Loading...
Agenda and Packet (2) 2019 Commissions Interview Schedule FIRST MEETINGS IN APRIL: Planning Commission - April 2, 2018 Environmental Commission - April 10, 2019 Senior Commission - April 18, 2019 Park & Rec Commission - April 23, 2019 City Council InterviewsEnvironmental Commission Interviews - February 13 February 25 (Monday):6:00Brian Smith (PRC 2nd Choice) 8:00Bhakti Modi (SC)6:15Ross Reeves (PRC 2nd Choice) 8:15Alice "Lisa" Lyon (SC)6:30 8:306:45Andrew Allen-NO SHOW 8:45Gerald Cook (PC)7:00Jeff Harken 9:00Laura Skistad (PC & PRC) 9:15 Planning Commission Interviews - February 19 9:30Andrew Aller (PC incumbent-coming from airport may be earlier)1stAntonio J. Fricano (SC 2nd Choice) 2ndBala Chintaginjala-NO SHOW WITHDRAWN February 26 (Tuesday): 3rdDouglas Reeder (PRC 2nd Choice) 5:00Sandy Sweetser (PRC)4thGerald Cook 5:15Bill Hickey (PRC)5thLynn Pelto WITHDRAWN Annette Stock-Lind 5:30Natalia Sander (PC-NO SHOW AT PC INTERVIEW) WITHDRAWN 6th 5:45Laurie Susla (PC)7thNatalia Sander-NO SHOW 6:00Jeff Harken (EC)8thJohn Kunitz 6:15Lynn Pelto (PC) WITHDRAW 9thLaurie Susla 6:30Steve Weick (PC incumbent)10thLaura Skistad (PRC 2nd Choice) 6:45Annette Stock Lind (PC) 7:00BREAKSenior Commission Interviews - February 21 7:15Rick Echternacht (PRC incumbent)4:10Ruth Lunde 7:30Cole Kelly (PRC incumbent)4:30Jim Camarata 7:45Haley Pemrick (PRC)4:50Alice "Lisa" Lyon 8:00Drew Allen (EC-NO SHOW AT EC INTERVIEW)5:10Bhakti Modi 8:15Brian Smith (EC & PRC)5:30Mike Schachterle 8:30Antonio Fricano (PC & SC)5:50Antonio Fricano (PC 1st Choice) 8:45Ruth Lunde (SC) 9:00Jim Camarata (SC)Park & Rec Commission Interviews - February 26 5:45Bill Hickey March 11 6:00Laura Skistad 4:30Doug Reeder (PC & PRC)6:15Sandy Sweetser 4:45John Kunitz (PC)6:30Doug Reeder 5:00Bill Chappell (EC incumbent)6:45Ross Reeves 5:15Mike Schachterle (SC)7:00Brian Smith 5:30Ross Reeves (EC & PRC)7:15Haley Pemrick 5:45Matt Kutz (PRC-OUT OF COUNTRY FOR PRC INTERVIEW) 6:00Discuss Commission Appointments Incumbents All commission appointments will take place at the March 11, 2019 City Council Meeting \[4\] ARTICLE IV. - BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS Footnotes: --- (4) --- Cross reference—Park and recreation commission, § 14-16 et seq.; planning commission, § 15-16 et seq. State Law reference—Authority to establish advisory boards and commissions, M.S. § 412.621(2). DIVISION 1. - GENERALLY Sec. 2-46. - Appointment to city committees and commissions. All vacancies on committees, commissions, and boards shall be advertised to seek applicants. The city council may interview applicants before making appointment. With the exception of the housing and redevelopment authority, all appointments shall be by majority vote of the city council. Once appointed, an applicant shall serve until removed, with or without cause, by a four-fifths vote of the city council, until the expiration of the term of appointment and following appointment of the applicant's successor. Vacancies during a term shall be filled for the unexpired portion of the term. Sec. 2-46.01. - Same—Generally. The council determines the duties and exercises the powers of administrative boards or commissions. However, the council may establish boards or commissions as set forth in this article to investigate subjects or to perform quasi-judicial functions. Additional administrative boards or commissions shall be established as required by law or for the administration of a municipal function jointly shared with another political subdivision. (Ord. No. 363, § 4, 1-12-04) Sec. 2-46.03. - Planning commission. (a)Commission established.The planning commission is established pursuant to the Minnesota Municipal Planning Act, and has the powers and duties assigned to it by that Act, by this Code, and state law. The planning commission is hereby designated the planning agency of the city pursuant to the Municipal Planning Act. (b)Membership.The planning commission consists of seven members appointed in the manner set forth in this subsection. Members of the commission are appointed by the council for staggered terms of three years,expiring on March 31 of each year. (c)Officers; meetings.The chairperson and vice chairperson of the planning commission are appointed by the commission from among its membership for the term of one year. The commission shall adopt its own bylaws with the approval of the city council. All members of the commission may vote on all questions before the commission. No member of the commission may vote on any question in which the member has fiduciary interest, either directly or indirectly. The commission shall determine in its bylaws the date and time of its meetings and shall set such public hearings as are necessary and desirable, or as required by law or this Code. Page 1 (d)Powers and duties.The planning commission shall have the powers and duties allowed under state law, including: (1)To prepare a comprehensive plan for the future development of the city that is submitted to the council for implementation and to recommend amendments of the plan to the council from time to time as may be necessary or desirable. (2)To initiate, direct, and review, from time to time, a study of the provisions of the zoning code and the subdivision regulations and to report to the council its advice and recommendations with respect thereto. (3)To study applications and proposals for amendments to the zoning code and applications for special permits and to advise the council of its recommendations thereon. (4)To study preliminary plats and to advise the council of its recommendations thereof. (5)To act in an advisory capacity to the council in all matters wherein powers are assigned to the council by state law concerning comprehensive planning, zoning, platting, changes in streets, and other matters of a general planning nature. (e)Reports.The commission shall make an annual written report to the council, not later than March 31 of each calendar year, containing the commission's recommendations for the ensuing year. (Ord. No. 363, § 5, 1-12-04) Sec. 2-46.05. - Park and recreation commission. (a)Creation.There is established a park and recreation commission for the city. (b)Membership.The park and recreation commission consists of seven members appointed in the manner set forth in this subsection. Members of the commission are appointed by the council for staggered terms of three years expiring on March 31 of each year. Additionally, the commission may also have one or two youth representatives who shall also be voting members. Youth representatives shall be appointed for one-year terms. (c)Officers; meetings.The chairperson and vice chairperson of the park and recreation commission are appointed by the commission from among its membership for the term of one year. The commission shall adopt its own bylaws with the approval of the city council. All members of the commission may vote on all questions before the commission. No member of the commission may vote on any question in which the member has fiduciary interest, either directly or indirectly. The commission shall determine in its bylaws the date and time of its meetings and shall set such public hearings as are necessary and desirable or as required by law or this Code. (d)Powers and duties.The park and recreation commission shall have the following powers and duties: (1)To hold meetings of its members, to consider such matters pertaining to parks and public recreation programs in the city as shall be referred to the commission by the council, or as the members of the commission themselves deem proper. (2)To prepare a comprehensive plan for the future development of the city park and recreation system, to be submitted to the city council for implementation, and to maintain said plan, and recommend amendments of the plan to the city council, as may become necessary or desirable. (3)To act in an advisory capacity to the council in all matters relating to park and recreation in the city. (e)Reports.The commission shall make an annual written report to the council, not later than March 31 of each calendar year, containing the commission's recommendations for the ensuing year. (Ord. No. 363, § 6, 1-12-04; Ord. No. 582, § 1, 4-22-13) Page 2 Sec. 2-46.07. - Board of adjustments and appeals. Pursuant to M.S. § 462.354, a board of adjustments and appeals is hereby established. The planning commission shall serve as the board of adjustments and appeals. (Ord. No. 363, § 7, 1-12-04) Sec. 2-46.09. - Environmental commission. (a)Commission established.The environmental commission is established to provide the residents of Chanhassen with opportunities to improve the quality of their environment, address issues that affect the city's natural resources, provide environmental education to the public, bring a comprehensive perspective to environmental issues, and advocate the benefits and necessity of Chanhassen's natural resources. (b)Membership.The environmental commission consists of seven members appointed in the manner set forth in this subsection. Members of the commission are appointed by the council for staggered terms of three years expiring on March 31 of each year. (c)Officers; meetings.The chairperson and vice chairperson of the environmental commission are appointed by the commission from among its membership for the term of one year. The commission shall adopt its own bylaws with the approvalof the city council. All members of the commission may vote on all questions before the commission. No member of the commission may vote on any question in which the member has fiduciary interest, either directly or indirectly. The commission shall determine in its bylaws the date and time of its meetings and shall set such public hearings as are necessary and desirable or as required by law or this Code. (d)Powers and duties.The environmental commission has the following powers and duties: (1)The environmental commission shall serve as an advisory body to the city council and planning commission in addressing the needs of the environment as directed by the city council. All final decisions are to be made by the city council. (2)The environmental commission will consider and make recommendations at the direction of the city council regarding environmental issues. (3)The environmental commission will make recommendations at the direction of the city council regarding funding for environmental projects. (4)The environmental commission may propose studies to the city council and make recommendations according to the results. (5)The environmental commission will coordinate services with other governmental and private agencies for related issues. (e)Reports.The environmental commission shall make an annual written report to the council, not later than March 31 of each calendar year, containing the commission's recommendations for the ensuing year. (Ord. No. 363, § 8, 1-12-04) Sec. 2-46.11. - Senior commission. (a)Commission established.The senior commission serves as an advisory body to the city council in addressing the special needs of people over age 55 living in Chanhassen. They consider and make recommendations to the city council regarding the special needs of seniors in the areas of transportation, information and assistance, independent living in the home, social and recreational Page 3 programs, senior center and senior housing, but are not limited to these issues. All final decisions are made by the city council. (b)Membership.The senior commission consists of seven or eight members appointed in the manner set forth in this subsection. Members of the commission are appointed by the council for staggered terms of three years, expiring on March31 of each year. (c)Officers; meetings.The chairperson and vice chairperson of the senior commission are appointed by the commission from among its membership for the term of one year. The commission shall adopt its own bylaws with the approval of the city council. All members of the commission may vote on all questions before the commission. No member of the commission may vote on any question in which the member has fiduciary interest, either directly or indirectly. The commission shall determine in its bylaws the date and time of its meetings and shall set such public hearings as are necessary and desirable or as required by law or this Code. (d)Powers and duties.The senior commission shall have the following powers and duties: (1)They make recommendations to the city council regarding funding for special services to be provided for citizens over age 55. (2)They may propose needs studies for this age group where necessary and make recommendations to the city council based on the results. (3)They coordinate services with other governments and private agencies for this age group. (e)Reports.The commission shall make an annual written report to the council, not later than the last day of March of each calendar year, containing the commission's recommendations for the ensuing year. (Ord. No. 363, § 9, 1-12-04; Ord. No. 581, § 1, 4-8-13) Sec. 2-46.15. - Resignations and removal from commissions. Commissioners may resign voluntarily or may be removed from office by a majority vote of the city council. Vacancies on any advisory board or commission shall be filled by appointment with a majority vote of the city council. Vacancies shall be announced in the city's official newspaper and posted within city hall. Applications shall be available at the city clerk's office and shall be forwarded to the city council within the time prescribed. (Ord. No. 363, § 10, 1-12-04) Sec. 2-46.17. - Compensation. Commissioners shall serve without compensation. (Ord. No. 363, § 11, 1-12-04) Secs. 2-47—2-55. - Reserved. \[5\] DIVISION 2. - HOUSING AND REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY Footnotes: --- (5) --- Page 4 State Law reference—Creation of city housing and redevelopment authority, M.S. § 469.003. Sec. 2-56. - Authority to adopt housing plan, issue bonds, etc. The city economic development authority is authorized to exercise on behalf of the city all of the powers conferred by M.S. §§ 462C.01 to 462C.08, including without limitation, the power to adopt a housing plan and program and to issue and sell mortgage revenue bonds for single family housing. (Ord. No. 75, 11-7-83; Ord. No. 363, § 12, 1-12-04) Secs. 2-57—2-65. - Reserved. \[6\] DIVISION 3. - RESERVED Footnotes: --- (6) --- Editor's note—Ord. No. 363, § 13, adopted Jan. 12, 2004, repealed Div. 3, which pertained to the public safety commissions and derived from Ord. No. 70-B, §§ 1.01, 3.02, 4.02, 5.01, and 6.01, adopted Oct. 1, 1984; Ord. No. 166, §§ 1 and 2, adopted Apr. 27, 1992; Ord. No. 268, § 1, adopted May 12, 1997; and Ord. No. 298, § 2, adopted Feb. 14, 2000. Secs. 2-66—2-71. - Reserved. Page 5 INTERVIEW SCORING SHEET 5=High/1=Low Name Years Lived in Knowledge Commitment Knowledge of Involvement in Total Chanhassenof Community to Position Major Issues CommunityPoints Doug Reeder (PC & PRC) John Kunitz(PC) Bill Chappell (EC incumbent) Mike Schachterle (SC) Ross Reeves (EC & PRC) Matt Kutz (PRC) 2019 Commissions Interview Schedule FIRST MEETINGS IN APRIL: Planning Commission - April 2, 2018 Environmental Commission - April 10, 2019 Senior Commission - April 18, 2019 Park & Rec Commission - April 23, 2019 City Council InterviewsEnvironmental Commission Interviews - February 13 February 25 (Monday):6:00Brian Smith (PRC 2nd Choice) 8:00Bhakti Modi (SC)6:15Ross Reeves (PRC 2nd Choice) 8:15Alice "Lisa" Lyon (SC)6:30 8:306:45Andrew Allen-NO SHOW 8:45Gerald Cook (PC)7:00Jeff Harken 9:00Laura Skistad (PC & PRC) 9:15 Planning Commission Interviews - February 19 9:30Andrew Aller (PC incumbent-coming from airport may be earlier)1stAntonio J. Fricano (SC 2nd Choice) 2ndBala Chintaginjala-NO SHOW WITHDRAWN February 26 (Tuesday): 3rdDouglas Reeder (PRC 2nd Choice) 5:00Sandy Sweetser (PRC)4thGerald Cook 5:15Bill Hickey (PRC)5thLynn Pelto WITHDRAWN Annette Stock-Lind 5:30Natalia Sander (PC-NO SHOW AT PC INTERVIEW) WITHDRAWN 6th 5:45Laurie Susla (PC)7thNatalia Sander-NO SHOW 6:00Jeff Harken (EC)8thJohn Kunitz 6:15Lynn Pelto (PC) WITHDRAW 9thLaurie Susla 6:30Steve Weick (PC incumbent)10thLaura Skistad (PRC 2nd Choice) 6:45Annette Stock Lind (PC) 7:00BREAKSenior Commission Interviews - February 21 7:15Rick Echternacht (PRC incumbent)4:10Ruth Lunde 7:30Cole Kelly (PRC incumbent)4:30Jim Camarata 7:45Haley Pemrick (PRC)4:50Alice "Lisa" Lyon 8:00Drew Allen (EC-NO SHOW AT EC INTERVIEW)5:10Bhakti Modi 8:15Brian Smith (EC & PRC)5:30Mike Schachterle 8:30Antonio Fricano (PC & SC)5:50Antonio Fricano (PC 1st Choice) 8:45Ruth Lunde (SC) 9:00Jim Camarata (SC)Park & Rec Commission Interviews - February 26 5:45Bill Hickey March 11 6:00Laura Skistad 4:30Doug Reeder (PC & PRC)6:15Sandy Sweetser 4:45John Kunitz (PC)6:30Doug Reeder 5:00Bill Chappell (EC incumbent)6:45Ross Reeves 5:15Mike Schachterle (SC)7:00Brian Smith 5:30Ross Reeves (EC & PRC)7:15Haley Pemrick 5:45Matt Kutz (PRC-OUT OF COUNTRY FOR PRC INTERVIEW) 6:00Discuss Commission Appointments Incumbents All commission appointments will take place at the March 11, 2019 City Council Meeting 2018 Planning Commission Attendance Record Percentage of July 3 May 1 June 5 April 3 July 17 May 15 June 19 April 17 Attendance March 6 August 7 Otober 2 January 2 March 20 August 21 January 16February 6 October 16 February 20 December 4 November 6 September 4 November 20 September 18 Andrew Aller 1111111111111193% 4/10 - 4/19 Mark Undestad 0000110111001147% 4/5 - 4/20 Steven Weick 1010111110110167% 4/13 - 4/19 John Tietz 1111111101011180% 4/15 - 4/20 Mark Randall 1101101111111180% 6/16 - 4/21 Michael McGonagill 1110011101047% 4/18 - 4/21 Nancy Madsen 1111111111111193% 4/15 - 4/19 Total Attended54040050076506606556060 Number of meetings to 15 date: red means no meeting PARK & RECREATIONCOMMISSION APPLICATIONS SUMMARY PARK & RECREATION COMMISSION – 2019 Terms Expiring: Cole Kelly (Reapplied) COMMISSIONCOUNCIL Rick Echternacht (Reapplied) RANK RANK Steve Scharfenburg (Resigning with one year left in his term) Grant Schaeferle (Youth Representative-no longer eligible) Cole Kelly, 1556 Bluebill Trail1 Rick Echternacht, 8746 Flamingo Drive 2 Sandy Sweetser, 9132 Springfield Drive 3 Applicants Haley Pemrick,7608 Erie Avenue4 Bill Hickey, 6301 Elm Tree Avenue--- Matt Kutz, 1080 Lyman Court--- Brian Smith, 7610 Great Plains Blvd. Apt. 201 5 st (EC 1 choice) Ross Reeves, 8471 Swan Court --- st (EC 1 choice) Alternate Douglas Reeder, 590 Broken Arrow Road --- st Applicants (PC 1choice) Laura Skistad, 2284 Stone Creek Lane West --- st (PC 1choice) Natalia Sander, 6671 Amberwood Lane (WITHDRAWN) --- Youth None --- Applicants First Ranked by: April 23 Meeting Steve Scharfenberg, Meredith Petouvis, and Karl Tsuchiya, in April Vacancies Two3-Year Terms/ One 1-Year Terms 1. 3-Year Terms (2) 2. 1-Year Term 1. (1) g:\\commission\\2019\\park & recreation commission matrix.docx ENVIRONMENTALCOMMISSION APPLICATIONS SUMMARY ENVIRONMENTALCOMMISSION – 2019 Terms Expiring: COMMISSION COUNCIL Bill Chappell (Reapplied) RANK RANK Wayne Benbow Bill Chappell, 8736 Stonefield Lane (Incumbent)1 Jeff Harken, 7020 Derby Drive 2 Brian Smith 3 Applicants Ross Reeves 4 Drew Allen5 Alternate None--- Applicants Ranked by: Environmental Commissioners Keith Butcher, Don Vasatka, First April 10 Greg Hawks, Wayne Benbow, and Kristin Fulkerson. Rachel Popken was Meeting absent. in April Vacancies Two3-Year Terms 1. 3-Year Terms (2) 2. g:\\commission\\2019\\environmental commission matrix.docx SENIORCOMMISSION APPLICATIONS SUMMARY SENIOR COMMISSION – 2019 Terms Expiring: COMMISSION COUNCIL Jackie Engel RANK RANK Cheryl Ayotte Jim Camarata, 6340 Oxbow Bend1 Ruth Lunde, 6721 Hopi Road3 Alice “Lisa” Lyon, 889 Kimberly Lane4 Applicants Bhakti Modi, 8663 Flamingo Drive 5 Mike Schachterle, 2852 Century Trail 6 Antonio Fricano, 980 Lake Lucy Road Alternate 2 st (PC 1choice) Applicants Ranked by: Senior Commissioners Barbara Nevin, Jerry Cerchia, and First April 18 Mack Titus. Commissioners Dorina Tipton and Carol Buesgens were Meeting absent. in April Vacancies Three 3-Year Terms 1. 