffman: ... that we provided...
21
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Lash: In their city though.
Hoffman: Yeah... continue to negotiate.
Lash: Just on the very south end of 101, I can recall there was a resident and I drive there every
day too, who was concerned about all the large evergreens there too. Right, and so that's
something we're going to try and work around too aren't we? And then up at the north stretch,
the guys with the culvert.., what did you guys come up with?
Hoffman: They drove that in fact that night and.., in fact all the trails have some of the most
exciting connections... Questions on the process. What we're looking for is for you to establish
that special meeting to review this.., where you will be presented with a formal presentation from
the consultant... Where we are at with design, alignments, working with the neighborhoods. We
will have held all of our on site meetings and then you can take public comment and we'll be
looking for a recommendation before it gets to the City Council. The following evening, on the
21st will be the same report with the Planning Commission and then move into the following week
for the first review by the City Council. As far as timing, that's what we.
Roeser: You expect to get through all six segments?
Hoffman: In one special meeting, yeah. One night. That will be a sole topic agenda.
Manders: Just that meeting then, not the following regular meeting too?
Hoffman: You'll probably have 30 to 40 minutes of formal presentation and discussion on each.
Lash: Can we start at 7:00 that night? Is everybody okay with that?
Hoffman: And then these are the details...
Audience...
Hoffman: Council has ordered a preliminary feasibility study be delivered...
Lash: Anything else? Referendum.
Hoffman: The last item is the preservation of open space. What we're into right now is a airing
out period belween the kind of the.., and the City of Chanhassen and the landowners and...
Lash: Okay. Anybody have any further comments on that? Okay. Let's move onto the next item
which is our 1998 meeting schedule.
B. 1998 MEETING SCHEDULE.
22
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Hoffman: The only change would be to take that special meeting in January from 13th to the 20th
and then take any other comments from the commission on the schedule.
Lash: Would we want to move the May one a week forward then so we're conflicting with City
Council?
Hoffman: You'd meet in two different rooms.
Lash: Right. Move it to the 19th? Does anyone have a conflict with the November one? Okay.
Is there a motion to accept this schedule with that change? The May change. Someone please.
Meger: So moved.
Lash: Is there a second?
Howe: Second.
Meger moved, Howe seconded to accept the 1998 meeting schedule for the Park and
Recreation Commission amended to change the May meeting to May 19th. All voted in
favor and the motion carried.
C. FAREWELL TO JANE MEGER~ RESIGNING MEMBER.
Lash: Okay our next sad note is our farewell to Jane. Gee just when things are getting
interesting.
Meger: Yeah, I just decided after watching this that maybe I'm not going to go.
Lash: So what, you know you're willing to help out until we find a replacement?
Hoffman: ... your formal January, regular meeting. 27th so Jane would have to stay for at least...
Meger: And that's just fine. I just thought at this point I'm spending so much time heading
north...
Lash: Are you planning on looking through the file for who we interviewed last time to contact?
Hoffman: Yep. We put the ad twice in the Villager. We'll mail it back to those candidates...
Lash: Thanks. Well we're going to miss you Jane.
COMMISSION MEMBER PRESENTATIONS: None.
ADMINISTRATIVE PACKET:
23
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Lash: Anyone besides me?
Howe: Well I saw that article. I talked to Fred about that. I mean how much did you pay her to
write that?
Lash: Okay, and that was not solicited. It truly was not solicited but is it everything that I've
been trying to say? And I just feel re-energized here, that someone else is trying to say what I'm
saying and you know for Caroline, this is her area of expertise and for me it also is my area of
expertise. However I'm tom being on the commission and trying to get the Rec Center be a
financially functioning entity and then, and it is being, it turned out to be our biggest drawing card
there. So I'm really tom in looking at the financial aspect of it, but in my heart I know we should
not be providing this activity for children this age. Every bit of my training tells me that children
who are 4 years old, 4 to 6 years old are not developmentally ready for these programs. Whether
their parents want them in there or not, and the kids think they want to be in it, they are just
developmentally not physically or emotionally ready for some of these programs. So I'll just go
on record again as saying I really am fairly opposed to the pre-school soccer and basketball
programs that we're offering and I'm glad to see someone else has voiced this concern and if
there's anyone else who has got feelings, I'd appreciate having some backing. Besides Caroline.
But I am tom. I know it's a financially thing for us and we need those programs but.
Dexter: ... and I don't know, maybe Todd will comment on it also, but I followed up with a
phone call and talked.., and from what I heard her say was that that basketball.., but on the flip
side...much of an issue with soccer. That was not as structured maybe or technical of skills... I
don't wan to say competitive but not as maybe technical is the word. And so she supported part
of it. I asked here, I said you know what could we do to maybe help you out here in, with your
comments and she said, you know she also made the comment, she said you know 4, 5 and 6 year
olds all, at those three ages do not belong together. I said, you know if we maybe just offered it to
4 and 5 year olds, are you more receptive to that? Is your concern... She said, yeah. That would
help. That there wouldn't be that range. 4 year olds and your 6 year olds... So I talked to her
about that. And then we talked a little bit about that there is the expectations of the parents is a lot
different than what the child is getting out of it. And I don't, I did not ask Caroline if she had...