3-Year Terms 2. (3) 3. NOTE: The Senior Commission has the option to appoint a total of 7 or 8 commissioners per Section 2.46-11 (b) of the City Code. g:\\commission\\2019\\senior commission matrix.docx 2018-2019SENIOR COMMISSION ATTENDANCE RECORD AprMayJuneJulyAugSeptOctNovDecJanFebMarPercent of Commissioner 201815201620191521182115Meetings Attended Dorina A. Tipton XX X XXXX 100% Cheryl AyotteXXXAXXA71% Carol BuesgensXXXXXXA85% Barbara NevinXX X XXXX 100% Mack TitusXX X AXXX 85% NO MEETINGNO MEETINGNO MEETINGNO MEETING Jackie Engel XX X XXXX 100% Jerry Cerchia XX X XXXX 100% \\\\cfs5\\cfs5\\shared_data\\plan\\sj\\sc\\attendance\\2018.docx Potential Property Acquisition ta ewash Minn rk hts Pa Heig S t a t e H w y 7 A d a r o Town Line Road b 7R y w H o te W. 62nd Sta .ta S t.k W.62ndS s ane Lilac L 7 Hwy a Lilac Lanee ate llyLan St Ho Ch d C S Sta te Hw vC a y 7 Circle W de a tadec s r e aa ra scPC C asa rb cs taes B s wa wh C yr d e t n ra e ba a n L ap y ey B Ca r r n ao y rs y b Cto tu r e e t yw C rl at r e L eL iKoehne ly n Circle East l R v r uR a L r o H a cDriv o he A nto u n o le m g ta eer e Christmas e a l d n Dk re d er n o iaa Le vrd i a i l c r R K ro e Ov Nh ta Cir E OShas a O BN W RKoehnen Circle WestA W En t Hummingbird Road onr ad Hi lin dm R ieC s IPC alP e lie t hd Lra mLanoa kouat DeTr C t ns dro er Cr as ti Lpa FaR e H1 aLh ah r ke ic Lake Virginia ca A w La nS tor s s ha LC O Naa r LP kym wa GC Ed ue oTs r lnrapper s nl ri ie a eH ie d war W re o rr) t ahSoms c 7 mer Gs a w eaterC C e M C o he euo Ty B P e y oRon y OHW 932.77 R a ev oY Ta1 nRrl iaMo d av r L w dra e s C ea0 ood Lane o Pipew e Jbd s ove w d 1 et g H r c Cir oi mpi nhu Oly L aiv dn os i ie(i a ae e wdC nt d t erAu na Re lL s ivlu u s r wpe wtG a.so Ai r aDr Oe ssDtR iM t rirBA urtMu lek Ashton Coa orl Me Vor tc v ee xee .PC e g dM r bc e id a gsen1 lR e o et l a7 tt dlWest 63rd St ws OHW 929.8 o P ey sa nWest 1 n63rd St) od gC i Sta a Sel Ba oye o Hp T uorn R pB n i H)m F n i Lanea el r W7 l i Pleasant View RoadCs l mv r nlo Mi da 1 d l is ina B ina t esht1 t waMCP L l Ce a y l h Clasen . v ry R e i r a Bid T cd d re s t tg r.a ol on ee l n D ieMelody Hill C C MelodyHillr earMoun WeNta (vino di v o nM aB heasanu ea PtyCl e CMountain Wayv .r veS d ri t D iw re r nhoM Sd eo i e h avl t o w S l hd Murray Hill Crt P oy td L x r e o T Bn F D e tr PiadH e rve d d sB u Herman e en na Lak ne i TetonLa oi B o b P d l Oxbow e o ol C ol lw w i ge P sR n T wa PPlea isant veLC omView ol lRoa enbd Road l bPleasant View ee e ax rgi nr Tsr id O i a s e Rr k p CD catH iH r B id uo lR FieldPark VPleasantView s Ciewi r DCRoad l P tgy l n i n r o d i a a an dL o nR nik i PBj anc o LPar o Piptridge Cu i ewoodC 7 ir no W rR e ut t aen a y e ia l L k hd td n e M r a o i L n t r o eWc vo ou idD D r eW k P a Curry r v y F a s r o a D a e t t xno n t e ra t65thStreete Wes i P S o o h n kD P da o x FarmsPark s L s r r Ki nao Cvw a oe tI a onF h i d e eiy t a C e D r n g d i r s H R il t a r T i ulFG e it ol hB C Pheasant R W x o odtHunters ll l For wDrivewDrive Wllo v o uourt CH Nez hP eo Di t d fxt oe eyTfC veo nC i e e u M CerlF P n Li Ll ieurtD(o i ie rStrattonCotD p n B dir r s C e ne elw w nw r Crestvie r C i aenF i o r ov c hl l. e CresLdoGl dtviW ews R Dr x lo ner Ce w H i L. H roCy v d a Hill Lo k d 1 aCx Cr R est tiF view De hrl r eelo mo D 7 cl L Pi hPw ddolaloF ac P u cex )H e c S D i y VinelandCnr ou i rv L t atae i u a a d n F o C e xn d North y I P aG Park ta h o e . u R t P s r aG r ray lw t e Ci ne CharingiFox a V d C Curv u t CRoad a cy Bend u n L na e La s dkke o Luc Ly R aoad ) L t Vs N r r e lu 7 i eos D C Foxtail Lak wPi 1e Luc wty Roa n d Lotus s 1 g r R . i o ) h a P R d eC d r. e r vsmn ti rvE. LM ie C t wb ed ue( Den v g sra a e Cr L.p le w v e iLake ( Crestview Drd Lucy Ro poow adQ ed u i v B er lo D v r D eLl r Co yr Lake r r M d c t e eB D u sn sL lo n yL r aNGraF i nby d eNaGrey p i ee ea o D vp kFox e ker av el i l Lze e awurv Maple Cir rC r ena Hr r n P dC oD a e l eev e a D G p C rn D e vtCr ru i L iv c e n MrRC r iiDee e lo t d Doc ekih De s l Pna e yw Park e Lake rr s Glendale D ir rive avah Wwo T e Ma sH h w s o P e uu k Shenandt oahMr l a boo L Hi Western Drive dghg L ate LH a Ci ar r k y ale DriveR Glend y y c L a w L C e t c r k ce v aL lr eu u Park w L u d C d c a k y Eo e r o t R o Hiawatha DrR a o h er a Carv R e es d P e o Country Oaks Drive li s V t S k Minnewashta a o Lake C Lak arver eLu CH cyR oad e h .t a t a y e e r P B ch tC HCarverBeachRoad ea Bea ch Carv er Beach o Road n d Ca v D w e u r n o r o o e e P layground e c D v a Cwr l i P r ris y HCa r ae r C lla e g rDim e M hrB n r h St Ltratfoge o k ardRidr Par co n a l eB Halv lgren C d nn p t u d r d d ad a R oY Cree Drive v ou r feCree Drive l b e u t yy r M h (n n ae L m B a aaC a l r gn L ie ta Lr y R . i Regional H u R a S bd cD i ynC n Stratford LnR g g r . ieC eio l ie tv a r g 1 T dieDh er Higov e h e m 7 war ni C n iv a e Uc e)Pre Pr ln a t n u tgImperial Dra k c L r r ee taw i m e e Ci a n r t c Lane ta White Oak Minnewash C r r i i Tar c le )C p c i o t 7Tp u n rP r t E 1 mU ea C re S aln dLa a 1 z i z . c lD N eR rive derosa D a Pon .rive erosa D r Pond o a C ( r e r . s N d s Park o Lo etu s T arail v nv l R aa a B j a L Nd o Lane RedOakO Lake vn t i i D r Lone Eagle Dr r y p r l u C Lotus tD a R r Roundho use G e OHW 944.5 u r v N o r e e H D z w o Pr i r C ToA g pa Park o z Dn rive e rk hh cro eB go C i t v Kerb H n er Blvd a r ison L W Harr Woodhill Dr Ker aber B y l v d r h Kings Road Kings Road(County Park)s D S t m nr r D l ul Ri La H x o e F d k M T eyH do no e va ik S s n o eW R g y re htod 993.6 an OHW y rSH L gC n o h id ao Cs g o nn i lC n ae K w l d ig e e L R a a N e r M d r b n Preakness Lane a Preakne a e s l Lake Lucy L r L L ia a n n a e k a L e c n i B tL igWBlvd oods i C Rn e s n d C B Ue eeR o eh d a n l e r n v a C a y t o d L v r L e ir Hickory Rd n C e C OHW 9 t 56.1 S s n H eo aa c i d c nlte e h mo g ille i H o w rrisonk HaP C v ev i s H aa Lake eT Py onr w nti d r rta ChcD HD D a e rh L Sa a n i L e c C r ao i nr R ti k ero l bukC e nry o Circle do a C r N e y m d a e Jdn r La R cy P ntia uePo o b o i n nRr e ood ta reenw v G e Ri o i r J St p dD o a D s e P d e r Lc onga o rrive D A tn Arrow- a L r i v edCed t Rar a Po in n tt rn e R oBigho c on a head i d lmo n et C u B u Ct G Park i Shores ner a eLCheyenne cC a e ticc U v a iti t r nC c o n D d Pl e L o w ) e g dr Meadow n i7 i c k a 1 a u ee 1 B v iP d rh. e n Da v i roR er o . a D d c r eo C a o ( C r p C h. tAT e c u Gunflint dt ia Pont oH Green i t ve S r i Crt d C l n Rx r eo i dF n oBT r f a eil iLw n n Di WillowVie ad w rn sBigho u C p ev rl l c v G aa OHW g B nG o o w Park L d e a iv r o D s re R riMapleSo edl kHi e t 2 a 945.a r i i L dlB ut teT l urt sCo P s r lP e e s S Conea v stog r Ci Loe u u o o K r T n na w i gt n t Ta nad ooneC a Drae iveo Cu M 1 er ct d a v r i rDd p ey D e sa e r cBrH u an L gS ae w t n n o DL r r H in vD eg T t r dr i vo Bl Ri Let a Lake tr ae es gT k ed rir rook bs eTe wlr a d dil a e S y r v i d Tr r i Lake e ai r D c C S l Re l l l o i d H H L e u r a kn a Basswood Cir t e e L rD rtrive7 idr d RCa gM W F o e c FrontierTr c ailu s aS r t s wv Tanado i ona Drive n R a T e r. o l d d o Ann d R ( l D l.e i w a r d i h Hawthorne Cir r v t L et l k o u n )e r g i nR s Bs r a o cc Cuk g d Mo a i d W P v n e T s i i t R we r o ay i o W d p Cactusw ca Highland Drive Bi D lt Highland Drive es OHW 955.5 t r aj M i C n urve l a OHW 896.3 l C n K G i e r nv r c u F B C l o a e H o l n w Ht rk i llC a o e h ugarbus S v Fo i d r 7 r 7b T D r F i s ti inhe r Dl D o ri ve C S n im d aircle drronC oW tL et i B r e ia g Park a L ot r r i rS wtn r T 7d 7C ths Seo t r C a m u op n i C l Ci c g d i li o l o o l e t u tq r R D dT a g t C r dr Chippewa Ciru d a i t o i s iv rBrinker S SC treet r e e i R C t n t o r a e Del Rio DriveF s o n L a ra re a e id r oL gL a oh C F n C o e S t t R W a o r ad n S lae S vir ar y t io eaa g o ra wL Dell Road Highwood Dr n T r Pve o l r on Cu i Cany i n l r tCurve aln Wu t C u R rve aDrive er V i e l da i na Tr a tury g r aw d t n ee ae te Si v t p Ci i . rn e p te yi we r Fr Ch u W tF W F .C s n 7 a n 8 ea e ta Lak n t Le t i Cyn h n .go i l d a a e la aS i l S v Su lya lS i l VDen P n r a t i a V B Fee r Trail ota Vrt Minnes m P ArboretumV s illW eu ageh rmot C y u t arourC rct rC A t ernr v e t e ma v e C v e gu Tilo e o o r ru r t t tC te rLr ley oS Ci l o r ul C l e n ti h D brv e H V eF r G o b ee A h DellRoad b Cr v u cg w i r t S t anr ei h et Lo A r o Dr a K eD o C P B tA u b eO r rl scape eR Land v i Q C r mL tI A e SA v Villar n lR ge Cirril li t orN P u H W R r 76th h y s Ann St DE c Cirn1 aeDT V o B d y aS l C n rrE e v r rt b P li e erW r v re o y l& a West V Village Roadue W h S st t saC oE a H I sly IS y Way l rEe e trT W eberBaneberryI e Ban K C m oe niC n i y err WaEqN a nE tus I Village Crt A S Lo rbo et Su Blvd o uml W d oretum Vi Arb SoT hS oout S H aea Bl a vi i s r u n o e a a a n A l rr ru elo a w o w oCvTh R flhicor k T neyWay ic t oB N n l Co e iW i u r y K o 7s a8 l a S it e ch n l a e Lak L m BS d elv n g u a t B llV t t i e e V Arr 77thSt. bor n a77th St. B Park o iPoppy Dr n e le uLu l t l V aB a t d s t igdCW 77th St C S le rim ly r l ae irr p a tcr g p u Se e ei pt r t Bln Pue S rk age Pa LN n E o ee lgr a S ue W Blu F W Nn L W 8 T e d H 7 v n 1 8 r V a i T Watere leafwA H h t 0 k Park o e tr e e 1 et LanE e Chan View 5 HwyArb rleaf R eor Wate tate Stu m SmBoule Y taoretuvard l teArb Hwy5 W Lane l m r t Chan View e e D o b H 8TS W7tre W r et bor e Aretu 7 m 8i A 5B t e ou h l r ev S wa t t d E e t a v t t S l S W tat S e H w y 5 A B rbo re tum B o ule va rd 78thSt. y W 7 r 8 t eh t e ne tr u S a t e t(W78thSt) n State Hwy 5 Arboretum Boulevard W 78th St e g Lr 5 a o. N y w CH T tstWa Harve y e s a t e S v v A Place Corporate e a g P Chanhassen d a ParDell Road Srk Cou rt k D t A m M o O D d R L I tA n v R a u r McGlynnDrive l N R ei E AT v S Recreation k E W e & r S Lake Drive East E rBou I el lte T re I uv C oa eha N ric I dP b W T r e e KB t D S t Center t l9 W7 s rv d n t d East mC ve Drive Lak u t l E ue Ag a d B i r k e Lake Drive East R e t S t hassen se Chan A v u A n H i u e i r m a E i l n D g y R C P P i o d aDell Road u r h g k 5 e l RC W t the e oy ates r ae Est d n rB wC A an oua ltevlvd rBoule y d .lvd. Coulter B r e Co ulter Bouu b r a aleva D rd v o Ga y A r M e t rk 4 Pa u k m 1 P t B Andr A W e C E a o r o l e u vv r ky T t o u r w de e rPlace 7h i l eCr P9 e u t hHp S ltS i a A c a Dakota ed r d v v e r Cir o e a v e C l u eB y du m u v t e l C r o t tb Bs A a (5 y E r s ew H e e en t Dta nv S ia e ir L D n a o l eeD o kda k a Pdo w i Lt a rD H tA v P e br a i m m n tu D L re ake bo A De r O riv e A de ap e R sc IL rH d a A t an Chanhassen L o R ota es w N r n R in R E i M T G k S dE E r W u o a& S d P E I or o T I C ei IN de W r T C n d e a C T n A e om C Pr n i dn i d rv H o n ie Mr Le o e o d P a w T a Nature t ed l A i p w o s a m H k M a e v i r r D D ue ee ry p k ie a L SC V e reserv i P e e i w r o E Driv e n d G M k usan W 82nd St ake S L a D a l e a l O o L a u k k wr o e y o d U w t R i dCa p g o e l r o a t Park n d r i D r S d BM i n ne C n a S e r ni r s s t c wo h l e t n s D e L e o iW d r e l a e d v i i C Cr rD e C e e k k e a k t d L i T reC rl ai x a La n kte eo kD la D p r o t o r M o eCu rt u a arsh L Rice M B rid Stone l e C T kview e Cree E e s k Crt Til Park ra Lake e B i Cr d eek l e b r rt e e C e nc sa is ea en R C w i r Park o o r e D v i r D l D sL a ok e r f i f RiceMarsh u D H riv De S ls il H a n a a s n us e S eeu Cr ek r nH an to us S t e S o S LkD S Lake n tS o Wn en e s l CL reekLs e E La C keDriv e k W a D n n Lake r La Preserve e o r L eR t C i k t o t v s S e s Ce r r w r e t e Do E o e d D W d G A ice R k D Oo I R r Lo I a A s Rw t l l dr N r p C R u r Eu o D T o OHW 881.8 i Sd B M n C Eo o u w r ose v D R W k l s aer & i r t t B S C S n d e E Hi I ll ns n B T o I L l t 8 C nS Lake Marsh W N S I n Ct W n ec T r o W u He a ron De Sr CourteC Dove tr C cs o t nrD LDr DSake es Ceknt rerol Herl r ul t Ci D R s o n na a u c ois l . er r n OHW 8 HP 77.0 1 o Hi M 9 lws k 1 o a H ) r 0 r oOP nm f Dr a e e si v Hills Mission i p l P n r t Cr r e i o w C Mallard ll d Di C LH a a kn H Crtea r M Sus o r e D lu s i BT b r n ils l a lvd (CSAH 18)i Lyman Be g g e r s L e e y il u g l Hs m M T o a e d D a rn n c E a.L t a a Bluff ilr s l i r n u v P M M r e e d i t s l s s us i r a o ( n C o e ill s W rt Fri Ds C C n rw ek T o r n o a. A a P s i H lD t A 1 8 e V )nW 8 6th St alL a u CL l a l Ridgey reTraib l Nk torthe llTr yyail r e eOK p ls lp s Vrei n ayS L C LO aCg M iV e n Ric ee Creek u fa e ri w i ts s s kc h a ea Marsh land Trl l D i n o oSP n u rs oweassenHillsDrNorth l P h W ln a m B H h ly l y a H i llHa W MissionW ke t i b l l i Preserve d P t r erv se C TD hr ushCrt r t r n v d M C e rt a r ey Van lley Rid ge P lac ee a c n l h t r 2 l 1 o 2 . DC N H . e ay T B i D rh V r o Power N ns l y o L L at la l l y l S k Lake Susan Drive a m yn e l e R Hill idg r R eTs a rail South D i n Bar bara Cl rt e y y h e B l i D l R Park v r L d e d k k Cr R e eu a ( o L su C S v n n S o s i t A c t re H l f e C 1 eRw S unridgh t 8 ui o ) e SLa r D s l l i H n e s S s aL a uk h e n n a h e e y t T T r v nB a l lv a md r B y l L Riley i l a r i C s Chanhassen C ehe o s at r de dr R fi ki C e a l se ds o Ridge e L S R no i t O snc a Hills nl i ue S L y o mQ Park Southwest Village Dr Su a L r t o h y i v C u m w o ue t t he a Park s n W t B V e l v i d s l l (t C a S Village A g H 1 8 )e Lyman Blv d (CSAH 18) D r LymanBlvd( CSAH18) AH 18) Lyman Blvd (CS Lyman Blvd (CSAH 18)LymanBlvd(CSAH18) River Rock Dr N e i r f t a r fiu rD e n l e C d Cro ssroad Ct n Dy me ri e l a e m l r e Degler LN G f D S g r nv e r p S d e f r e v m l m ut B r d S lan ark P o y ay C W e G l i r e River Rock Dr N R e e v Mills Drive k e w e a Di L i r e v i r D s l l l i M e i f e v i rr Way y e l a e pv sy n rSun J D e g e r d C i r c R l e e Lake n g L e N l a Dee e rfoot Tra il d v n P e m b r o k e r e l l a D S e e E r f w t r T i C k a k d c s c r e e s h t t C e i r B C Bluff Creek Riley d v Foxwoods l Bandimere Preserve e e r n l L i n f Preserve f e ga s u r d s i d r B i u T k e ar P J R a Bandimere e lw v g o R i o c k K D Heights S t W a erR sivoc S Rk H D r i Park v e C w i rg t o n 1 G C n Ln Lincol r n OHW 865.3 a m P en C d md a g C e D a r t W a D l t aeh Hemlock Way BRlvd c s o l ha o B r n is a n e w t v gi v o ee t n o l a t D lD tr hr r u o C l iaLn lumb ld Co o g i r a M d H e m t C l o s s c 2 a r Franklin k g n W 1 o t t d o Ca 2 a y . o d va R H l . Eastwood C do B u r rt T h k o f i n s x e s r nial Ln Colo a o g P W. 96th Street C F B l f p f lp e o u l f M f d o C n r B e l e e a n outh L l Plym d L L r v l T d kn e a c B e y a eo W t s k c o l m e n H l i Ln oma eed Fr l o P H t d a a o e r R d G r o f 1 x 0 o P in eF vi e w 4 CF 1)1 o H ur t A S C y ( l i o a w r T P r ioe ne e H R R t d eo a E d l r a ) 4 Pioneer Trail (CSAH 14) 1 Pioneer Trail (CSAH 14) H A C ( l r r. T T r rxe p lo e e n o B i P s i r onee Pi e l l i P n H a y L r e e r m b R u p G ns i a n h e rk s Pa 0 Pas pr 1 l D s k e y l o Brami beo Dr D a w b r e v e H T e urse reek Golf Co Bluff C ek Drive Bluff Cre d R d n s H w 1 1 G e T r a i lllers e stC l S n n d B l rm se Fa u Hes fv f d C r e e k W D e s r t i F v e eserv Pr e r m R o a d W e s rive kwood D Cree m R a sseF Ha rm R d d a o R Rd Hesse Farm Wm r e a s e tn F a eF nL at La ita ids ero H mk ea L R l W o a 14) SAH d rail (C eer T Pion Pioneer Trail (CSAH 1 s 4) n a e l B c r t l i u a e r C fG f1 0 f f C y u l r e B e H k D r V o g i e l v s b e r g e T r l r D d u o l C g n i y l F / 1 6 d R o C d B s n i a P e r G 1 0 r d u o l C g n l F / 1 6 H A S C CSAH 61/Flying Cloud Dr Rice MN Valley National ry Fen Semina Lake Wildlife Re fuge fic and Scienti l Area Natura O HW 699 .2 A) (SN r D d u o l C g n i y l F / 1 6 H A S C Raguet Wildlife C r S D A d H u 6 o 02505001,000 l 1 C / F g l y n i i n y g l F C / l 1 o 6 u d H D Managemen t A r i S v e C Feet Area (WM A) ) 0 1 . Pictometry 2017 O N Raguet Wildlife . R . C n o t h g Management u o Area (WMA) µ 01,0002,0004,0006,0008,000 Feet Potential Property Acquisition Taxparcel K:\\NickLH\\Projects\\PW\\Engineering\\For Paul\\2018\\January\\PropertyAcquis\\Property Acquistion_V2.mxd CHANHASSEN FARMERS' MARKET ¯ 1 inch = 30 feet PC DATE: January 15, 2019 CC DATE: March 11, 2019 CITY OF CHANHASSEN REVIEW DEADLINE: February 12 April 5, 2019 CASE # 2019-01 BY:KA,EH, JS, TH PROPOSAL: The applicant is requesting Preliminary Subdivision approval, rezoning to PUD-R and a wetland alteration permit. LOCATION: 7141 Galpin Boulevard APPLICANT: U.S. Home Corporation, d/b/a Lennar PRESENT ZONING: RR Rural Residential 2030 LAND USE PLAN: Low Density Residential 1.2 –4 units peracre ACREAGE: Approximately 191 acres gross GROSS DENSITY: 1 unit per acre net 129 123 acres net NET DENSITY: 1.33units peracre net LEVEL OF CITY DISCRETION IN DECISION MAKING: The city’s discretion in approving or denying a Preliminary Plat is limited to whether or not the proposed plat meets the standards outlined in the Subdivision Regulations and Zoning Ordinance. If it meets these standards, the city must approve the preliminary plat. This is a quasi-judicial decision. The city has a relatively high level of discretion in approving Rezoning’s and Planned Unit Developments (PUD) because the city is acting in its legislative or policy-making capacity. A rezoning or PUD must be consistent with the city’s Comprehensive Plan. Notice was sent to adjacent properties within 500 feet. PROPOSAL/SUMMARY The applicant is requesting Preliminary Subdivision approval, rezoning to PUD-R and a wetland alternation permit. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 2of 45 Map of Property Parcel and Site Information GIS Parcel ID TaxpayerLand UseCurrent Zoning Acreage Low Density PRN 256900030 10 Rural Residential 1.2-4 units/acre Low Density PRN 256900020 156.07 Rural Residential 1.2-4 units/acre Low Density Paisley Park 250100100 3.75 Rural Residential Enterprises Inc. 1.2-4 units/acre Low Density PRN 19.74 Rural Residential 256900010 1.2-4 units/acre Low Density 250100200 PRN 6.49 Rural Residential 1.2-4 units/acre Deeded acres vs. Total 191/188 GIS City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 3of 45 The surrounding land uses are included in the following table: Subdivision Zoning Land Use Notes South Royal OaksRSFLow Density 13 acres-33 lots West Woods at Long Acres PUD Low Density 97 acres-115 lots Wynsong - Shoreland DistrictPUD Low Density 9.4 acres 4 units North Ashling MeadowsRSF Low Density 40 acres-51 units Lake Lucy Ridge RSF Low Density 9 acres-17 units not applicable not applicable East Lake Ann Recreational Undeveloped Adjacent Land South Gorra Property ZoningLand Use Notes 38 (25 net) acres- 50 units Low Density Rural Residential 34 acres –204 units Low/Medium Rural Residential 46 acres - 276 units Medium Density Rural Residential 28 acres -336 units High Density Rural Residential An existing home that is on 2.62 acres at 7011 Galpin Boulevard is not included in the subdivision. BACKGROUND The following meetings were held discussing the PUD/Subdivision: Where Meeting type Date City Council, Planning Commission and Tour of the Site June 4, 2018 Park & Recreation City CouncilWork Session June 11, 2018 Park Commission Concept PUDJune 26, 2018 Planning Commission -Public Hearing Concept PUD July 17, 2018 City Council Concept PUD August 13, 2018 City Council Work Session December 3, 2108 Planning Commission -Public Hearing Preliminary Plat January 15, 2019 Park Commission Preliminary Plat January 22, 2019 City CouncilWork Session January 28, 2019 City Council Work Session February 11, 2019 Planning Commission Public Comment March 5, 2019 (minutes not yet available) City Council Preliminary Plat Scheduled for March 11, 2019 City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 4of 45 A public meeting was held on a concept PUD before the Planning Commission on July 17, 2018 and with the City Council on August 13, 2018. Included in the concept review were two layouts. One demonstrated a traditional subdivision using the RSF zoning district and the second layout applied the PUD zoning witha cluster development. The RSF zoning district showed a plan with 202 lots and the PUD showed a plan with 199 lots. The City Council held an additional work session on December 3, 2018 to discuss proposed changes for the preliminary review based on neighborhood meetings held in November. A summary of the comments from the Concept review include: The elimination of the through streetthe on the north end. Reduction of eight lots. Larger lots and deeper lots were created on the southern end (Majestic Oaks) to accommodate stormwater and tree preservation. Four lot sizes were introduced. The most significant changes from the Concept PUD and the Preliminary PUD application are: Plan modifications since initial concept review Overall 50+ acres designated for city park. Lot count has been reduced to 191 181 homesites down 17 lots since the concept (1.37 1.33 DU/Acre). Stormwater ponding has been incorporated to accommodate Galpin Boulevard upgrades and has shifted to minimize visual impact to the Longacres neighborhood and allows anopportunity to preserve the existing guardhouse as a symbol of neighborhood identity (condition and ability to preserve guardhouse to be further evaluated for safety). Perimeter buffering has been evaluated. Monumentation and landscape detail created. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 5of 45 North end Through-street from Galpin Boulevard to Lucy RidgeLane has been eliminated. Buffering through preservation has been identified. Fourteen (14) lots have been eliminated to minimize environmental impacts. South end Twelve (12) lots have been eliminated from the southern 1/3 of the property to reduce density. Lots along the southern property line have been enlarged from 55’to 75’ wide to 75 90’ wide to meet the RSF standard to accommodate standard homes rather than a Villa. Storm sewer and emergency overflows have been identified to alleviate water issues in adjacent neighborhood. Back yard areas along the southern property line have been expanded allowing for the preservation of existing trees. Landscape buffering has been integrated into the plan. ZONING DISTRICT Low-density zoning options for 1.2-4 units an acre. Within the low-density land use, there are a number of zoning applications including RSF, RLM, R-4 and PUD. The applicant’s proposal is requesting the Low Density Residential PUD Zoning. Residential Single Family (RSF) requires 15,000 square foot lots. This zoning district would cause the most environmental impacts to the site. In order to achieve the desire for a larger preservation area next to the lakes, the most appropriate zoning would be either a PUD or residential-low and medium density (RLM). Both of these districts require preservation of environmental features. It will be the city’s goal to ensure that the request for either zoning meets the intent. ARTICLE VIII. – PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT DIVISION 1. – GENERALLY Sec. 20-501. – Intent. Planned Unit Developments (PUD) offer enhanced flexibility to develop a site through the relaxation of most normal zoning district standards. The use of the PUD zoning also allows for a greater variety of uses, internal transfers of density, construction phasing, and a potential for lower development costs. In exchange for this enhanced flexibility, the city has the expectation that the development plan will result in a significantly higher quality and more sensitive proposal than would have been the case with the use of other, more standard zoning districts.It will be the applicant’s responsibility to demonstrate that the city’s expectation is to be realized as evaluated against the following criteria. The applicant is pursuing the PUDzoning.In their narrative,they have stated,“The use of the PUD zoning also allows for greater specificity in the types, location and sizes of uses. The city has the expectation that the development plan will result in a significantly higher quality and more sensitive proposal than would be the case with the other, more standard zoning districts. It is the City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 6of 45 applicant's responsibility to demonstrate that the city's expectations are to be realized as evaluated by the city’s goals.” Justification for Rezoning to PUD Sec. 20-501. – Intent. Planned unit developments offer enhanced flexibility to develop a site through the relaxation of most normal zoning district standards. The use of the PUD in this instance is to preserve a significant open space (100 +/- acres) next to Lake Ann Park as identified in the city’s Comprehensive Plan. The transfer of density preserves land by dedication rather than acquisition by the city.In exchange for this enhanced flexibility, the city has the expectation that the development plan will result in a significantly higher quality and more sensitive proposal than would have been the case with the other more standard zoning districts. The proposed subdivision provides a compatible development with the surrounding development and subject to the recommended modifications to the plan. The proposed PUD rezoning assists in the furtherance of the following land use goals of the City of Chanhassen Comprehensive Plan: Enhanced preservation of Lake Ann and Lake Lucy by limited development within the shore land district. Reduction in total impervious surfacethrough the cluster development. Preservation of native vegetation and habitat within the shoreland district. Preservation of over 90% of the wetlands on the site. Reduction of city long-term maintenance costs. Provide connectivity (trials) to existing parks and trails. Dedication of right-of-way along Galpin Boulevard. The proposed amendment and rezoning assists in the furtherance of the following housing goals of the City of Chanhassen Comprehensive Plan: A variety of housing types for people in all stages of the life-cycle. Development will be encouraged within the MUSA line. The plan should seek to establish sufficient land to provide a full range of housing opportunities. APPLICABLE