Lash: She has children but not that age.
Dexter: So she was unaware that we do a letter out at the beginning of the session going over the
philosophy of the program. That we really focus on more of a socialization. Incidental learning.
Some sports though, there is going to be more skills involved. So when I asked, you know if she
had any ideas of how we could maybe.., a little bit so that we state that we don't encourage
competitiveness. There's no scoring for the team. It's a little different than ice skating but it's
an... that's very much individual. You know so we tossed out some of those ideas and when I, in
wrapping up with her I said that we do have a letter that goes out.., about the philosophy of the Y
and the City in that it's very much a socialization.., and I left it at that and said if she had.., and I
also told her, I said you know I don't believe that at any point.., feel pressured to do this. The
YMCA approached us a year ago or a year and a half ago and at that time, you know as
programmers we look at it as you know how can we... so we thought well let's go for it and I
24
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
think we were surprised that the response was as great as it is. So I told her you know that it
wasn't pressure that we were receiving to do it. On the flip side it's...
Lash: I said if we tried to cancel it at this point there'd be.
Hoffman: There may be but again, our programming is based on supply and demand. That's
how we manage it... Now here we're making a judgment on whether or not it's...
Lash: I've never seen this offered. I don't know really how it's delivered. I don't, I haven't seen
the letter that goes to parents.
Hoffman: Do you want to review that?
Lash: Yeah. That'd be a good thing for me to probably see. It might make me rest easier over
the whole.
Howe: My son took t-ball and very low key and everybody hits and everybody runs around the
bases and nobody keeps score and I thought it was well done. It's not very competitive. Now
basketball I consider a much more of a skill game. I don't think my kid could dribble a
basketball, or shoot but t-ball I thought was great and I see soccer's huge. I mean the fields are
packed.
Dexter: One of the things that, every week we have a theme. It might be like beach ball one
night. It might be camcorders another night. I don't know if you remember some in the summer.
They really try to tie in public socialization out there with 4 and 5 year olds so...
Lash: All my early childhood classes that I had, I mean the guiding rule was no games with rules
below age 7. That's it. You know until they're 6-7 year olds, they just really have difficulty
following rules and the meaning of it and feeling the pressure and not understanding what they're
doing and why they're doing it and why they're not the center of everything because that's,
they're very egocentrical at that age. And games with rules are confining and especially the team
thing. I mean we've all seen our kids play t-ball. You know if they're not up to bat or the ball is
not hit directly to them, they're not engaged in what they're doing. You know they're twirling
their hats and they're throwing their mitt in the air and they're doing, you know writing in the dirt
and they're doing whatever else they can do until it's actually their turn to do something. So they
really need to be actively involved all the time or they're not really a part of the team.
Manders: The question I would ask, in answer to the question is how self supportive are any of
these programs?
Hoffman: They make money.
Manders: To the extent that they make money and they're paying for themselves, and the parent
wants to put them in there, fine. Let them. I think we're in no position to.
25
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Lash: And this is where I'm saying I'm conflicted. You know we're offering a program that
goes contrary to everything that I've learned in the best interest of children. But the children are
doing it because the parents, because we're offering it and the parents want them involved. And
it's self supporting and it's earning us money so that's why I'm conflicted.
Berg: ... don't have any problem with the age limit on other activities, whether it be through
CAA or our regulations... I don't see how there's any difference.
Manders: I think you have a good point in terms of supply and demand. I mean if there's
obviously the demand, the supply situation gets in the way of... then I'd come over to that way of
thinking. Given that we have the supply, and there's certainly the demand, I don't have a problem
with supplying it...
Berg: Then it does become a philosophical question. We have an obligation as a commission,
knowing what we know.., do we have an obligation to look at that.., and maybe eliminate it
because.., but we do it at other age levels. We do limit things because it's going to be harmful for
kids to play hockey at this age. If it's going to be harmful to play...
Lash: They're all the parents of preschoolers. No, but they do. They have the kids in that age.
Hoffman: As long as we're airing the issues, let's get it all on the table. You know there is a
certain amount of animosity between the Athletic Associations in town and the Y being here as
well. Because what tends to happen where the CAA off'ers programs and the Y... on what they
feel. Why are they offering? What's their incentive in offering these programs?
Lash: They make money.
Hoffman: Is it because there's a need or is it because they have a strong... Then you bring the
CAA to the table and how do they feel about the YMCA being in town, taking up facilities,
offering programs... The Mayor asked a question about, well can you soften the program and I
think we can but.., providers of the program would come in and say, programs are...