REGULATIONS Chapter 18, Subdivisions Chapter 20:Article VI. - Wetland Protection Article VII. -Shoreland Management District Article VII. - Planned Unit Development District City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 7of 45 EXISTING CONDITIONS A bluff area to the northern off of Lake Lucy Ridge. A portion of the site is within the Shoreland District of Lake Ann and Lake Lucy. All lots within 1000 feet of the shoreland must have a minimum lot size of 15,000 square feet. This standard has been meet with the lots on the end of Street “Z”and the end of Lake Lucy Lane. There are several wetlands on the site,the largest of which is approximately 42 acres. The wetlands have been delineated and a Notice of Decision has been made. SUBDIVISION PRELIMINARY PLAT The applicant is requesting subdivision of 191 acres into three outlots and 191 181 residential lots.Access to the site is from Galpin Boulevard except for the connection to the north that connects Topaz Drive and Lucy Ridge Lane. Street “Z”off of Galpin Boulevard is now a cul- de-sac. While a variance is not required for the cul-de-sac length, staff has reviewed the criteria necessary to permit longer cul-de-sacs. The maximum length of a street terminating in a cul-de- sac shall be 800 feet. The city manager or their designee may approve a cul-de-sac exceeding 800 feet if they determine that the following necessitates a length in excess of 800 feet. Topography would require substantial grading and the loss of significant trees that would alter the physical character of the property and surrounding parcels. Additionally, the 16 lots proposed for housing accessed via this cul-de-sac are on larger lots, rather than the 26-30 homes that would be permitted by City Code. Site Analysis Total Gross Area191.0456 +/- Acres Total Development Area 51.9451 51.21 Acres Number of Lots191 181 Number of Outlots3 Total Outlot Area122.3114 123.28 Acres Total Right-of-Way Area 16.79 16.47 Acres Gross Density .9474 Lots/Acre Net Density (Excludes Wetlands & Co. Rd. 117) 1.5 1.33+/-Acres City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 8of 45 DEVELOPMENT DESIGN STANDARDS Staff is proposing that the following development standards govern the development of the property. Wetland Standards - Manage 1 Buffer: 30 feet Building Setback for Buffer: 25 feet Accessory Building setback from the Buffer: 15 feet Proposed Lot Standards 90-Foot Lots - Shoreline Overlay Non-Riparian Lots Width: 90 feet Area: 15,000 sq. ft. OHW: 75-foot setback Bluff: 30-foot setback Local street ROW setback: 20 feet (25 feet with sidewalk) Corner Lot Right-of-way: 20 feet Lot Coverage: 25% Total Lots: 31 42 City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 9of 45 75-footlots Width:75feet Area: 11,000 sq. ft. Front setback: 20 feet Rear setback: 25 feet Side setback: 7.5 feet Corner at ROW: 20 feet County Road 117: 50 feet Lot Coverage: 35% Total Lots: 10 65-Foot Lots Width: 65 feet Area: 8,450 sq. ft. Front setback: 20 or 25 feet Rear setback: 25 feet Side setback: 7.5 feet Lot Coverage: 35% Total Lots: 116 139 55-footlots Width: 55 feet Area: 6,000 sq. ft. Garage setback: 25 feet; Living space: 20 feet Rear setback: 25 feet Side setback: 7.5 feet Lot Coverage: 35% Total Lots: 34 *Lots within each category may exceed the pervious surface because they are averaged with the overall preservation area within the development. The PUD ordinance requires setbacks from roadways and exterior property lines. The following table displays these setbacks: GALPIN PROPERTY COMPLIANCE TABLE Lot Lot Area Lot Width Lot Impervious (SF) (Feet) Depth Area (SF) (Feet) 90 foot 15,000 90 125 5,500 frontage 90 foot 11,250 90 125 5,500 frontage ** 65 ft Lots 8,450 65 125 4,400 City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 10of 45 Front Rear Side Yard Corner CR 117 Setback SetbackSetback Setback Setback 20 ft* 25 ft 7.5 ft 20 ft50 ft 25 ft 25 ft 7.5 ft 20 ft50 ft Wetland Buffer Setback 20 ft. *25 ft. with Sidewalk **Lots 101-111 90-Foot Frontage Lot Lot Area Lot Width Lot Impervious (SF) (Feet) Depth Area (SF) (Feet) 501 18,092 100177 5,500 502 17,455 90 167 5,500 503 15,030 90 167 5,500 504 22,829 90 249 5,500 505 24,572 90 249 5,500 506 16,733 90 175 5,500 507 18,427 90 201 5,500 508 17,037 90 142 5,500 509 23,848 90 159 5,500 510 20,017 90 137 5,500 511 18,801 90 156 5,500 512 17,844 90 167 5,500 513 15,032 90 167 5,500 514 15,030 90 167 5,500 515 16,667 100167 5,500 516 15,574 90 175 5,500 517 15,514 90 175 5,500 51815,482901745,500 519 15,576 90 174 5,500 520 15,300 90 170 5,500 521 15,300 90 170 5,500 522 15,300 90 170 5,500 523 15,440 90 172 5,500 524 15,882 90 168 5,500 525 16,629 90 136 5,500 526 22,359 90 140 5,500 527 27,426 90 143 5,500 528 16,764 90 160 5,500 529 15,371 90 165 5,500 530 44,983 90 165 5,500 531 47,788 90 125 5,500 City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 11of 45 90-Foot Frontage Lot Lot Area Lot Width Lot Impervious (SF) (Feet) Depth Area (SF) (Feet) 10119,8971351435,500 10213,371901485,500 103 13,297 90 148 5,500 104 13,297 90 148 5,500 10513,297901485,500 10613,297901485,500 107 13,297 90 148 5,500 108 13,297 90 148 5,500 109 14,599 90 148 5,500 110 14,840 90 148 5,500 111 25,529 90 148 5,500 Avg. 18,479 65-Foot Frontage Lot Lot Area Lot Width Lot Impervious (SF) (Feet) Depth Area (SF) (Feet) 301 9,993 78 125 4,400 302 8,450 65 125 4,400 303 8,450 65 125 4,400 304 8,450 65 125 4,400 305 8,450 65 125 4,400 306 8,450 65 125 4,400 307 11,132 65 125 4,400 308 13,748 78 131 4,400 309 8,925 65 129 4,400 310 12,282 65 126 4,400 311 8,607 65 125 4,400 312 8,126 65 125 4,400 313 8,257 65 125 4,400 314 8,795 65 130 4,400 315 9,683 65 142 4,400 316 12,836 78 125 4,400 317 12,591 78 150 4,400 318 10,414 65 145 4,400 319 10,228 65 145 4,400 320 11,448 65 145 4,400 321 13,180 65 147 4,400 322 12,052 65 145 4,400 323 11,853 65 142 4,400 324 10,767 65 142 4,400 325 9,524 65 139 4,400 City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 12of 45 326 9,135 65 132 4,400 327 8,609 65 132 4,400 328 8,609 65 132 4,400 329 10,232 65 132 4,400 330 9,750 65 125 4,400 331 9,478 65 125 4,400 332 10,900 65 125 4,400 333 16,107 78 125 4,400 334 11,215 78 136 4,400 335 10,404 65 153 4,400 336 11,607 65 167 4,400 337 10,622 65 142 4,400 338 11,545 65 133 4,400 339 14,532 65 125 4,400 340 12,761 65 125 4,400 341 13,019 65 125 4,400 342 10,858 65 125 4,400 343 10,887 65 163 4,400 344 10,502 65 152 4,400 345 9,306 65 134 4,400 346 10,263 78 125 4,400 347 10,020 78 125 4,400 348 9,385 65 135 4,400 349 10,984 65 154 4,400 350 10,228 65 126 4,400 351 8,474 65 126 4,400 352 8,474 65 125 4,400 353 8,776 65 125 4,400 354 8,864 65 125 4,400 35513,586651314,400 35614,313651304,400 357 12,790 65 132 4,400 358 12,963 65 125 4,400 359 14,449 65 145 4,400 360 11,360 65 126 4,400 361 11,011 78 125 4,400 362 10,508 65 142 4,400 363 11,458 65 145 4,400 364 13,033 65 130 4,400 365 12,790 65 130 4,400 366 12,940 65 132 4,400 367 12,790 65 130 4,400 368 9,728 65 131 4,400 369 10,036 65 140 4,400 370 10,303 78 125 4,400 City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 13of 45 371 8,933 65 130 4,400 372 9,242 65 130 4,400 373 9,242 65 130 4,400 374 9,242 65 130 4,400 375 9,236 65 130 4,400 376 8,450 65 130 4,400 377 8,450 65 130 4,400 378 8,450 65 130 4,400 379 8,450 65 130 4,400 380 8,450 65 130 4,400 381 8,801 65 130 4,400 382 15,319 95 130 4,400 383 11,772 78 145 4,400 384 9,453 65 145 4,400 385 9,780 65 145 4,400 386 9,898 65 134 4,400 387 9,263 65 130 4,400 388 8,450 65 130 4,400 389 8,450 65 130 4,400 390 8,450 65 130 4,400 391 8,450 65 130 4,400 392 8,450 65 130 4,400 393 8,749 65 130 4,400 394 9,189 65 130 4,400 395 9,390 65 130 4,400 396 9,313 65 130 4,400 397 8,922 65 134 4,400 398 12,754 78 130 4,400 399 8,474 65 130 4,400 4008,450651304,400 4018,450651304,400 402 8,450 65 130 4,400 403 8,450 65 130 4,400 404 8,450 65 130 4,400 405 10,504 65 130 4,400 406 11,092 65 130 4,400 407 8,819 65 130 4,400 408 8,450 65 130 4,400 409 8,729 65 130 4,400 410 12,658 78 131 4,400 411 10,192 78 127 4,400 412 9,559 65 127 4,400 413 9,104 65 145 4,400 414 9,702 65 137 4,400 415 14,151 65 135 4,400 City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 14of 45 416 9,676 65 135 4,400 417 8,779 65 130 4,400 418 8,570 65 130 4,400 419 9,103 65 136 4,400 420 9,344 65 143 4,400 421 9,170 65 143 4,400 422 10,929 78 132 4,400 423 12,265 78 142 4,400 424 9,984 65 130 4,400 425 10,465 65 130 4,400 426 11,434 65 159 4,400 427 12,108 65 170 4,400 428 12,591 65 178 4,400 429 12,589 65 178 4,400 430 12,101 65 170 4,400 431 10,764 65 130 4,400 432 9,554 65 130 4,400 433 11,046 78 128 4,400 434 12,618 65 141 4,400 435 14,656 65 212 4,400 436 14,357 65 248 4,400 437 14,285 65 248 4,400 438 13,661 65 200 4,400 439 12,931 65 134 4,400 Avg. 10,475 Design Standards 1. The permitted uses in this zoning district shall be single-family detached houses and their accessory uses. House styles include the Lennar Lifestyle, Luxury, Landmark, Classic and Villa home plans; similar or equivalent as approved by the Community Development Director. 2. The 31 northern lots that are adjacent to Lake Lucy Ridge and Ashling meadows maybe developed by another entity. These lots are a part of these governing documents; the home styles may differ but must be similar in architectural scale and quality (Exhibit A). EASEMENTS & RIGHT-OF-WAY There is an existing 20’ wide Metropolitan Council Environmental Services (MCES) sewer and utility easement located on the property as illustrated on the submitted preliminary plat. Generally, the easement traverses from the northwest corner of the property to the southeast corner of the property, bisecting the site diagonally. The applicant is proposing to impact the easement at two locations. The first location is within the northwest corner of the site where grading and construction of Street “Z” and Basin 200 are proposed. The second location is to the east of Street “G” where grading is proposed behind Lots 143-144. The MCES has been City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 15of 45 supplied withthe applicant’s site plans. The applicant shall address all comments and conditions set forth by the MCES. An agreement to construct any of the proposed improvements over the MCES’s easement must be executed and supplied to the city for review prior to the issuance of grading permits. Furthermore, the applicant shall supply callouts identifying the width of the MCES easement on the plat prior to recording. The applicant is proposing standard drainage and utility easements (D&U’s) around the majority of the lots on the provided preliminary plat. Additional 20’ wide D&U’s have been provided within Lots116-130 abutting Street “Z”, Lots 108-111 abutting Street “A”, and Lots 102-105 abutting Topaz Drive. These 20’ wide D&U’s are provided for stormwater collection and conveyance systems located in backyards that fall outside the standard D&U’s. Furthermore, 30’ wide D&U’s between Lots 133-134 abutting Street “H” and Lots 116-117 abutting Street “D” have been proposed. These additional 30’ wide D&U’s are provided for access to proposed utilities and the north side of Basin 300. However, 30’ wide D&U’s between additional lots throughout the development shall be provided in areas requiring access to utilities and stormwater basins. This shall include the location of a water main connection off Street “Z” to a stub off Ruby Lane, discussed under the “Water” section of this staff report, and between lots abutting stormwater Basins 100, 300, and 600. Right-of-way dedication will be required along the east side of Galpin Boulevard per Carver County’s review and comments (see attached “Carver County Development / Access Review Comments” letter), the Highway 117 Corridor Study, and the typical roadway sections identified in the county’s Draft 2040 Comprehensive Plan. The Corridor Study identifies specific right-of- way needs and the plat will be required to follow and be consistent with the preferred roadway alternative. The right-of-way shall tie into the existing highway right-of-way north and south of the proposed development. The preliminary and final plat proposals shall be reviewed and approved as to form and content by the county surveyor and city. Specific right-of-way dedications and recommended cross-section submittals are referenced in the county’s comments under Item 5. Currently, there exists overhead utilities within the right-of-way abutting the development on the east side of Galpin Boulevard. The applicant will be required to underground all overhead th utilities from W. 78 Street to the northern property line. Underground utilities reduce the risk of accidents, such as vehicles colliding with poles and service impacts such as storms knocking down limbs on lines. It also improves the overall esthetics of roadway corridors and neighborhoods, which improves and promotes livability. The undergrounding of utilities from th Street to the southern property line is required to maintain continuity, discourage W.78 associated impacts with piecemealed undergrounding activities, and promote constructability. EXISTING CONDITIONS SURVEY The provided existing conditions survey does not call out any existing septic systems or water wells. However, Engineering and Public Works are aware of a potential septic system near the “guard house” on the development. The applicant shall determine, to the satisfaction of the City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 16of 45 Engineering and Public Works departments, that there are in fact, no existing septic systems and/or wells located on the property. If found, the abandonment of all existing wells shall be in accordance with the Minnesota Department of Health’s review and regulations, and the abandonment of all existing septic systems shall be in accordance with the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency’s review and regulations. All required permits from the appropriate regulatory agencies shall be obtained prior to the commencement of any abandonment(s). There is an existing MCES sanitary and utility easement on parcels 250100400 and 257580040 that is not delineated on the existing conditions survey. The applicant shall identify the document numbers and illustrate the extents of the easement on these parcels and resubmit the existing conditions survey. GRADING The applicant is proposing to construct five stormwater basins (Basins 100, 200, 300, 400, 600) within and around the development. Through the preliminary grading plan and grading details, drainage from individual lots will be routed away from buildings into a series of catch basins and reinforced concrete pipe located within drainage and utility easements in backyards. Drainage from proposed public streets will be collected through catch basins located next to curbs and routed to stormwater basins within and around the site. The applicant has not provided in the narrative or on the preliminary plans details regarding whether the site will be mass graded or if the site will be graded under a phased approach. The applicant shall supply a mass grading plan or a phased grading plan (whichever is applicable) for review and approval by the city prior to the issuance of grading plans. There are proposed driveways that approach the maximum 10% grade (e.g. Lot 130 abutting Street “Z” is at 9.9% grade) and one street that reaches the maximum 7% grade (Street “A” near station 24+50) allowed by city ordinance. Staff recommends limiting maximum grades in order to achieve a higher level of constructability. Any constructed street or driveway that exceeds maximum allowable grades upon final inspection will be required to be removed and replaced. The applicant has not supplied top of curb elevations or spot elevations at the center of proposed driveways at curb line on the submitted grading plans. Updated grading plans shall be submitted illustrating these elevations for review by the city to ensure constructability and any potential conflicts. The proposed grading to the north of Street “Z” between stations 6+50 and 11+00 is called out as a 2:1 slope. The slope shall be reduced to 2.5:1, at a minimum, upon submittal of construction drawings and prior to the issuance of a grading permit. Certain locations that call out the emergency overflow route (EOF) are missing the associated drainage arrows. All locations of the EOF shall be illustrated with accompanying drainage arrows upon resubmittal of grading plans. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 17of 45 There are two bluffs within the site. One bluff is located west of Lots 111-115 abutting Lucy Ridge Lane and a second bluff is located south of Lots 125-126 abutting Street “Z”. The grading plans do not indicate the locations or extent of the bluffs and their appropriate buffers and setbacks. The extent and location of all bluffs shall be provided on the grading plans upon submittal of construction drawings, and the grading and/or building of any structures adjacent to bluffs shall be subject to review and approval prior to the issuance of a grading permit. Proposed grading for Basin 400 encroaches into the southern section of the city’s well house #3 and water station site off Galpin Boulevard. The applicant will be required to perform site improvements associated with the well house site as discussed under the “Water” section of this staff report, including the relocation of the access driveway off Galpin Boulevard. Additionally, there is a significant oak tree that shall be protected during grading operations. The grading plans shall show the relocated access driveway location and grades, the location and footprint of the well house, and call out the protection of the oak tree upon resubmittal of grading plans. There is a low point indicated on the preliminary grading plans at the intersection of Street “E” and Street “H” that does not align with the proposed storm catch basin. The applicant shall adjust the grading plans so that the low point is adjacent to the catch basin for optimal drainage and to reduce ponding or “bird bathing”. The preliminary grading plans indicate drainage of backyards from Lots 164-174 abutting Street “A” to runoff directly onto the proposed public trail, north of Wetland 11. The applicant shall submit revised grading plans and stormwater plans so that no stormwater runoff flows directly onto the public trail. Furthermore, no untreated stormwater shall be routed to wetlands prior to treatment. Immediately east of Lot 110 abutting Street “A”, the applicant is proposing a stormwater conveyance pipe with catch basins. The preliminary grading plans indicate a grade of approximately 30% running perpendicular to the stormwater system. The applicant shall adjust the grading plans to create a grade of not more than 10% over the utility for maintenance and accessibility purposes. Furthermore, staff has concerns regarding slope stability immediately east of Lot 110. The applicant shall submit an updated geotechnical report, including soil types, groundwater elevations, and slope stability calculations for this area based on the proposed structure to be constructed on the lot. The public trail adjacent to the back lot lines of Lots 112-115 has a proposed continuous grade of 8% extending over 150’. While the proposed public trail system meets the Americans with Disabilities Act Accessibility Guidelines (ADAAG) for maximum running slope of trail segments (no more than 30% of the total trail length to exceed a 1:12 slope), staff recommends the installation of a level resting pad over this continuous grade. This recommendation is based on the intent of ADAAG which is to provide access to the greatest extent possible. The plat’s final grading plans, ponds, and right-of-way along Galpin Boulevard shall be reviewed and approved by the county and the city to show how they conform to the potential City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 18of 45 future Galpin Boulevard reconstruction. A cross reference of grading plans, profiles, and respective cross sections should be provided at key locations such as intersections, ponds, or other special features for review by the county and city prior to acceptance. RETAINING WALLS There are three proposed retaining walls on the site. All retaining walls exceeding 4’ in height shall be constructed in accordance with plans prepared by a registered engineer or landscape architect and shall be constructed of a durable material (smooth face concrete/poured in place, masonry/mortared, railroad ties and timber are prohibited). No such plans or details were submitted with the plan sheets and must be provided prior to issuance of grading permits. The retaining wall on the south side of the development behind Lots 108-111 abutting Street “A” is approximately 420’ long and ranges from 4’-10’ tall. The retaining wall is currently proposed to be offset approximately 10’ from a proposed stormwater conveyance line. The retaining wall shall be adjusted to accommodate a 1.5:1 buffer from the bottom of the proposed stormwater line to the bottom of the proposed retaining wall foundation. The 1.5:1 buffer is required for maintenance and repair purposes and to maintain structural stability of the wall during such activities. The retaining wall on the west side of the development behind Lots 161-163 abutting Street “A” is approximately 170’ long. Top of wall and bottom of wall spot elevations were not provided. The updated grading plans shall include the top of wall and bottom of wall elevations. The retaining wall on the north side of the development behind Lots 123-125 abutting Street “Z” is approximately 200’ long and ranges from 6’-8’ tall. The construction of this wall appears to be within a bluff setback. Pending updated grading plans that illustrate the bluff, addressed previously under the “Grading” section of this staff report, the retaining wall may have to be adjusted outside the bluff protection area. STREETS The applicant is proposing the construction of nine new streets (Streets “A”-“H” and Street “Z”) and the extension of two existing streets (Topaz Drive and Lucy Ridge Lane) that shall be owned and maintained by the city after acceptance of the public improvements by the City Council. All newly constructed street sections shall be designed to meet the current standard specifications and detail plates for residential streets. These new streets and extensions will result in six cul-de- sacs with five of the six proposed cul-de-sacs meeting current City Code and standard specifications. Street “Z”, a newly constructed street and cul-de-sac in the northern section of the development, exceeds the maximum length for a cul-de-sac per city ordinance. City ordinance section 18.57.k limits the length of any cul-de-sac to 800’. Street “Z” is proposed as a cul-de-sac with a length of 1376’ measured from the centerline of Galpin Boulevard to the center point of the turnaround radius. However, Engineering recommends approval of the cul-de-sac as City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 19of 45 the topography would require substantial grading and the loss of significant trees that would alter the physical character of the property and surrounding parcels (Ordinance 18.57.k.2). Furthermore, public