Lash: Well and as much as you try to soften it and they've done that with t-ball, my kids have
been through it so you know I've been there. I even helped coach it. It's, ultimately it ends up
being the parents and as much as you can try to soften it, it's only as soft as the parents will allow
it to be. And eventually it gets, the parents get like this and then the kids get like this and then
pretty soon coaches are, I was out yelling at a guy out at second base one time you know. I mean
it's the nature of the game. You get caught up in it. Well the guy was a, you know, he wasn't
coaching appropriately. But it's unfortunate but that happens and then that's the kind of stuff that
the kids get wrapped up in and as much as you don't keep score and you don't count outs and you
don't do all of that, the kids do. If you talk to the kids at the game, they know if they got out.
They know if they made it home. They know ultimately who won, as much as the parents keep
saying it was a tie, it was a tie, it was a tie. The kids keep track because they know in baseball
there's a winner and there's a loser and they've seen it on TV and they know. They keep track. I
saw it year after year. It happened. As much as we try, it just doesn't ever seem like there's too
26
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
much you can do. But maybe this is, it gets to be definitely a philosophical debate that could
probably go on forever but maybe it's food for thought that we can bring up as some of these
seasons open up again.
Meger: I have, my 5 year old is going to... so then I'll be very interested to watch. His big thing
is he wants to get in the gym and just be able to dribble around. That's what he wants to do so it
will be interesting to see.
Audience...
Lash: Okay. I don't think we did either but I think it can be continued another night.
Hoffman: ... it will just lay until you bring it up again.
Lash: Yeah. Are there any other?
Howe: Two more things. One more thing. This is less controversial. Adult volleyball. Who is
going to play in the Park and Rec team? Any interest here? Seriously.
Berg: What's the commitment time wise?
Howe: Looks like Wednesday night.
Hoffman: Nine weeks.
Howe: I don't know what times are. Any interest yet?
Ruegemer: Yeah, we're getting some phone calls...
Howe: If we have enough people you know you can miss some games. What is it, it's 6 people?
We need more women. Can you fill in for us?
Berg: Clearly recreational?
Howe: Yeah. I'm not going to be...
Meger: ...unless I get to win.
Manders: I already play Wednesday nights so... I'd play but.
Howe: All right. Ron, would you play?
Roeser: Let me know when it's going down, yeah.
Berg: Yeah, church night but I'll get away.
27
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Howe: Jan?
Lash: No.
Howe: No?
Lash: No, I might break a nail and then I'd cry .... water volleyball, that's it. Otherwise I hate
volleyball.
Howe: I've got to rethink this and I'll get back to you all. The other thing I wanted to say about
the Rec Center, about dribbling around the gym is, I told maybe Patty this the other day. Or
someone at the breakfast, maybe Jerry. I rented the gym with a bunch of men from my
neighborhood to play basketball the last Saturday in November and we have 12 men and half of
these guys, and they live in one of the circles of that Rec Center, had never been there and they
loved it. I was shocked and they wanted to come back so we're going to start a regular thing
where we'll rent the gym once a month but they'd never seen the place and they were walking
around and what a great place and I really couldn't believe that there are people who live that
close to that kind of facility and didn't use it. Or had never seen the inside of it, so I'm not, just a
comment. They'll be customers now.
Hoffman: Try to get them.
Howe: I'll get them.
Hoffman: Good. Great, thank you.
Lash: Anyone else?
Hoffman: I'd like to echo Mayor Mancino's comments on your participation level and also...
support the commission. Often times you think you operate here in vacuum and a bubble. If you
recall a couple years back Jan Lash ordered a statewide report on commission participation and
we had that same banquet here this past Friday up... and we talked to some Park and Rec
Commissioners from St. Louis Park. Communities that.., and we discussed how engaged and
active this commission is. You remain one of the envies of the metropolitan area as far as park...
so I think if you're ever wondering, are we doing a good job? That's known but are you active
and are you participating I think...
Audience...
Hoffman: Yeah, the real hard facts are Ashworth, Aanenson, Folch, and Hoffman at least at staff
level.., and my argument will not include a great deal about traffic studies except I will comment
on how I feel both businesses and residents would access that part of...
Lash: Any show of hands of... ?
28
Park & Rec Commission Meeting - December 9, 1997
Audience...
Howe: I'd like to make it. I'll try.
Lash: I'll commit.
Roeser: I'm not sure yet.
Hoffman: 6:30 back here. Actually it starts at 5:30... secondary topic if you're at all interested
in... preservation will I think so I'm sure it will come up... keep thinking about it...
Lash: Isn't it going to be the, science, what are we talking about?
Mayor Mancino: Interpretative center.
Lash: Interpretative center, there you go. That's the word I'm looking for.
Howe moved, Roeser seconded to adjourn the meeting. All voted in favor and the motion
carried.
Submitted by Todd Hoffman
Park & Rec Director
Prepared by Nann Opheim
29