outreach efforts and public hearings were conducted by the city regarding the option for a local through street connecting Galpin Boulevard to Lucy Ridge Lane (i.e. Street “Z”). The responses received from residences in the Ashling Meadows neighborhood noted that they opposed the connection. The concerns were regarding perceived increased cut-through traffic, safety associated with an increase in traffic through residential neighborhoods, and loss of the natural barrier between neighborhoods. The alternative to connect Galpin Boulevard with Lucy Ridge Lane was conceptually proposed back in June of 2018 by the applicant (see exhibit below). Exhibit 1: Pioneer Engineering’s Concept Plan 07 from 6-1-2018 As the applicant has proposed not to extend or connect the development of the north section through the existing stub off Ruby Lane, the developer shall remove the existing hard surface and construct half-streetimprovements (extending curb & gutter) to maintain the continuity of Topaz Drive. The city will reach out to the property owners abutting the removed stub to discuss vacating the right-of-way, while maintaining utility easements over existing utilities. Access to Street “Z” is from Galpin Boulevard, a collector road. There is an existing driveway 30 feet south of Street “Z” providing access to parcel 250100400. This spacing does not meet MnDOT Access Management Guidelines or Carver County’s requirements for access points off collector roads. The parcel’s access from Galpin Boulevard shall be abandoned and realigned to City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 20of 45 tie into Street “Z”. Additionally, a water stub for future connection shall be installed to serve the property. The city has had discussions with the resident of this property and has obtained verbal agreeance of such a realignment and future water service connection. The applicant has supplied a geotechnical evaluation report that was completed by Braun Intertec Corporation on June 29, 2018. The report discussed and explored design and construction recommendations for roadway sections, amongst other topics. The report utilized eight boring locations for the entire site. Due to the size of the development, the city will require additional borings. In-situ soil strata and subsoil conditions over a large area, such as this development (approximately 52 acres), requires a more comprehensive understanding of subsoil constraints that additional borings can provide. The city will require additional borings where roadways are to be constructed and at all cul-de-sac locations. The city will require the applicant to submit an updated geotechnical evaluation report based on the additional borings. Sidewalks and pedestrian access points have been proposed on a majority of the streets throughout the development. However, Streets“D”, “G”, and “Z” will require extensions of sidewalk to provide access within the cul-de-sacs. Sidewalks shall be constructed in accordance with city standard specifications and detail plates. Furthermore, there are considerable stretches of sidewalk that do not provide access points or curb ramps to the newly constructed sidewalks. The applicant shall provide curb ramp/access points for every 500 feet of sidewalk. This will result in three additional curb ramps/access points from the provided preliminary site plan. All curb ramps shall be constructed to meet ADA standards and the city’s detail plates. The sidewalk located at the intersection of Galpin Boulevard and Street “E” terminates with no proposed intersection improvements to access the existing trail system on the west side. The developer will be required to extend connectivity by providing access from the newly constructed east side to the existing west side of Galpin Boulevard by utilizing approved MUTCD practices for pedestrian crosswalk and intersection improvements. Street lights have been proposed throughout the development. No street light construction detail or specifications were provided with the subdivision submittals. A detail of the street lights shall be submitted and reviewed prior to the issuance of building permits. An enumerated list of all street lights and their locations shall be submitted prior to the recording of the final plat. Street lights will be required at all intersections and at the end of each cul-de-sac. The developer will need to work with Xcel Energy for the installation of city-approved street lights. A $300 fee shall be collected with the development contract for each street light for the purpose of electricity costs for the first year of operation. WATER MAIN & SANITARY SEWER Water The applicant is proposing to construct 8” PVC C900 water main throughout the development that shall be owned and maintained by the city after acceptance of the public improvements by City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 21of 45 the City Council. The development is located between two pressure zones in the city; a high pressure zone and a low pressure zone. To the west in the Longacres neighborhood is a high- pressure zone. To the north and south in the Ashling Meadows and Royal Oak Estates neighborhoods, respectively, are low-pressure zones. The city has modeled the impact of the development based on the proposed usage. It was found that in order to provide adequate pressures and fire flows, water mains shall be tied into the high-pressure zone located on Galpin Boulevard. This will result in some areas of the development experiencing pressures above 90 PSI. Therefore, a portion of the homes will likely require individual pressure reducing valves. The developer will need to work with the Building Department and Public Works Utility Department to determine which homes will require pressure-reducing valves. In the northwest area of the development where Topaz Drive and Lucy Ridge Lane will be extended, the developer is proposing to tie into the low-pressure water system via the existing 8” PVC water mains. Engineering does not anticipate any extraordinary impacts to the water system’s pressure or fire flow for the proposed 15 connections. Street “Z” will be tied into the high zone water system via the existing 14” HDPE SDR 11 water main off Galpin Boulevard. Street “Z” is currently proposed as a cul-de-sac and the applicant is proposing the creation of a dead end system. Public Works will require the applicant to resubmit plans to tie into the proposed water main on Street “Z” to the existing water main stub located off Ruby Lane, to the north. Because Street “Z” will be within the high-pressure zone and the north tie-in location on Ruby Lane (Ashling Meadows neighborhood) is within the low-pressure zone, updated construction plans shall call out a gate valve to be installed where the system ties in. This gate valve will remain closed in order to separate the two zones and will be opened by city forces during any maintenance or repair work in order to “back feed” the system, as necessary. The majority of the water main to be installed is within the central and southern portion of the development (Streets “A”-“H”). The applicant is proposing to create a looped water system which meets city best management practices for water utilities. Looped systems improve reliability by feeding water from two directions rather than one, which subsequently allows service to continue during an event that may otherwise cause disruption to water service. Water main connections will be tied into the high zone water system off Galpin Boulevard via a 14” HDPE SDR 11 pipe. The applicant shall verify the location of the connections on the construction plans. All water main taps, connections, and required water main testing shall be witnessed by the city. A pre-construction meeting prior to the commencement of any work shall be scheduled by the developer’s contractor with the city. Additionally, all underground utilities on the east side of Galpin Boulevard have not been located. For example, the city’s raw water main that feeds the west treatment plant. This area on the east side of Galpin Boulevard is where water and sanitary sewer will cross before entering the development. Thus, prior to the issuance of building permits, all underground utilities in this area shall be surveyed and illustrated in the profile sheets in order to identify any conflicts. The applicant is proposing a “land swap” to build Lot 163 abutting Street “A” within the city’s well house #3 property off Galpin Boulevard. This exchange of land will require the execution City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 22of 45 of an agreement to be reviewed and approved by the city prior to acceptance and recording of the final plat. The agreement will set forth conditions for improvements to the well house #3 site in exchange for the land required for Lot 163. The improvements will include: the relocation of the ingress/egress driveway to well house #3 due to vertical curve and sight distance hazards, relocation of the SCADA antenna due to the impact of Lot 163, improvements to the hard surface area surrounding the well house which shall include a turning movements analysis to ensure proper widths for design vehicles are adequate, and potential landscaping improvements. Furthermore, the applicant must maintain a 50-foot setback of all structures from well house #3 in accordance with the Minnesota Department of Health requirements. From the proposed preliminary water plans, there are multiple areas where water main and sanitary sewer mains will cross. All crossings of water and sewer utility mains are required to have 18” of vertical separation and 10’ of horizontal separation, measured from the edge of pipe. Additionally, where water mains cross sanitary sewer mains, the sanitary sewer shall be constructed of C900 water main material and the sanitary sewer pipe length shall be centered over the water main crossing. The preliminary plans delineate areas where water main will run closely adjacent to, or under, stormwater catch basins. This may cause a potential for freezing of the water main at these locations due to inadequate ground cover from catch basin bottoms (sumps) to the water main. Water mains shall be constructed at 7.5’ below grade, or insulated, and constructed in conformance with the city’s standard specifications and detail plates. Plan and profile sheets provided with the construction drawings of the water main shall include the location and depth of catch basins and their sumps for review and approval prior to issuance of building permits. The location of gate valves at some locations are up to 40’ away from tees. The applicant shall cluster all valves at tees to obtain a minimum of 5’ spacing from the tee to the valves, where feasible. Review of valve locations and other water main appurtenances shall be conducted by Public Works and Engineering prior to the issuance of building permits. The applicant shall ensure all fire hydrant spacing meets fire codes and are subject to the review and approval of the Fire Department. Sanitary Sewer The applicant is proposing to construct 8” PVC sanitary sewer main throughout the development that shall be owned and maintained by the city after acceptance of the public improvements by the City Council. The entire sanitary sewer system will operate as a gravity system and connects to existing sanitary sewer mains at five locations (Lucy Ridge Lane, Topaz Drive, the intersection of Galpin Boulevard and Hunter Drive, a direct connection to the MCES sanitary sewer trunk line on Street “Z”, and at the Majestic Way extension off Street “D” through a utility easement). City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 23of 45 As proposed, the connection to the MCES sanitary sewer trunk line from Street “Z” and its subsequent manhole are not within the roadway, down steep grades, and abutting Basin 200. The applicant shall resubmit construction drawings to provide the access manhole and tie-in on and within Street “Z”. All conditions set forth by the MCES shall be addressed by the applicant for the required access manhole and direct connection to their trunk line, and all permits required shall be obtained prior to the commencement of construction. The sanitary sewer line to the south, adjacent to Lots 101-109 abutting Street “A”, are proposed to be constructed at the minimum slope for gravity systems based on 10 States Standards (0.4% for 8” PVC pipe). It is the recommendation of the Engineering department to increase the slope to a minimum of 2% for a more effective cleaning velocity. This approach is feasible as the proposed manhole depths are 12-22 feet (e.g. MH-92) from top of lid to invert-outs. Also, the tie-in of this sewer line is to a manhole at the intersection of Galpin Boulevard and Hunter Drive. From the proposed preliminary plans, the applicant is proposing a new manhole, while city records show an existing manhole directly adjacent to the proposed new manhole. The applicant shall field verify this connection and its configuration prior to the submittal of construction plans. The preliminary plans submitted utilize a nomenclature for identifying proposed manholes that differs from the city’s. Prior to the submittal of construction drawings, the applicant shall ensure the city’s manhole naming conventions are incorporated within the plans. The city will provide a list of appropriate manhole identifiers. This will ensure an efficient transition of the newly constructed public improvements into the city’s asset management system for sanitary sewer appurtenances. Profile sheets for all public utilities, including sanitary sewer, shall be required for review and approval by the city prior to issuance of building permits. Based on the provided plan sheets, the applicant is proposing sanitary sewer that reaches a maximum depth of 26.47’ (see MH-26 in front of Lot 172 abutting Street “A”). PVC sanitary sewer pipes that have a burial depth of 0-16 feet are required to be class SDR 35, burial depths of 16-26 feet requires class SDR 26, and burial depths of greater than 26 feet requires class C900. The applicant shall update construction drawings indicating sanitary sewer pipes that fall within these burial depths to have the appropriate class of PVC. Furthermore, all inverts that have a 20-inch or greater differential shall be supplied inside drops per city standards and be constructed per the city’s detail plate for inside drops. The preliminary plans show one manhole (MH-99 in front of Lot 118 abutting Street “C”) having sewer flows in opposing directions, i.e. the east “invert out” flows to the east, and the west “invert-out” flows to the west. The applicant shall submit construction drawings that isolate flow directions via separate manholes and independent pipe systems. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 24of 45 STORMWATER MANAGEMENT Please note that due to the need to review additional stormwater information, additional comments will likely be provided on any resubmitted plans. General The applicant has delineated all wetlands on the property and agencies have approved the boundaries and type. 1. Wetland permitting is required due to the proximity and proposed impacts to wetlands on site. A wetland permit application has not yet been received by the City from the applicant. Grading permits will not be issued until approved wetland permits have been received. See “Wetland Alteration” of this staff report for more information. 2. Wetland review will include ensuring hydrology is maintained to all wetlands to be preserved as well as review of proposed stormwater impacts. 3. Storm sewer sizing calculations should be provided to confirm storm sewer is sized to convey the 10-year storm event. 4. A NPDES permit and accompanying Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) will be required prior to the start of construction. 5. An operations and maintenance plan for the proposed stormwater management system will be required prior to approval. 6. Provide infiltration test results per MPCA Requirements in the location of each proposed infiltration area. 7. All comments and conditions set forth by the Riley Purgatory Bluff Creek Watershed District shall be addressed by the applicant. Preliminary Plans 1. Show all existing storm sewer and other water resource related features in plans. 2. Adjust and show all easements over the Metropolitan Council Environmental Services’ sanitary sewer on the preliminary and final plat. 3. Clearly indicate what storm sewer will be private and what will be public. All public storm sewer will be required to be shown in profile view. Applicant should confirm there are no conflicts with the watermain or sanitary sewer throughout the site. 4. The following comments pertain to all proposed ponds that include an infiltration bench (Basins 100, 200 and 300): a. Infiltration test results will be required in the location of all proposed infiltration benches and infiltration basins. Infiltration test results have not been submitted in the location of proposed Basin 100. If filtration is to be used, the applicant will need to provide a specification for amended soils. b. The exfiltration above the piped outlet elevation should be included in the HydroCAD model and the exfiltration rate should correspond to what is presented in the infiltration test results. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 25of 45 c. The proposed infiltration benches will be required to meet the 48-hour drawdown requirement. d. Outlets from the pond should be moved out of the permanent pond area and should be moved away from the inlet to minimize the risk of short circuiting. 5. The proposed piped outlet being modeled for Basin 400 is not shown in the plans. 6. Access routes for all proposed stormwater basins are required for maintenance purposes. Applicant should callout access locations for all proposed stormwater basins. 7. A defined riprap EOF spillway will be required for all stormwater basins per details provided on Sheet 33. Applicant should include location and elevation of all EOF spillways on the storm sewer plans. HydroCAD Model 1. The soil borings provided show that there are clay soils throughout the site. Modeling should be updated to reflect the D soils present. 2. Proposed and existing HydroCAD models should be modeling the same area. There is roughly 120 acres included in the existing conditions model that is not included in the proposed conditions model. All offsite drainage should be included in the models. 3. Existing and proposed conditions drainage area maps should be updated to show the location and boundaries of all subcatchments included in the models. 4. Time of concentrations should be calculated in HydroCAD and not directly entered to confirm accuracy. Provide supporting calculations for all directly entered times of concentrations. 5. From the drainage area maps, it appears that P-LU 2-6 (P.E. Edit) in the existing model corresponds to Pond 500P in the proposed conditions model. The modeled storage for the wetland differs between the existing and proposed conditions models but no wetland impacts are shown on Sheet 37 for this wetland. Applicant should update the models so that they have the same storage modeled for the wetland. a. There is a proposed piped outlet from this wetland that is over 4 feet lower than the current natural spillway outlet. The applicant will be required to show that this does not change the hydrology of the existing wetland as part of the wetland permit requirements. 6. There are numerous inconsistencies between what is shown in the plans on Sheet 35 for the outlets of the stormwater basins and what is being modeled in HydroCAD and P8. Applicant will need to update the models so that they are representative of what is being shown in the plans. P8 Model 1. The same total area should be modeled in P8 as in HydroCAD. 2. The model should be run for at least 50 years and should include the most recent precipitation data included in the precipitation file to get accurate removal efficiencies. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 26of 45 3. The modeling of the proposed stormwater ponds with filtration benches is incorrect and is overestimating the removal efficiencies of the basins. The applicant should update the model for the stormwater basins in the following way: a. The design infiltration rate should be added to the flood pool section of the stormwater pond devices where applicable. This will model infiltration above the outlet elevation. The design infiltration rate should match what is being modeled in HydroCAD. b. The infiltration basins should be removed from the model (except for Device 600i). c. Applicant should confirm total phosphorus and total suspended solids removal requirements are still being met after the model has been updated. 4. Watersheds 201 and 600 are only modeling the impervious area. The pervious area in these watersheds should be added to the model. 5. Watershed 300 in the P8 model has 25% impervious while the corresponding HydroCAD subwatershed has 45% impervious modeled. Applicant should update the models to be consistent with one another and representative of the plans. Stormwater Management Plan 1. The total areas listed in the table in Section III.A of the Stormwater Management Plan are inconsistent with the total area called out in the plans and the total area being modeled. Applicant should include the entire site in the areas shown in the table. WETLAND ALTERATION Wetland Protection The plan set shows intent to impact several wetlands on site. A Wetland Replacement Plan application needs to be submitted to the cityand reviewed per the WCA. Many requirements of Article VI have not been addressed. Some of the important requirements include: 1. Any projects seeking a wetland alteration permit subject to this article will also be required to submit the following incomplete requirements: Existing and proposed drainage areas to wetlands; Buffer strip plan meeting the criteria of subsections 20-411(c) and (d). 2. Sec. 20-416. Mitigation. Wetland mitigation shall be undertaken on-site. If this is not feasible, then mitigation may occur locally within the subwatershed. If this is not possible, then mitigation may occur outside the subwatershed, elsewhere in the city. If mitigation cannot be accomplished on-site or if the city deems it necessary to perform mitigation off-site, then the applicant shall be responsible for providing off-site mitigation within the major subwatershed as designated by the Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act, or purchasing wetland credits from the state wetland bank. 3. Stormwater runoff shall not be discharged into wetlands without water quality pretreatment as prescribed by this Code. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 27of 45 4. If a wetland alteration permit is issued allowing wetland alteration, the following standards shall be followed: (1) The alteration will not have a net adverse effect on the ecological and hydrological characteristics of remaining wetland,(2) It shall belocated as to minimize the impact on vegetation, (3) It shall not adversely change water flow, (4) The size of the altered area shall be limited to the minimum required for the proposed action, (5) The disposal of any excess material is prohibited within remaining wetland areas, (6) The disposal of any excess material shall include proper erosion control and nutrient retention measures, (7) Alterations to any wetland area are prohibited during waterfowl breeding season or fish spawning season, unless it is determined by the city that the wetland is not used for waterfowl breeding or fish spawning, (8) Alterations to wetland areas shall be mitigated in accordance with the requirements of this article if the activity results in a loss of wetland area and/or function and value of the wetland. 5. The alteration shall not alter the hydrological patterns in the remainder of the wetland, if a portion of the wetland remains, unless exempted under Sec. 20-417. Please show how hydrologic patterns will not be altered for the remaining wetlands. 6. Sec. 20-405. Wetland delineation. An electronic copy of the delineated wetland boundaries must be submitted in a format compatible with the city's GIS database. 7. Sec. 20-406. Wetland classification. All wetlands delineated under Sec. 20-405 of this article that have not been previously classified shall be classified using the results from the Minnesota Routine Assessment Method for Evaluating Wetland Functions (MnRAM Version 3.0), or future versions. A MnRAM shall be completed by the property owner or applicant for each previously unclassified wetland. An electronic version of the MnRAM evaluation must be submitted to and approved by the city to establish the classification of each wetland prior to any alteration or impact to the wetland. 8. Staff review will be conditional upon an approved Wetland Replacement Plan. 9. A grading permit cannot be issued until the applicant has completed the WCA process. 10. Wetland Buffers. Wetland buffers and buffer monumentation will be required adjacent to the wetlands on site. Please indicate wetland buffers widths and locations where signage will be placed on a plan sheet. Please find additional information on signage placement in the guidance document attached. The WMO provides signs and sign posts for the cost of materials. Alternative signs (by the city or applicant) are also acceptable provided they contain similar information. 11. Sec. 19-146. Wetland elements. a. Water level fluctuations (peak elevation and duration) for wetlands shall be limited to two feet and duration not to exceed 48 hours so as to prevent the destruction of wildlife habitat and wetland vegetation. b. Sedimentation basins or sediment removal devices shall be provided prior to discharge into wetlands. c. Variable bottom contours should be considered to provide deeper holes and flat shallow benches. This feature will provide habitat for diversity of plants and wetland inhabitants for wetland mitigation sites and stormwater basins. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 28of 45 WetlandAcresStatus 141.9preserved 20.18preserved 30.16filled 40.2filled 50.05filled 60.06preserved 70.62preserved 80.17preserved 90.38preserved 100.13preserved 112.79preserved 120.6filled 12A0.04filled 130.03preserved 140.23filled Percent Total47.54100% Filled1.283% Preserved46.2697% City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 29of 45 EROSION PREVENTION & SEDIMENT CONTROL The proposed development will exceed one (1) acre of disturbance and will, therefore, be subject to the General Permit Authorization to Discharge Stormwater Associated with Construction Activity Under the National Pollution Discharge Elimination/State Disposal System (NPDES Construction Permit). The applicant has prepared and submitted a Surface Water Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) to the city for review. The SWPPP is a required submittal element for preliminary plat review. No earth disturbing activities may occur until an approved SWPPP is developed. This SWPPP shall be a standalone document consistent with the NPDES Construction Permit and shall contain all required elements as listed in Parts III and IV of the permit. The SWPPP will need to be updated as the plans are finalized, when the contractor and their sub-contractors are identified and as other conditions change. Financial Assurance. To guarantee compliance with the plan and related remedial work, a cash escrow or letter of credit, satisfactory to the city, shall be furnished to the city before a building permit is issued. The escrow amount shall be $7,500.00 per acre. The city may use the escrow or draw upon the letter of credit to reimburse the city for any labor or material costs it incurs in securing compliance with the plan or in implementing the plan. If the city draws on the escrowed funds, no additional building permits shall be issued until the pre-draw escrow balance has been restored. The city shall endeavor to give notice to the owner or developer before proceeding, but such notice shall not be required in an emergency as determined by the city. The assurance shall be maintained until final stabilization and removal of erosion and sediment controls. STORMWATER UTILITY CONNECTION CHARGES Section 4-30 of City Code sets out the fees associated with surface water management. Water quality and water quantity fees are collected with a subdivision. These fees are based on land use type and are intended to reflect the fact that the more intense the development type, the greater the degradation of surface water. This fee will be applied to the new lot of record being created. It is calculated as shown in the table below: AREA PER ACRE FEEACRESFEE GROSS AREA $8,320191.0465$ 1,589,506.88 SURFACE WATER ROW$8,32016.79$ (139,692.80) DEVELOPMENT FEE OUTLOTS$8,320122.3114$ (1,017,630.85) NET AREA51.9451$ 432,183.23 The SWMP Fee is $432,183.23 pending any plan revisions. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 30of 45 ASSESSMENTS Water and sewer partial hookups are due at the time of final plat. The partial hookup fees will be assessed at the rate in effect at that time. The remaining partial hookups fees are due with the building permit. FEES Based on the proposal,the following fees would be collected with the development contract: Administration Fee: If the improvement costs are between $500,000 and $1,000,000, 2% of the improvement costs. If the improvement costs exceed $1,000,000, 2.5% of the first $1,000,000 plus 1.5% of the remainder. Surface Water Management fee: $432,183.23 A portion of the water hook-up charge: $2,311/unit A portion of the sanitary sewer hook-up charge: $691/unit GIS fees: $25 for the plat plus $10 per parcel Street light operating fee for one year: $300 per light. LANDSCAPING AND TREE PRESERVATION City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 31of 45 The applicant for the Galpin Property development submitted tree canopy coverage and preservation calculations. However, the minimum parkland dedication of 9.1 acres was not included in the calculations; it has been incorporated into staff’s calculations. Total upland area (excl wetlands, bluff and parkland) 130.2 acres Baseline canopy coverage 69% or 89.8 acres Minimum canopy coverage required 46% or 59.8 acres Proposed tree preservation 36% or 47.5 acres The developer does not meet minimum canopy coverage for the site; therefore, the applicant must bring the canopy coverage on site up to the 46% minimum. The difference between the required coverage and the remaining coverage is multiplied by 1.2 for total area to be replaced. One tree is valued at 1,089 SF. Minimum required 59.8 acres Less canopy preserved 47.5 acres Minimum canopy coverage to be replaced 12.3 acres Multiplied by 1.2 14.76 acres Divided by 1089 = Total number of trees to be planted 590 trees The applicant has submitted a landscape plan showing a total of 397 trees to be planted in the development. The applicant shall increase tree planting in the development to meet minimum requirements. While it may seem that tree removal on the site is significant, the intensity of it is regulated to the proposed development of the west side of the property. Out of a total of 89.8 acres, which does not include wooded wetlands, forested bluffs or parkland dedication, 42.3 acres will be removed for homes, but a majority of 47.5 (52% of existing woods) acres will be preserved. This is a positive outcome for the preservation of natural resources on the site. The development is required to install a buffer yard along Galpin Boulevard. Landscaping Item RequiredProposed Bufferyard B – Galpin Boulevard., 12 Overstory trees 12 Overstory trees 1200’ 24 Understory trees 66 Evergreen trees 24 Shrubs0 Shrubs The applicant is also proposing bufferyard planting along the south property line. According to ordinance, a low-density development abutting a low-density development is not required to have a bufferyard. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 32of 45 Landscaping Item RequiredProposed Bufferyard B – South property 0 Overstory trees 6 Overstory trees line, 1050’0 Understory trees 61 Evergreen trees 0 Shrubs0 Shrubs The city well house on Galpin Boulevard abuts the development. Staff recommends that buffer plantings be added to the east of the building. There are also three oaks on city property to the south of the building that appear to be within the grading limits for a proposed pond. Staff recommends that these trees remain and the grading limits be adjusted to provide for preservation by avoiding any grading within the critical root zone areas of the trees. The plant schedule submitted with the landscape plan lists overstory and evergreen tree selections. Applying the city ordinance dealing with species diversity, each type (species) of tree should be in quantities of 40 or less (10% of the total) and each group (Genus) of trees (maples, oaks, etc.) should have no more than 80 specified. Using those designations, staff recommends that Autumn Blaze maples be eliminated from the plant schedule since maples comprise 23% of the total trees and these types of maples are overplanted and have an undesirable structure as they mature. The applicant shall choose a different genus of tree to replace the Autumn Blaze. Other trees which are noted in excess of the maximum quantities allowed include Northern Pin Oak, Black Hills Spruce and White Pine. These quantities must be reduced to a maximum of 10% of the total trees and new varieties of trees added to increase diversity of plantings. Additionally, Northern Pin Oak shall be replaced with white, bur, red or bicolor oak species. The alkaline soils of Chanhassen make the Northern Pin Oak selection undesirable for long-term survivability. Additional selections of tree species should expand the breadth of tree types and take into consideration soil conditions and future hardiness zone changes. Staff has reviewed the tree clearing limits for the development on the plans and on site. There are a number of trees at the edge of the grading limits that staff would like to consider for preservation. Staff requests that the developer conduct a walk-through of the grading limits on site prior to removals with city staff to inspect for opportunities for additional tree preservation. Grading and tree removal is not allowed within the bluff impact zone. The grading plan does not show the impact zone on the plans and proposed grading and tree removal to the top of the bluffs. The applicant shall revise the plans to show the bluff impact zone on both bluffs and eliminate grading within these areas. Additionally, private lot boundaries should not encompass surveyed bluff areas. Property lines could meet the edge of the bluff, but not encroach into it. Staff recommends that lots with significant tree cover contain conservation easements to protect the wooded areas. Lots 101, 104, 105, 130 and 131 should have protective easements over parts of the lot containing existing forest. Specifically, the rear 40’ of Lot 101, the rear 100’ of Lots 104 and 105, the westerly 200’ of Lot 130 and the easterly 250’-300’ of Lot 131. Staff fully supports the clustering of development/density transfer to preserve the significant open space to the east. The existing woods on the east side of the property contain significant City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 33of 45 oaks, maples, and other native species. Many of these trees are over a hundred years old and provide a wooded legacy within the community. Traditional subdivision development would not preserve as many trees and would compromise the health of Lake Ann by removing woods and vegetation along the lakeshore. As stated earlier, the applicant is preserving a majority of the existing woods on site thereby allowing the Chanhassen community, and more directly the residents of this neighborhood, an experience not found in every community whereby significant open space is reachable and accessible from someone’s front door. That experience is a raregem and would offer this neighborhood, and the others adjacent to it, an enhanced quality of life. PARKS & RECREATION Summary Lennar is proposing to develop 191 acres of property located midway between W.78th Street and Lake Lucy Road and east of Galpin Boulevard. The existing zoning is rural residential and the existing guide plan designation is residential low density (1.2- 4 units per acre). Two concept plans were originally submitted by Lennar for consideration. One plan titled Concept Plan 04 depicted an invariable plat of uniform sized residential single-family lots covering all quadrants of the property. A second plan titled Concept Plan 07 depicted a variable plat of mixed lot sizes clustered to the west-central and north-central quadrants of the property, 3.6 units per acre, and preserving 100+/acres of public park area utilizing a density transfer and park dedication in the eastern quadrant of the property. The Park and Recreation Commission supported the density transfer and park dedication proposal at a concept review on June 28, 2018. Background This site has been held as an estate property in the community for an extended period of time and is now being proposed for development as a single-family home community. The property includes a large quadrant of land identified in the city's Comprehensive Plan as conceptual park expansion area and in the city's Parks and Recreation System Plan as a priority park expansion area. This eastern quadrant proposed for preservation is 100+/acres in size consisting of wetlands and wooded uplands and featuring extensive shoreline on both Lake Lucy and Lake Ann. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 34of 45 Discussion Upon completing conceptual plan review with city Commissions and Council this past summer, Lennar also held a neighborhood meeting in November and met with individual residents to receive feedback on the proposed development. The preliminary plat that has developed as a result of the input gained from these reviews, is an excellent model of the use of a PUD. City Code states "The use of a planned unit development for residential purposes should result in a reasonable and verifiable exchange between the city and developer. The developer gains the potential for offering reduced lot sizes and the flexibility indevelopment standards that resultin a combination of reduced development costs and improved marketing flexibility. At the same time, the city should be offered enhanced environmental sensitivity beyond normal ordnance requirements". The city's PUD ordinance addresses the desire for the creation of parks and open space consistent with the city's planning documents. The proposed PUD, with the noted conditions, provides public benefit and helps the city meet stated goals with respect to parks, trails, and open space by: Preserving for the public 100+/acres of unique natural open space with very high recreational and environmental value. This includes 50+/acres of upland around Lake Ann and Lake Lucy that might otherwise be privatized. Providing land and connections for trails to eliminate trail gaps and better connect the community and natural areas. Allowing for the expansion of Lake Ann Park and enhancing its role as Chanhassen's premier community park. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 35of 45 This proposed PUD benefits all parties and ultimately fulfills the desires and intent of the city’s Comprehensive Plan and Park and Recreation System Plan. On December 28, 2018, the city received letters from Lennar and Comerica requesting additional compensation for the proposed 50+/acre dedication ofupland for park purposes above and beyond the granting of full park dedication fee credit ($1,107,800) and application of a density transfer moving housing density from the eastern half of the property to the western half of the property. In that this is a PUD application, staff is not recommending that compensation be granted beyond the density transfer and full park dedication fee credit. RECOMMENDATION Denial “The City Council denies the Rezoning of 191 acres from Rural Residential District, RR, to Planned Unit Development - Residential, PUD-R, including the PUD ordinance “Galpin Design Standards” “The City Council denies the Wetland Alteration Permit of 1.28 acres of wetland impacts subject to conditions in the staff report; “The City Council denies the Subdivision Preliminary Plat creating 181 lots, three outlots and dedication of public right-of-way, as shown in plans prepared by Pioneer Engineering dated February 28, 2019. And The City Council a adopts the attached findings of fact and decision for denial. Approval “The City Council approves the Rezoning of 191 acres from Rural Residential District, RR, to Planned Unit Development - Residential, PUD-R, including the PUD ordinance “Galpin Design Standards” “The City Council approves the Wetland Alteration Permit of 1.28acresofwetland impacts subject to conditions in the staff report; “The City Council approves the Subdivision Preliminary Plat creating 181 lots, three outlots and dedication of public right-of-way, as shown in plans prepared by Pioneer Engineering dated February 28, 2019, subject to conditions in the staff report subject to the following conditions: City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 36of 45 Parks &Recreation 1. Dedication of 100+/- acres of wooded open spaces and wetlands in the eastern half of the property to the City of Chanhassen forparkland in exchange for a housing density transfer and fulfillment of a nine +/-acre parkland dedication requirement. 2. Acknowledgement that the dedicated land may be developed at the city's discretion as parkland for public use and may include, but is not limited to trails, boardwalks, bridges, structures, and signage. 3. The planning, engineering and construction of a 10-foot wide bituminous east/west trail connection between Galpin Boulevard and a location east of Street “D” and a 10-foot wide bituminous trail adjacent to Galpin Boulevard between Street “E” and Street “A”. 4. All trails shall meet all city standards for trail construction. 5. The east/west trail shall maintain a minimum 10-foot setback from outside edges of trail to private property and be designed to minimize encroachment of wetland buffers. 6. The east/west trail crossing of Street “A” shall be relocated from a midblock crossing as shown to the intersection of Street “A” and Street “D”. 7. The east/west trail be designed and constructed so as not to require retaining walls. 8. The entirety of the east/west trail and associated buffers shall be constructed within the dedicated public outlots. 9. The entirety of the Galpin Boulevard trail between Street “E” and Street “A” shall be constructed in dedicated public right-of-way. 10. The planning, engineering and construction of 10-foot wide bituminous trails connecting both Street “Z” and Topaz Drive Ridge Lane to the planned trail at the western edge of Lake Lucy including trail easements. Planning 1. All 191 acres must be included in the PUD. 2. All lots and homes must be developed consistent with the standards in the Compliance Table. 3. Approve the length of the cul-de-sac on Street “Z”. Engineering 1. Any requirements set by the MCES to work within the MCES’s sewer and utility easement shall be addressed by the applicant. 2. An executed agreement between the developer and the MCES allowing work within the MCES’s easement shall be provided to the city prior to the issuance of grading permits. 3. The width of the MCES sewer and utility easement shall be called out on the final plat prior to acceptance and recording. 4. The width of the public right-of-ways shall be called out on the final plat prior to acceptance and recording, this includes radii cul-de-sacs bulbs. 5. Thirty foot (30’)wide drainage and utility easements, for the purpose of accessing utilities and basins, shall be provided between but not limited to Lots 109 and 110 abutting the cul- de-sac of Lucy Ridge Lane and Topaz Drive, Lots 152 and 153 abutting Street “E”, Lots 119 and 120 abutting Street “D”, in the area of Lots 128 and 130 abutting Street “Z” where the City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 37of 45 water main loop is to be installed, andLots 120 and 121 abutting Street “Z” prior to acceptance and recording. 6. Right-of-way dedication in conformance with the attached Carver County Development/Access Review Comments, subject to review and approval by the county and city prior to acceptance and recording of the final plat. 7. On-going coordination with the county and city regarding future improvements to Galpin Boulevard. Also see Condition 25. th 8. The developer shall underground all overhead utilities from W.78 Street to the northern properly line of the development. 9. The developer shall locate on the existing condition survey all existing wells and septic fields. 10. The developer shall abandon all existing wells and septic fields in accordance with all federal, state and local regulatory agency standards, and obtain all necessary permits for said abandonments. Prior to commencement of abandonment activities, a copy of all required permits from the appropriate regulatory agencies shall be provided to the city. 11. Provide an updated existing condition survey that illustrates the MCES sanitary and utility easements on parcels 250100400 and 257580040. 12. The applicant shall submit a mass grading plan or a phased grading plan (as applicable) for review and approval by the city prior to issuance of grading permits. 13. Proposed spot elevations shall be shown on the grading plans at the center of the proposed driveway at the curbline for review prior to issuance of grading permits. 14. Proposed spot elevations shall be shown on the grading plans at top of curb for review prior to issuance of grading permits. 15. Slopes north of Street “Z” called out as 2:1 between stations 6+50 and 11+00 shall be adjusted to achieve a minimum slope of 2.5:1. 16. Drainage arrows for all EOF routes shall be included on the grading plans prior to issuance of grading permits. 17.Grading plans shall be updated to include bluff extents and setbacks. Grading within bluff setbacks is subject to review and approval by the city prior to issuance of grading permits. 18.All existing buildings and structures within the city’s well house #3 property abutting Galpin Boulevard shall be included on the grading plans. 19.Grading plans shall be updated to include the location and grade of the improved and relocated access driveway to well house #3 off Galpin Boulevard. 20.Grading plans shall be updated to include the location and protection methodology of the significant oak tree on the well house #3 site. 21. The low point south of the catch basin (CBMH-306) near the intersection of Street “E” and Street “H” shall be adjusted to be adjacent to the catch basin. 22. The applicant shall submit revised grading plans and stormwater plans so that no stormwater runoff flows directly onto the public trail south of Lots 164-174 abutting Street “A”. 23. Slopes shall not exceed 10% immediately to the east of Lot 110 abutting Street “A” where stormwater conveyance systems are proposed. 24. An updated geotechnical report assessing slope stability immediately east of Lot 110 abutting Street “A” shall be submitted for review and approval prior to the issuance of grading permits. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 38of 45 25. Final grading plans, including pond locations, sizing and analysis, along with right-of-way dedications off Galpin Boulevard, shall conform to the future Galpin Boulevard reconstruction project. Cross reference of grading plans, profiles, and respective cross sections are to be provided at key locations such as intersections, ponds, or other special features required by the county and city for review prior to acceptance and recording of the final plat. 26. All retaining walls exceeding 4’ in height shall have plans and details prepared by a registered engineer or landscape architect prior to issuance of building permits. 27. The retaining wall south of Lots 108-111 abutting Street “A” shall be adjusted to accommodate a 1.5:1 buffer from the bottom of the proposed stormwater line to the bottom of the proposed retaining wall foundation. 28. Spot elevations of top of wall and bottom of wall for the retaining wall behind Lots 161-163 abutting Street “A” shall be included on the grading plans. 29. Grading and construction within bluff setbacks are subject to review and approval by the city prior to issuance of grading permits. This includes, but is not limited to, the retaining wall located south of Lots 123-125 abutting Street “Z”. 30. All newly constructed streets and the extension of any existing streets shall be public streets, owned and maintained by the city,after acceptance of the public improvements by the City Council. 31. All newly constructed public streets shall be designed to meet the current standard specifications and detail plate for residential streets (Detail Plate #5200), unless otherwise directed by the City Engineer. 32. Any and all conditions associated with the alignment and configuration of Street “Z” set by the Planning Commission or City Council shall be addressed by the applicant prior to acceptance and recording of the final plat. 33. The applicant shall remove all impervious surface from the existing Ruby Lane stub-out, construct half street improvements (extending curb and gutter) on Topaz Drive, and restore the area to the surrounding conditions. 34. The existing driveway off Galpin Boulevardlocated on parcel 250100400 shall be abandoned and tied into Street “Z”. 35. A water service lateral shall be stubbed off Street “Z”’s watermain for the future connection to parcel 250100400. 36. An updated geotechnical report with additional soil borings shall be provided for review and approval prior to the commencement of construction. 37. Sidewalks shall be extended along the cul-de-sacs located off Streets “D”, “G”, and “Z” and shall be constructed in accordance with the city’s standard specifications and detail plates for concrete sidewalks. 38. The applicant shall install curb ramps for pedestrian access to stretches of sidewalk greater than 500’ between intersections and/or proposed curb ramps. 39. All curb ramps shall be constructed to meet ADA standards and the city’s Detail Plates #5215-5215D. 40. Intersection improvements to provide pedestrian access at the intersection of Galpin Boulevard and Street “E” shall be constructed in accordance with MUTCD best management practices. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 39of 45 41. A detail of the proposed street lights shall be provided prior to the issuance of building permits. 42. An enumerated list of all street lights and their proposed locations shall be provided for review and approval prior to the recording of the final plat. 43. Street lights shall be installed at all intersections and at the end of each cul-de-sac subject to review and approval of the city prior to issuance of building permits. 44. The site plan shall be updated to provide proposed street grades (centerline gradients). 45. All newly constructed water mains shall be public water mains, owned and maintained by the city,after acceptance of the public improvements by the City Council. 46. Water mains located on Streets “A”-“H” and Street “Z” shall be tied into the high-pressure zone located on Galpin Boulevard. Water main extensions on Topaz Drive and Lucy Ridge Lane shall be tied into the existing water main stubs (low-pressure zone). 47. The water main located on Street “Z” shall be tied into the existing stub off Ruby Lane and a gate valve near the connection point shall be installed. The gate valve shall be closed to separate the pressure zones. 48. The developer shall field verify the location of all water main taps prior to the issuance of building permits and update the plans accordingly. 49. The developer’s contractor shall schedule a preconstruction meeting with Engineering and Public Works Utilities prior to the commencement of any work to the water main installation and tapping. 50. Updated plans indicating the location of all underground utilities on the east side of Galpin Boulevard, along with plans and profiles of any utility crossings on the east side of Galpin Boulevard, shall be submitted for review and approval prior to the issuance of building permits. 51. An agreement that lists the conditions and required improvements for the land swap between the developer and the city regarding Lot 163 and a portion of the well house #3 site, shall be executed and recorded prior to the acceptance and recording of the final plat. 52. All utility crossings of potable water and sanitary and/or storm mains will require 18” of vertical separation and 10’ of horizontal separation. The developer shall submit construction plans with profiles and plan views of the utilities for review and approval prior to the issuance of building permits. 53. All utility crossings of potable water and sanitary sewer will require that the sanitary sewer main at that crossing be constructed of PVC C900 water main material. The developer shall submit construction plans indicating material type at these locations for review and approval of the city prior to issuance of building permits. 54. The developer shall submit construction plans indicating that pipe lengths of sanitary sewer mains are centered over potable water crossings. 55. Water mains shall be constructed at 7.5’ below grade, or insulated, and constructed in conformance with the city’s standard specifications and detail plates. 56. Cluster valves located around water main tees shall be installed at a minimum of 5’ from the tees to the valves, where feasible. All valve locations and any other water main appurtenances shall be reviewed and approved by Engineering and Public Works prior to the issuance of building permits. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 40of 45 57. All comments and conditions regarding fire appurtenances, spacing, and location set forth by the Fire Department shall be addressed by the applicant. 58. All newly constructed sewer mains shall be public sewer mains, owned and maintained by the city after acceptance of the public improvements by the City Council. 59. A 30’ utility easement shall be recorded over the existing public sewer line, within Outlot A located near the south-central area of the preliminary plat, prior to acceptance of final plat. 60. All conditions set forth by the MCES for the direct connection and installation of an access manhole to their trunk line shall be addressed by the applicant, and all permits required for the connection and installation of the manhole shall be obtained prior to the commencement of construction. 61. The applicant shall fieldverify the proposed sanitary sewer connection and existing sewer system configuration at the intersection of Galpin Boulevard and Hunter Drive prior to the submittal of construction plans. 62. The applicant shall ensure the city’s sanitary sewer nomenclature is incorporated in the construction plans. 63. Profile sheets for all public utilities, including sanitary sewer, shall be required for review and approval by the city prior to issuance of building permits. 64. PVC sanitary sewer pipes that will be constructed at a burial depth of 0-16 feet shall be constructed of pipe class SDR 35, burial depths of 16-26 feet shall be of pipe class SDR 26, and burial depths of greater than 26 feet shall be of pipe class C900. 65. Inverts that have a 20 inch or greater differential shall be supplied inside drops per city standards and be constructed per the city’s Detail Plate No. 2104. 66. The applicant shall submit construction drawings that isolate flow directions via separate manholes and independent pipe systems. Stormwater Conditions & Wetlands The SWMP Fee is $432,183.23, pending any plan revisions. This fee will be applied to the new lot of record being created. It is calculated as shown in the table below: AREA PER ACRE FEEACRESFEE GROSS AREA$8,320191.0465$ 1,589,506.88 SURFACE WATER ROW$8,32016.79$ (139,692.80) DEVELOPMENT FEE OUTLOTS$8,320122.3114$ (1,017,630.85) NET AREA51.9451$ 432,183.23 Assessments Water and sewer partial hookups are due at the time of final plat. The partial hookup fees will be assessed at the rate in effect at that time. The remaining partial hookups fees are due with the building permit. Fees Based on the proposal,the following fees would be collected with the development contract: City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 41of 45 Administration Fee: If the improvement costs are between $500,000 and $1,000,000, 2% of the improvement costs. If the improvement costs exceed $1,000,000, 2.5% of the first $1,000,000 plus 1.5% of the remainder. Surface Water Management Fee: $432,183.23 A portion of the water hook-up charge: $2,311/unit A portion of the sanitary sewer hook-up charge: $691/unit GIS fees: $25 for the plat plus $10 per parcel Street light operating fee for one year: $300 per light 1. Wetland permitting is required due to the proximity and proposed impacts to wetlands on site. A wetland permit application has not yet been received by the city from the applicant. Grading permits will not be issued until approved wetland permits have been received. 2. Wetland review will include ensuring hydrology is maintained to all wetlands to be preserved as well as review of proposed stormwater impacts. 3. Storm sewer sizing calculations should be provided to confirm storm sewer is sized to convey the 10-year storm event. 4. An NPDES permit and accompanying Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP) will be required prior to the start of construction. 5. An operations and maintenance plan for the proposed stormwater management system will be required prior to approval. 6. Provide infiltration test results per MPCA Requirements in the location of each proposed infiltration area. 7. All comments and conditions set forth by the Riley Purgatory Bluff Creek Watershed District shall be addressed by the applicant. 8. Show all existing storm sewer and other water resource related features in plans. 9. Adjust and show all easements over the Metropolitan Council Environmental Services’ sanitary sewer on the preliminary and final plat. 10. Clearly indicate what storm sewer will be private and what will be public. All public storm sewer will be required to be shown in profile view. Applicant should confirm there are no conflicts with the watermain or sanitary sewer throughout the site. 11. The following comments pertain to all proposed ponds that include an infiltration bench (Basins 100, 200 and 300): a. Infiltration test results will be required in the location of all proposed infiltration benches and infiltration basins. Infiltration test results have not been submitted in the location of proposed Basin 100. If filtration is to be used, the applicant will need to provide a specification for amended soils. b. The exfiltration above the piped outlet elevation should be included in the HydroCAD model and the exfiltration rate should correspond to what is presented in the infiltration test results. c. The proposed infiltration benches will be required to meet the 48-hour drawdown requirement. d. Outlets from the pond should be moved out of the permanent pond area and should be moved away from the inlet to minimize the risk of short circuiting. 12. The proposed piped outlet being modeled for Basin 400 is not shown in the plans. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 42of 45 13. Access routes for all proposed stormwater basins are required for maintenance purposes. Applicant should callout access locations for all proposed stormwater basins. 14. A defined riprap EOF spillway will be required for all stormwater basins per details provided on Sheet 33. Applicant should include location and elevation of all EOF spillways on the storm sewer plans. 15. The soil borings provided show that there are clay soils throughout the site. Modeling should be updated to reflect the D soils present. 16. Proposed and existing HydroCAD models should be modeling the same area. There is roughly 120 acres included in the existing conditions model that is not included in the proposed conditions model. All offsite drainage should be included in the models. 17. Existing and proposed conditions drainage area maps should be updated to show the location and boundaries of all subcatchments included in the models. 18. Time of concentrations should be calculated in HydroCAD and not directly entered to confirm accuracy. Provide supporting calculations for all directly entered times of concentrations. 19. From the drainage area maps, it appears that P-LU 2-6 (P.E. Edit) in the existing model corresponds to Pond 500P in the proposed conditions model. The modeled storage for the wetland differs between the existing and proposed conditions models but no wetland impacts are shown on Sheet 37 for this wetland. Applicant should update the models so that they have the same storage modeled for the wetland. a. There is a proposed piped outlet from this wetland that is over four feet lower than the current natural spillway outlet. The applicant will be required to show that this does not change the hydrology of the existing wetland as part of the wetland permit requirements. 20. There are numerous inconsistencies between what is shown in the plans on Sheet 35 for the outlets of the stormwater basins and what is being modeled in HydroCAD and P8. Applicant will need to update the models so that they are representative of what is being shown in the plans. 21. The same total area should be modeled in P8 as in HydroCAD. 22. The model should be run for at least 50 years and should include the most recent precipitation data included in the precipitation file to get accurate removal efficiencies. 23. The modeling of the proposed stormwater ponds with filtration benches is incorrect and is overestimating the removal efficiencies of the basins. The applicant should update the model for the stormwater basins in the following way: a. The design infiltration rate should be added to the flood pool section of the stormwater pond devices where applicable. This will model infiltration above the outlet elevation. The design infiltration rate should match what is being modeled in HydroCAD. b. The infiltration basins should be removed from the model (except for Device 600i). c. Applicant should confirm total phosphorus and total suspended solids removal requirements are still being met after the model has been updated. 24. Watersheds 201 and 600 are only modeling the impervious area. The pervious area in these watersheds should be added to the model. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 43of 45 25. Watershed 300 in the P8 model has 25% impervious while the corresponding HydroCAD subwatershed has 45% impervious modeled. Applicant should update the models to be consistent with one another and representative of the plans. 26. The total areas listed in the table in Section III.A of the Stormwater Management Plan are inconsistent with the total area called out in the plans and the total area being modeled. Applicant should include the entire site in the areas shown in the table. 27. Any projects seeking a wetland alteration permit subject to this article will also be required to submit the following incomplete requirements: Existing and proposed drainage areas to wetlands; Buffer strip plan meeting the criteria of subsections 20-411(c) and (d). 28. Sec. 20-416. Mitigation. Wetland mitigation shall be undertaken on-site. If this is not feasible, then mitigation may occur locally within the subwatershed. If this is not possible, then mitigation may occur outside the subwatershed, elsewhere in the city. If mitigation cannot be accomplished on site, or if the city deems it necessary to perform mitigation off site, then the applicant shall be responsible for providing off-site mitigation within the major subwatershed, as designated by the Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act, or purchasing wetland credits from the state wetland bank. 29. Stormwater runoff shall not be discharged into wetlands without water quality pretreatment as prescribed by this Code. 30. If a Wetland Alteration Permit is issued allowing wetland alteration, the following standards shall be followed: (1) The alteration will not have a net adverse effect on the ecological and hydrological characteristics of remaining wetland, (2) It shall be located as to minimize the impact on vegetation, (3) It shall not adversely change water flow, (4) The size of the altered area shall be limited to the minimum required for the proposed action, (5) The disposal of any excess material is prohibited within remaining wetland areas, (6) The disposal of any excess material shall include proper erosion control and nutrient retention measures, (7) Alterations to any wetland area are prohibited during waterfowl breeding season or fish spawning season, unless it is determined by the city that the wetland is not used for waterfowl breeding or fish spawning, and (8) Alterations to wetland areas shall be mitigated in accordance with the requirements of this article if the activity results in a loss of wetland area and/or function and value of the wetland. 31. The alteration shall not alter the hydrological patterns in the remainder of the wetland, if a portion of the wetland remains, unless exempted under Sec. 20-417. Show how hydrologic patterns will not be altered for the remaining wetlands. 32. Sec. 20-405. Wetland delineation. An electronic copy of the delineated wetland boundaries must be submitted in a format compatible with the city's GIS database. 33. Sec. 20-406. Wetland classification. All wetlands delineated under Sec. 20-405 of this article that have not been previously classified shall be classified using the results from the Minnesota Routine Assessment Method for Evaluating Wetland Functions (MnRAM Version 3.0), or future versions. A MnRAM shall be completed by the property owner or applicant for each previously unclassified wetland. An electronic version of the MnRAM evaluation must be submitted to and approved by the city to establish the classification of each wetland prior to any alteration or impact to the wetland. 34. Staff review will be conditional upon the approved Wetland Replacement Plan. 35. A grading permit cannot be issued until the applicant has completed the WCA process. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 44of 45 36. Wetland Buffers. Wetland buffers and buffer monumentation will be required adjacent to the wetlands on site. Please indicate wetland buffers widths and locations where signage will be placed on a plan sheet. Please find additional information on signage placement in the guidance document attached. The WMO provides signs and sign posts for the cost of materials. Alternative signs (by the city or applicant) are also acceptable provided they contain similar information. 37. Sec. 19-146. Wetland elements. a. Water level fluctuations (peak elevation and duration) for wetlands shall be limited to two feet and duration not to exceed 48 hours so as to prevent the destruction of wildlife habitat and wetland vegetation. b. Sedimentation basins or sediment removal devices shall be provided prior to discharge into wetlands. c. Variable bottom contours should be considered to provide deeper holes and flat shallow benches. This featurewill provide habitat for diversity of plants and wetland inhabitants for wetland mitigation sites and stormwater basins. Landscaping and Tree Preservation 1. The developer shall conduct a walk-through of the grading limits on site prior to removals with city staff to inspect for opportunities for additional tree preservation. 2. Tree preservation fencing shall be installed around existing trees to be saved prior to any construction activities and remain installed until completion. 3. All trees shall be planted outside of the street right-of-way. 4. The applicant shall increase tree planting in the development to meet minimum requirements of 590 trees. 5. Buffer plantings shall be added to the east of the city well building. 6. The three oaks on city property (not inventoried) to the south of the city well building shall remain and the grading limits be adjusted to provide for preservation by avoiding any grading within the critical root zone areas of the trees. 7. Autumn Blaze maples shall be eliminated from the plant schedule. 8. Northern Pin Oak shall be replaced with white, bur, red or bicolor oak species in the plant schedule. 9. Additional selections of tree species shall expand the breadth of tree types and take into consideration soil conditions and future hardiness zone changes. 10. No tree Genus shall comprise of more than 20% of the total number of trees and no tree species shall comprise of more than 10% of the total number of trees. 11. The applicant shall revise the plans to show the bluff impact zone on both bluffs and eliminate grading within these areas. 12. Private lot boundaries shall not encroach into bluff areas. 13. Lots with significant tree cover contain conservation easements to protect the wooded areas. Lots 501, 504, 505, 530 and 531 should have protective easements over parts of the lot containing existing forest. Specifically, the rear 40’ of Lot 501, the rear 100’ of Lots 504 and 505, the westerly 200’ of Lot 530 and the easterly 250’-300’ of Lot 531. City Council Galpin Property Preliminary Subdivision Planned Unit Development – Planning Case 2019-01 January 15, 2019 and Updated March11, 2019 Page 45of 45 And The City Council a adopts the attached findings of fact and decision of approval. ATTACHMENTS 1. Staff Report 2. PUD Ordinance 3. Findings of Fact and Decision - approval 4. Finding of Fact and Decision - denial 5. Development Review Application 6. Project Narrative 7. Affidavit of Mailing 8. Compliance Table 9. March 5, 2019 Planning Commission Minutes 10. Exhibit A – Home Styles 11. Pioneer Engineering Plan set dated February 28, 2019 12. Fire Marshall Letter 13. Carver County Development / Access Review Comments Letter 14. MCES Comments 15. Army Corp of Engineers dated 1-8-2019 16. Emailed Comments g:\\plan\\2019 planning cases\\19-01 galpin site preliminary plat and rezoning pud\\pc prelim staff report - 1-15-19.docx CITY OF CHANHASSEN CARVER AND HENNEPIN COUNTIES, MINNESOTA ORDINANCE NO. XXX AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 20 OF THE CHANHASSEN CITY CODE, THE CITY'S ZONING ORDINANCE BY REZONING CERTAIN PROPERTY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF CHANHASSEN ORDAINS: Section 1. Chapter 20 of the Chanhassen City Code, the city's zoning ordinance, is hereby amended by rezoning all property describedwithin Exhibit A from Rural Residential District,RR, to Planned Unit Development Residential, PUD-R. Section 2. The rezoning of this property incorporates the following development design standards: The Galpin Site Zoning Standards a. Intent The purpose of this zone is to create a Planned Unit Development (PUD) for single-family detached housing. The use of the PUD zone is to allow for more flexible design standards while creating a higher quality and more sensitive proposal. The development will preserve 50 acres of woods adjacent to Lake Ann. There are a number of housingcollections with a variety of housing styles and exterior materials with in each collection serving different life stages. Except as modified by this PUD ordinance, the development shall comply with the requirements of the Residential Low and Medium Density District, RLM. The property shall be developed in accordance with the following plans. 1. Preliminary Plat 1 2.Landscaping Plan 3. Tree Preservation Plan 4. House Plans (Exhibit A) b. Permitted Uses 1. The permitted uses in this zoning district shall be single-family detached houses and their accessory uses. House plans include the Lennar Lifestyle, Luxury, Landmark, Classic and Villa home plans or similar or equivalent plans. c. Design Standards 1. Development - Amenities Design Integrate pathways with the local street system to maximize access and flexibility of use. 2 2. House designs There shall be a mix and a variety of housing materials. Linear repetitive streetscape appearance and building facades shall be avoided by providing variation between the front elevations. No two identical facades shall be located next to each other. The same front or rear elevations shall not be located directly across from one another. No similar material/colors shall be located adjacent to each other. There shall be articulation of wall planes, a variety of roof forms, variation in roof heights or other architectural treatments. If side loaded garages are incorporated into the development, the front facing wall must be architecturally integrated with the design of the home (no blank wall). d. Lot Requirements and Setbacks The PUD ordinance requires setbacks from roadways and exterior property lines. The following table displays those setbacks: GALPIN PROPERTY COMPLIANCE TABLE Lot Lot Area Lot Width Lot Impervious (SF) (Feet) Depth Area (SF) (Feet) 90 foot 15,000 90 125 5,500 frontage 90 foot 11,250 90 125 5,500 frontage ** 65 ft Lots 8,450 65 125 4,400 Front Rear Side Yard Corner CR 117 Setback SetbackSetback Setback Setback 20 ft * 25 ft 7.5 ft 20 ft50 ft 25 ft 25 ft 7.5 ft 20 ft50 ft Wetland Buffer Setback 20 ft. *25 ft. with Sidewalk **Lots 101-111 90 foot frontage Lot Lot Area Lot Width Lot Impervious (SF) (Feet) Depth Area (SF) (Feet) 501 18,092 100177 5,500 502 17,455 90 167 5,500 503 15,030 90 167 5,500 504 22,829 90 249 5,500 505 24,572 90 249 5,500 506 16,733 90 175 5,500 507 18,427 90 201 5,500 508 17,037 90 142 5,500 509 23,848 90 159 5,500 510 20,017 90 137 5,500 511 18,801 90 156 5,500 3 512 17,844 90 167 5,500 513 15,032 90 167 5,500 514 15,030 90 167 5,500 515 16,667 100167 5,500 516 15,574 90 175 5,500 517 15,514 90 175 5,500 518 15,482 90 174 5,500 519 15,576 90 174 5,500 520 15,300 90 170 5,500 521 15,300 90 170 5,500 522 15,300 90 170 5,500 523 15,440 90 172 5,500 524 15,882 90 168 5,500 525 16,629 90 136 5,500 526 22,359 90 140 5,500 527 27,426 90 143 5,500 528 16,764 90 160 5,500 529 15,371 90 165 5,500 530 44,983 90 165 5,500 531 47,788 90 125 5,500 90 foot frontage Lot Lot Area Lot Width Lot Impervious (SF) (Feet) Depth Area (SF) (Feet) 101 19,897 135143 5,500 102 13,371 90 148 5,500 103 13,297 90 148 5,500 104 13,297 90 148 5,500 105 13,297 90 148 5,500 106 13,297 90 148 5,500 107 13,297 90 148 5,500 10813,297901485,500 10914,599901485,500 110 14,840 90 148 5,500 111 25,529 90 148 5,500 Avg. 18,479 65 foot frontage Lot Lot Area Lot Width Lot Impervious (SF) (Feet) Depth Area (SF) (Feet) 301 9,993 78 125 4,400 302 8,450 65 125 4,400 303 8,450 65 125 4,400 304 8,450 65 125 4,400 305 8,450 65 125 4,400 306 8,450 65 125 4,400 307 11,132 65 125 4,400 308 13,748 78 131 4,400 309 8,925 65 129 4,400 310 12,282 65 126 4,400 4 311 8,607 65 125 4,400 312 8,126 65 125 4,400 313 8,257 65 125 4,400 314 8,795 65 130 4,400 315 9,683 65 142 4,400 316 12,836 78 125 4,400 317 12,591 78 150 4,400 318 10,414 65 145 4,400 319 10,228 65 145 4,400 320 11,448 65 145 4,400 321 13,180 65 147 4,400 322 12,052 65 145 4,400 323 11,853 65 142 4,400 324 10,767 65 142 4,400 325 9,524 65 139 4,400 326 9,135 65 132 4,400 327 8,609 65 132 4,400 328 8,609 65 132 4,400 329 10,232 65 132 4,400 330 9,750 65 125 4,400 331 9,478 65 125 4,400 332 10,900 65 125 4,400 333 16,107 78 125 4,400 334 11,215 78 136 4,400 335 10,404 65 153 4,400 336 11,607 65 167 4,400 337 10,622 65 142 4,400 338 11,545 65 133 4,400 339 14,532 65 125 4,400 340 12,761 65 125 4,400 341 13,019 65 125 4,400 342 10,858 65 125 4,400 343 10,887 65 163 4,400 344 10,502 65 152 4,400 345 9,306 65 134 4,400 346 10,263 78 125 4,400 347 10,020 78 125 4,400 348 9,385 65 135 4,400 349 10,984 65 154 4,400 350 10,228 65 126 4,400 351 8,474 65 126 4,400 352 8,474 65 125 4,400 353 8,776 65 125 4,400 354 8,864 65 125 4,400 355 13,586 65 131 4,400 356 14,313 65 130 4,400 357 12,790 65 132 4,400 358 12,963 65 125 4,400 359 14,449 65 145 4,400 360 11,360 65 126 4,400 361 11,011 78 125 4,400 5 362 10,508 65 142 4,400 363 11,458 65 145 4,400 364 13,033 65 130 4,400 365 12,790 65 130 4,400 366 12,940 65 132 4,400 367 12,790 65 130 4,400 368 9,728 65 131 4,400 369 10,036 65 140 4,400 370 10,303 78 125 4,400 371 8,933 65 130 4,400 372 9,242 65 130 4,400 373 9,242 65 130 4,400 374 9,242 65 130 4,400 375 9,236 65 130 4,400 376 8,450 65 130 4,400 377 8,450 65 130 4,400 378 8,450 65 130 4,400 379 8,450 65 130 4,400 380 8,450 65 130 4,400 381 8,801 65 130 4,400 382 15,319 95 130 4,400 383 11,772 78 145 4,400 384 9,453 65 145 4,400 385 9,780 65 145 4,400 386 9,898 65 134 4,400 387 9,263 65 130 4,400 388 8,450 65 130 4,400 389 8,450 65 130 4,400 390 8,450 65 130 4,400 391 8,450 65 130 4,400 392 8,450 65 130 4,400 393 8,749 65 130 4,400 394 9,189 65 130 4,400 395 9,390 65 130 4,400 396 9,313 65 130 4,400 397 8,922 65 134 4,400 398 12,754 78 130 4,400 399 8,474 65 130 4,400 400 8,450 65 130 4,400 401 8,450 65 130 4,400 402 8,450 65 130 4,400 403 8,450 65 130 4,400 404 8,450 65 130 4,400 405 10,504 65 130 4,400 406 11,092 65 130 4,400 407 8,819 65 130 4,400 408 8,450 65 130 4,400 409 8,729 65 130 4,400 410 12,658 78 131 4,400 411 10,192 78 127 4,400 412 9,559 65 127 4,400 6 413 9,104 65 145 4,400 414 9,702 65 137 4,400 415 14,151 65 135 4,400 416 9,676 65 135 4,400 417 8,779 65 130 4,400 418 8,570 65 130 4,400 419 9,103 65 136 4,400 420 9,344 65 143 4,400 421 9,170 65 143 4,400 422 10,929 78 132 4,400 423 12,265 78 142 4,400 424 9,984 65 130 4,400 425 10,465 65 130 4,400 426 11,434 65 159 4,400 427 12,108 65 170 4,400 428 12,591 65 178 4,400 429 12,589 65 178 4,400 430 12,101 65 170 4,400 431 10,764 65 130 4,400 432 9,554 65 130 4,400 433 11,046 78 128 4,400 434 12,618 65 141 4,400 435 14,656 65 212 4,400 436 14,357 65 248 4,400 437 14,285 65 248 4,400 438 13,661 65 200 4,400 439 12,931 65 134 4,400 Avg. 10,475 Section 3. The zoning map of the City of Chanhassen shall not be republished to show the aforesaid zoning, but the Clerk shall appropriately mark the zoning map on file in the Clerk's Office for the purpose of indicating the rezoning hereinabove provided for in this ordinance, and all of the notations, references, and other information shown thereon are hereby incorporated by reference and made a part of this ordinance. Section 4. This ordinance shall be effective immediately upon its passage and publication. PASSED AND ADOPTED this ___ day of _____, 2019 by the City Council of the City of Chanhassen, Minnesota. Todd Gerhardt, City Manager Elise Ryan, Mayor (Published in the Chanhassen Villager on ______________________________) 7 CITY OF CHANHASSEN CARVER AND HENNEPIN COUNTIES, MINNESOTA FINDINGS OF FACT AND DECISION IN RE: Application of U. S. Home Corporation, DBA Lennar, and Comerica Bank and Trust, NA, for the Estate of Prince Rogers Nelson and Paisley Park Enterprise, Inc. for Rezoning, Preliminary Plat with a Wetland Alteration Permit. On January 15, 2019, the Chanhassen Planning Commission met at its regularly scheduled meeting to consider the application of U. S. Home Corporation, DBA Lennar, and Comerica Bank and Trust, NA, for the Estate of Prince Rogers Nelson and Paisley Park Enterprise, Inc. for a Rezoning from Rural Residential District, RR, to Planned Unit Development – Residential, PUD-R; Preliminary Plat approval creating 191 lots and three outlots with and approval of a Wetland Alteration Permit to fill and alter wetlands on site. The Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on the proposed rezoning, subdivisionand wetland alteration permit preceded by published and mailed notice. The Planning Commission heard testimony from all interested persons wishing to speak and at the conclusion of the public hearing and discussion by the Planning Commission, McGonagill moved, Tietz seconded that the Planning Commission recommends denial of the rezoning for 191 acres from Rural Residential District (RR) to Planned Unit Development Residential (PUD-R) including PUD ordinance for Galpin Design Standards; the wetland alteration permit and the subdivision preliminary plat creating 191 lots, three outlots and dedication of the right-of-way as shown in plans prepared by Pioneer Engineering dated December 5, 2018. Commissioners McGonagill, Tietz and Randall voted in favor of the motion for denial. Commissioners Madsen, Weick and Aller voted against the motion for denial. The motion tied with a vote of 3 to 3, and, therefore failed. On March 5, 2019, the Planning Commission held a public comment meeting. No formal action was taken. On March 11, 2019, City Council met and reviewed the proposed development. They reviewed the testimony from the Planning Commission. The City Council makes the following: FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The property is currently zoned Rural Residential District (RR). 2. The property is guided in the Land Use Plan for Residential Low Density (net density 1.2-4.0 units per acre) use. The net density of the PUD is 1.3 units an acre. 3. The city’s Comprehensive Plan has identified the eastern portion of this site (49 acres) as future park expansion. This development will dedicate these 49 acres as open space. 1 4. The legal description of the property is: (See Exhibit A) 5. The Zoning Ordinance directs the city to consider six (6) possible adverse affects of the proposed amendment. The six (6) affects and our findings regarding them are: a. The proposed action has been considered in relation to the specific policies and provisions of and has been found to be consistent with the official city Comprehensive Plansince the zoning is consistent with the land use designation of the property, preserves significant areas of natural habitat, trees and vegetation, protects shore landarea, utilizes available infrastructure and provides a variety of housing opportunities; b. The proposed use is and will be compatible with the present and future land uses of the area, which are residential uses to the west, north and south, an arterial roadway to the west and is buffered from existing single-family homes by distance and landscaping. The subdivision buffers existing development/homes on the north and south by matching or exceeding lots sizes and creating a landscape buffer; c. The proposed use conforms to all performance standards contained in the Zoning Ordinance, subject to the conditions of approval for the subdivision and wetland alteration; d. The proposed use will not tend to or actually depreciate the area in which it is proposed since the use is similar to surrounding uses as well as providinga significant area of permanent open space to be enjoyed by the community, which adds value to all the homes; e. The proposed use can be accommodated with existing public services and will not overburden the city's service capacitysince adequate infrastructure is available to the site; and f. Traffic generation by the proposed use is within capabilities of streets serving the property. This subdivision will dedicate the necessary right of way for the upgrade of Galpin Boulevard. 6. The Subdivision Ordinance directs the cityto consider seven (7) possible adverse effects of the proposed subdivision. The seven (7) affects and our findings regarding them are: a. The proposed subdivision complies with the zoning ordinance; b. The proposed subdivision is consistent with all applicable city, county and regional plans including but not limited to the city's Comprehensive Plan; c. The physical characteristics of the site, including but not limited to topography, soils, vegetation, susceptibility to erosion and siltation, susceptibility to flooding, and stormwater drainage are suitable for the proposed development; d. The proposed subdivision makes adequate provision for water supply, storm drainage, sewage disposal, streets, erosion control and all other improvements required by the subdivision ordinance; e. The proposed subdivision will not cause significant environmental damage; f. The proposed subdivision will not conflict with easements of record, but will provide additional required easements; and g. The proposed subdivision is not premature since it is providing all required infrastructure improvements necessary for residential housing as well as improving 2 existing stormwater issues for adjacent properties. A subdivision is premature if any of the following exists: 1)Lack of adequate stormwater drainage. 2) Lack of adequate roads. 3) Lack of adequate sanitary sewer systems. 4) Lack of adequate off-site public improvements or support systems. 7. When approving a Wetland Alteration Permit, the city must determine the capability of a proposed development with existing and proposed uses. The general issuance standards of the conditional use Sec. 20-232, include the following 12 items: a. The proposed development will not be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety, comfort, convenience or general welfare of the neighborhood or the city. While the development impacts several wetlands, the majority of the wetlands (97 percent) are being preserved and protected. The developer shall mitigate any wetland impacts as well as preserve significant areas of permanent open space for enjoyment by the community. b. The proposed development will be consistent with the objectives of the city's Comprehensive Plan and the subdivision and zoning ordinances. The developer shall meet all water quality standards required of it. c. The proposed residential development will be designed, constructed, operated and maintained so to be compatible in appearance with the existing and intended character of the general vicinity and will not change the essential character of that area. The project proposes the development of single-family homes, which currently exist to the south, west and north of this parcel. d. The proposed development will not be hazardous or disturbing to existing or planned neighboring uses. The project proposes single-family homes and a significant public open space. e. The proposed development will be served adequately by essential public facilities and services, including streets, police and fire protection, drainage structures, refuse disposal, water and sewer systems and schools and will be served adequately by such facilities and services provided by the persons or agencies responsiblefor the establishment of the proposed use. The developer shall preserve the easterly outlot as permanent open space. f. The proposed development will not create excessive requirements for public facilities and services and will not be detrimental to the economic welfare of the community, but will increase the value of the community through the provision of additional housing as well as a significant public open space. g. The proposed development will not involve uses, activities, processes, materials, equipment and conditions of operation that will be detrimental to any persons, property or the general welfare because of excessive production of traffic, noise, smoke, fumes, glare, odors, rodents, or trash since the use is similar to adjacent uses. h. The proposed development will have vehicular approaches to the property which do not create traffic congestion or interfere with traffic or surrounding public thoroughfares. Primary access is provided viafull intersectionsoff of a collector street. 3 i. The proposed development will not result in the destruction, loss or damage of solar access, natural, scenic or historic features of major significance. Wetland impacts will be mitigated. A significant amount of the site will be preserved as permanent open space. j. The proposed development will be aesthetically compatible with the area.The project proposes the development of single-family homessimilar to those in the developments to the north, south and west. k. The proposed development will not depreciate surrounding property values. The project proposes the development of residential uses similar to those in the developments to the north, south and west and will increase the value of the community through the provision of additional housing as well as a significant public open space. l. The proposed development will meet standards prescribed for certain uses as provided in Chapter 20, Articles VI, VII, VIII, XIV - Division 1, XXIII and XXIVof the Chanhassen City Code. 8. The Planning Report #2019-01 dated January 15, 2019, and updated March 11, 2019,and prepared by Kate Aanenson, et al, is incorporated herein. MOTION The City Council approves the rezoning of the property from Rural Residential District, RR, to Planned Unit Development - Residential, PUD-R; Preliminary Plat approval creating 181 lots and three outlots; and a Wetland Alteration Permit; and an ordinance amending Chapter 20 of the City Code, subject to the conditions of the staff report. th ADOPTED by the Chanhassen City Council this 11 day of March, 2019. BY: BY: Todd, Gerhardt, City ManagerElise Ryan,Mayor 4 EXHIBIT A Legal Description: Tract A, Registered Land Survey No. 89, files of Registrar of Titles, Carver County, Minnesota. Tract B, Registered Land Survey No. 89, files of Registrar of Titles, Carver County, Minnesota. Tract C, Registered Land Survey No. 89, files of Registrar of Titles, Carver County, Minnesota. That part of the Northeast Quarter of the Northwest Quarter of Section 10, Township 116, Range 23, Carver County, Minnesota, described as follows: Beginning at the North Quarter corner of said Section 10; thence South along the North- South Quarter line of said Section 10 as distance of 409.69 feet; thence West along a line parallel with the South line of the North Half of said Northeast Quarter of the Northwest Quarter a distance of 435.76 feet to the centerline of the Excelsior-Shakopee Road; thence Northeasterly along said centerline a distance of 419.39 feet to the North line of side Section 10; thence East along the North line of said Section 10 to the point of beginning, all according to the U.S. Government Survey thereof. That part of the South half of the Northeast Quarter of the Northwest Quarter of Section 10, Township 116, Range 23 Carver County, Minnesota lying easterly of the centerline of County Road No. 117, also known as Galpin Boulevard, and lying North of the South 186.00 feet of said South half of the Northwest Quarter of the Northwest Quarter thereof. Together with: That part westerly 183.00 feet of each of the following two tracts: (1) That part of the South 186.00 feet of the Northeast Quarter of the th Northwest Quarter of Section 10, Township 116 North, Range 23 West of the 5 Principal Meridian, lying Easterly of the centerline of County Road No. 117 (also known as Galpin Lake Road and formerly known as Chaska and Excelsior Road and as Excelsior and Shakopee Road). (2) That part of the South Half of the Northwest Quarter of Section 10, th Township 116 North, Range 23 West of the 5 Principal Meridian, lying Easterly of the centerline of County Road No. 117 (also known as Galpin Lake Road and formerly known as Chaska and Excelsior Road and as Excelsior and Shakopee Road). Which lies northerly of lines described as follows: Commencing at the Northeast corner of said South Half of the Northwest Quarter; thence on an assumed bearing of North 89 degrees 49 minutes 08 seconds West, along the North line of 5 said South half of the Northwest Quarter a distance of 588.71 feet, to the beginning of the lines to be described; thence South 65 degrees 37 minutes 15 seconds West a distance of 98.69 feet; thence Northwesterly a distance of 141.37 feet along a non-tangential curve concave to the Southwest having a radius of 180.00 feet and a central angle of 45 degrees 00 minutes 00 seconds, the chord of said curve is 137.77 feet in length and bears North 46 degrees 52 minutes 45 seconds West; thence North 69 degrees 22 minutes 45 seconds West, tangent to said curve a distance of 40.00 feet and said line there terminating. g:\\plan\\2019 planning cases\\19-01 galpin site preliminary plat and rezoning pud\\city council 3-11-19\\findings of fact and recommendation cc approval.docx 6 CITY OF CHANHASSEN CARVER AND HENNEPIN COUNTIES, MINNESOTA FINDINGS OF FACT AND DECISION IN RE: Application of U.S. Home Corporation, DBA Lennar, and Comerica Bank and Trust, NA, for the Estate of Prince Rogers Nelson and Paisley Park Enterprise, Inc. for Rezoning, Preliminary Plat with a Wetland Alteration Permit. On January 15, 2019, the Chanhassen Planning Commission met at its regularly scheduled meeting to consider the application of U.S. Home Corporation, DBA Lennar, and Comerica Bank and Trust, NA, for the Estate of Prince Rogers Nelson and Paisley Park Enterprise, Inc. for a Rezoning from Rural Residential District, RR, to Planned Unit Development – Residential, PUD-R; Preliminary Plat approval creating 191 lots and three outlots with and approval of a Wetland Alteration Permit to fill and alter wetlands on site. The Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on the proposed rezoning, subdivision and wetland alteration permit preceded by published and mailed notice. The Planning Commission heard testimony from all interested persons wishing to speak and at the conclusion of the public hearing and discussion by the Planning Commission, McGonagill moved, Tietz seconded that the Planning Commission recommend denial of the rezoning for 191 acres from Rural Residential District (RR) to Planned Unit Development Residential (PUD-R) including the PUD ordinance for Galpin Design Standards; the wetland alteration permit and the subdivision preliminary plat creating 191 lots, three outlots and dedication of the right-of-way as shown in plans prepared by Pioneer Engineering dated December 5, 2018. Commissioners McGonagill, Tietz and Randall voted in favor of the motion for denial. Commissioners Madsen, Weick and Aller voted against the motion for denial. The motion tied with a vote of 3 to 3 and, therefore, failed. On March 5, 2019, the Planning Commission held a public comment meeting. No formal action was taken. On March 11, 2019, the City Council met and reviewed the proposed development. They reviewed the testimony from the Planning Commission. The City Council makes the following: FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The property is currently zoned Rural Residential District (RR). 2. The property is guided in the Land Use Plan for Residential Low Density (net density 1.2-4.0 units per acre) use. 3. The legal description of the property is: (See Exhibit A) 1 4. The Zoning Ordinance directs the cityto consider six (6) possible adverse affects of the proposed amendment. The six (6) affects and our findings regarding them are: a.The proposed action has been considered in relation to the specific policies and provisions of and has been found to be inconsistent with the official city Comprehensive Plan since the zoning and resultant cluster development does not create a homogeneous development with the single-family zoning to the north and south of the project; b. The proposed use is not compatible with the present and future land uses of the area since it consists of cluster housing development, rather than the single-family residential uses to the west, north and south on 15,000 square foot or larger lots; c. The proposed use does not conform to all performance standards contained in the Zoning Ordinance for any existing residential zoning categories; d. The proposed use may not tend to or actually depreciate the area in which it is proposed since the use is similar, but not the same as surrounding uses; e. The proposed use can be accommodated with existing public services and will not overburden the city's service capacity since adequate infrastructure is available to the site; and f. Traffic generation by the proposed use is within capabilities of streets serving the property. 5. The Subdivision Ordinance directs the city to consider seven (7) possible adverse effects of the proposed subdivision. The seven (7) affects and our findings regarding them are: a. The proposed subdivision does not comply with the zoning ordinance; b. The proposed subdivision is inconsistent with all applicable city plans including but not limited to the city's Comprehensive Plan since it does not create a homogeneous development with the single-family zoning to the north and south of the project; c. The physical characteristics of the site, including but not limited to topography, soils, vegetation, susceptibility to erosion and siltation, susceptibility to flooding, and stormwater drainage are suitable for the proposed development; d. The proposed subdivision makes adequate provision for water supply, storm drainage, sewage disposal, streets, erosion control and all other improvements required by the subdivision ordinance; e. The proposed subdivision will not cause significant environmental damage; f. The proposed subdivision will not conflict with easements of record, but will provide additional required easements; and g. The proposed subdivision is not premature since it is providing all required infrastructure improvements necessary for residential housing as well as improving existing stormwater issues for adjacent properties. A subdivision is premature if any of the following exists: 1) Lack of adequate stormwater drainage. 2) Lack of adequate roads. 3) Lack of adequate sanitary sewer systems. 4) Lack of adequate off-site public improvements or support systems. 2 6. Planned unit developments offer enhanced flexibility to develop a site through the relaxation of most normal zoning district standards. The use of the PUD zoning also allows for a greater variety of uses, internal transfers of density, construction phasing and a potential for lower development costs. In exchange for this enhanced flexibility, the city has the expectation that the development plan will result in a significantly higher quality and more sensitive proposal than would have been the case with the use of other, more standard zoning districts. The applicanthas not demonstrated that the city's expectation is to be realized as evaluated against the following criteria. Planned unit developments are to encourage the following: a. Preservation of desirable site characteristics and open space and protection of sensitive environmental features, including steep slopes, mature trees, creeks, wetlands, lakes and scenic views. b. More efficient and effective use of land, open space and public facilities through mixing of land uses and assembly and development of land in larger parcels. c. High quality of design and design compatible with surrounding land uses, including both existing and planned. Site planning, landscaping and building architecture should reflect higher quality design than is found elsewhere in the community. d. Sensitive development in transitional areas located between different land uses and along significant corridors within the city. e. Development that is consistent with the comprehensive plan. f. Parks and open space. The creation of public open space may be required by the city. Such park and open space shall be consistent with the comprehensive park plan and overall trail plan. g. Provision of housing affordable to all income groups if appropriate within the PUD. h. Energy conservation through the use of more efficient building designs and sightings and the clustering of buildings and land uses. i. Use of traffic management and design techniques including the provision of transit and pedestrian linkages to reduce the potential for traffic conflicts. Improvements to area roads and intersections may be required as appropriate. Where appropriate, the use of transportation demand management strategies may be required within a project. 7. When approving a Wetland Alteration Permit, the city must determine the capability of a proposed development with existing and proposed uses. The general issuance standards of the conditional use Sec. 20-232, include the following 12 items: a. The proposed development will not be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety, comfort, convenience or general welfare of the neighborhood or the city. While the development impacts several wetlands, the majority of the wetlands (97 percent) are being preserved and protected. The developer shall mitigate any wetland impacts as well as preserve significant areas of permanent open space for enjoyment by the community. b. The proposed development is inconsistent with the objectives of the city's Comprehensive Plan and the subdivision and zoning ordinances. The developer shall meet all water quality standards required of it. c. The proposed residential development is not designed, constructed, operated and maintained so to be compatible in appearance with the existing and intended character of 3 the general vicinity and will change the essential character of that area. The project proposes the development of single-family homes thatare on smaller lots than currently exist to the south, west and north of this parcel. d. The proposed development will not be hazardous, but aredisturbing to existing or planned neighboring uses. The project proposes single-family homes on smaller lots than surrounding development. e. The proposed development will be served adequately by essential public facilities and services, including streets, police and fire protection, drainage structures, refuse disposal, water and sewer systems and schools and will be served adequately by such facilities and services provided by the persons or agencies responsible for the establishment of the proposed use. f. The proposed development will not create excessive requirements for public facilities and services and will not be detrimental to the economic welfare of the community but will increase the value of the community through the provision of additional housing as well as a significant public open space. g. The proposed development will not involve uses, activities, processes, materials, equipment and conditions of operation that will be detrimental to any persons, property or the general welfare because of excessive production of traffic, noise, smoke, fumes, glare, odors, rodents, or trash since the use is similar to adjacent uses. h. The proposed development will have vehicular approaches to the property that do not create traffic congestion or interfere with traffic or surrounding public thoroughfares. Primary access is provided via full intersections off of a collector street. i. The proposed development will not result in the destruction, loss or damage of solar access, natural, scenic or historic features of major significance. Wetland impacts will be mitigated. j. The proposed development will not be aesthetically compatible with the area since it consists of lots smaller than adjacent development. The project proposes the development of single-family homes on smaller lots than to those in the developments to the north, south and west. k. The proposed development will not depreciate surrounding property values. The project proposes the development of residential uses. l. The proposed development will meet standards prescribed for certain uses as provided in Chapter 20, Articles VI, VII, VIII, XIV - Division 1, XXIII and XXIV of the Chanhassen City Code. 8. The Planning Report #2019-01 dated January 15, 2019, and updated March 11, 2019, prepared by Kate Aanenson, et al, is incorporated herein. 4 MOTION The City Council deniesthe rezoning of the property from Rural Residential District, RR, to Planned Unit Development - Residential, PUD-R; Preliminary Plat approval creating 181 lots and three outlots; and aWetland Alteration Permit; and an ordinance amending Chapter 20 of the City Code. th ADOPTED by the Chanhassen City Council this 11day of March, 2019. BY: BY: Todd, Gerhardt, City ManagerElise Ryan, Mayor 5 EXHIBIT A Legal Description: Tract A, Registered Land Survey No. 89, files of Registrar of Titles, Carver County, Minnesota. Tract B, Registered Land Survey No. 89, files of Registrar of Titles, Carver County, Minnesota. Tract C, Registered Land Survey No. 89, files of Registrar of Titles, Carver County, Minnesota. That part of the Northeast Quarter of the Northwest Quarter of Section 10, Township 116, Range 23, Carver County, Minnesota, described as follows: Beginning at the North Quarter corner of said Section 10; thence South along the North- South Quarter line of said Section 10 as distance of 409.69 feet; thence West along a line parallel with the South line of the North Half of said Northeast Quarter of the Northwest Quarter a distance of 435.76 feet to the centerline of the Excelsior-Shakopee Road; thence Northeasterly along said centerline a distance of 419.39 feet to the North line of side Section 10; thence East along the North line of said Section 10 to the point of beginning, all according to the U.S. Government Survey thereof. That part of the South half of the Northeast Quarter of the Northwest Quarter of Section 10, Township 116, Range 23 Carver County, Minnesota lying easterly of the centerline of County Road No. 117, also known as Galpin Boulevard, and lying North of the South 186.00 feet of said South half of the Northwest Quarter of the Northwest Quarter thereof. Together with: That part westerly 183.00 feet of each of the following two tracts: (1) That part of the South 186.00 feet of the Northeast Quarter of the th Northwest Quarter of Section 10, Township 116 North, Range 23 West of the 5 Principal Meridian, lying Easterly of the centerline of County Road No. 117 (also known as Galpin Lake Road and formerly known as Chaska and Excelsior Road and as Excelsior and Shakopee Road). (2) That part of the South Half of the Northwest Quarter of Section 10, th Township 116 North, Range 23 West of the 5 Principal Meridian, lying Easterly of the centerline of County Road No. 117 (also known as Galpin Lake Road and formerly known as Chaska and Excelsior Road and as Excelsior and Shakopee Road). Which lies northerly of lines described as follows: Commencing at the Northeast corner of said South Half of the Northwest Quarter; thence on an assumed bearing of North 89 degrees 49 minutes 08 seconds West, along the North line of 6 said South half of the Northwest Quarter a distance of 588.71 feet, to the beginning of the lines to be described; thence South 65 degrees 37 minutes 15 seconds West a distance of 98.69 feet; thence Northwesterly a distance of 141.37 feet along a non-tangential curve concave to the Southwest having a radius of 180.00 feet and a central angle of 45 degrees 00 minutes 00 seconds, the chord of said curve is 137.77 feet in length and bears North 46 degrees 52 minutes 45 seconds West; thence North 69 degrees 22 minutes 45 seconds West, tangent to said curve a distance of 40.00 feet and said line there terminating. g:\\plan\\2019 planning cases\\19-01 galpin site preliminary plat and rezoning pud\\city council 3-11-19\\findings of fact and recommendation cc denial.docx 7 Galpin Property City of Chanhassen Introduction U.S. Home Corporation, d/b/a Lennar is proposing to develop Galpin Property (actual name TBD) in a manner that is sensitive to the environment and surrounding area. With this Preliminary Plat we are submitting a plan that has taken into account input from public leaders, staff, and neighbors. Our plan has 191 homes demonstrating how the property can be developed through the use of a PUD that will offer diversehousing opportunities and price points accompanied by the preservation of open space. Background/History In November 2017 the property was listed for sale by Comerica Bank; Trust NA, as personal representatives of the Estate of Prince Rogers Nelson and Paisley Park Enterprises. On several occasions the seller’s agents and members of Lennar have met with City staff to begin reviewing the zoning standards and the best use for the property. In May of 2018 U.S. Home Corporation entered into an Option Agreement to purchase the property. Property Description The site consists of approximately 188 acres made up of several tax parcels (PID 25.6900010, 25.6900020, 25.6900030, 25.0100100, and 25.0100200) located in the Notheast Quarter of the Northwest Quarter of Section 10, Township 116, Range 23. All buildings have been removed and the property has been vacant for some time. The site suffers from frequent trespassers that use the property for walking trails. City Standards Land Usedesignation The property is designated for Low Density residential: RSF 1.2-4 units per acre. Pre-plat – 1.37 DU/Acre Zoning Classification The site is currently zoned as Rural Residential with underlying zoningofRSF; low density residential 1.2-4 units per acre. Our plan requires a zoning change to PUD to allow flexibility and the relaxation of strict application of the zoning ordinance in exchange for greater environmental sensitivity and preservation of open space for public use.At 1.37units per acre ourplan alsofits into the low range of the RSF density classification. 1 Surrounding Land Uses Residential developments of varying densities surround the site to the North, South, and West. To the West, across Galpin is Long Acres which was developed as a PUD to allow flexibility in design standards. Our primary street connections appropriately line up with Hunter Drive and Long Acres Drive. Boarding the property to the North and South are existing neighborhoods zoned RSF. The existing neighborhoods to the North (Ashling Meadows and Lucy Ridge) provide road stubs to the subject property. There are no road connections to the South. Lake Lucy, and Lake Ann and their surrounding wetlands are located to the East. Plan modifications since initial concept review Overall 50+ acres designated for City Park Lot count has been reduced to 191 homesites (1.37 DU/Acre) Stormwater ponding has been incorporated to accommodate Galpin Rd upgrades Perimeter buffering has been evaluated North end Through street from Galpin to Lucy Ridge has been eliminated Buffering through preservation has been identified 14 Lots have been eliminated to minimize environmental impacts South end Density in Southern 1/3 of the property has decreased Lots along Southern property line have been enlarged from 55’ wide to 75’ wide to accommodate standard homes rather than Villa. Storm sewer and Emergency Overflows have been identified to alleviate water issues in adjacent neighborhood Back yard areas along South property line have been expanded allowing for the preservation of existing trees Landscape buffering has been integrated into the plan Open Space Preservation The City of Chanhassen’s 2030 Comprehensive Plan identifies significant trail improvements along the Eastern boundary of the property that would enhance the Lake Ann Park and trail system by completing important connections between Lake Ann, Lake Lucy and Galpin Road. Our plan for the Galpin property focuses housing development closer to Galpin and preserves approximately 50 acres of land adjacent to Lake Lucy and Lake Ann that could be used for park dedication to the City. By mixing lot sizes our plan strategically places the 191homes on 88 acres of land giving the opportunity to preserve significantly more open space for use by the residents of Chanhassen then would be available if strict RSF 2 zoning standards were followed. Preserving the open space in this manner not only minimizes environmental impacts but also significantly reduces the length of public infrastructure (sewer, water, roads) required for long term maintenance by the City. Building Plans/Product Information Extensive research on housing availability and market conditions within the City of Chanhassen has guided us in putting together a plan that is matched by a product portfolio that includes architecturally interesting variety of homes, and price points, that meet multiple buyer niches. Landmark Series - Designed with efficiency in mind, the Landmark series meets the demands of today’s challenging housing market by offering a fantastic value planned specially for 65’& 75’ wide homesites. Lennar has successfully built the Landmark series in Reflections at Lake Riley, Boulder Cove, and Camden Ridge. Typical footprints are 50’ wide allowing the ability to maintain setbacks designated by zoning standards. A variety of houseplans and elevations make up this series offering square footages ranging from 2,200 sq ft to 3,200 sq ft plus the ability to finish the basement to add footage to the home. With families in mind, the homes typically include four bedrooms, a large open living space on the main level, a master suite, mud room, and three car garage. Sixty-five foot wide lots allow the ability to preserve open space without compromising the integrity of the neighborhood. Typical side yard setbacks will be maintained. An interesting streetscape will be maintained through the incorporation of a variety of elevations, materials, and color packages. Lots are arranged in a manner that will include an assortment of walk-outs, look-outs, and flats. The 75’ wide lots will provide additional spacing and allow the opportunity to expand certain elevations to include a four-car garage. Included in this series are Lennar’sNextGen plans. This revolutionary series is a multi-generational home plan designed specifically to accommodate generations living under one roof with privacy and convenience. This truly unique home highlights the ‘NextGen suite’ that provides a separate first floor living space with its own entrance, living area, kitchenette, attached garage andlaundryall under one roof with access to the rest of the home. The result is a 5-bedroom, 5 bathroom home that creatively satisfies a variety of unique housing needs while fitting into the architectural styling of the neighborhood. Luxury Villa – The 34Luxury Villa aredesigned for the 55’ wide homesites just North of the Southern entrance. The LuxuryVilla provides minimal maintenance housing for an underserved market in Chanhassen; and the Twin Cities in general, the ‘empty nester’. Designed for single level living, the Villa homes offer a spacious first floor that includes a master suite, fireplace, open living room, gourmet kitchen, and study. A deck or three season porch is included with the home to allow the opportunity to enjoy the natural features of Galpin Property . Multiple elevations and color packages will be incorporated to reduce monotony. 3 Traditional -The 31 Traditional homesites on the North end of the property are currently being marketed for sale to custom homebuilders. We are requesting a lot split that would allow that portion of the site to be developed in the future, perhaps by another entity. It is recognized the lot split will not release the North portion of the site from the responsibilities of the overall PUD request. Lennar ultimately reserves the abilityto participate in development and construction of homes in that area but does not have the intention to do so at this time. Environmental Impacts Wetlands - A wetland delineation was completed on the site in September 2017 and was followed by a Wetland classification analysis. Wetland impacts have been minimized by careful planning and the preservation of open space. Following RSF standards for the entire property would require more impact to existing wetlands for the extension of public infrastructure (sewer, water, streets) to serve the upland adjacent to Lake Ann and Lake Lucy. Tree Preservation – Preservation of open space for public use will allow the opportunity to preserve large wooded areas that may otherwise be disturbed with development. Tree replacement as required by code has been factored into the landscape plan. Following the RSF zoning guidelines would have a much greater impact on the large stands of trees located in the upland areas fronting Lake Ann and Lake Lucy that are contemplated by Public Park with this plan. Water Quality – Water quality will be managed through the incorporation of on- site ponding and other appropriate erosion control measures. We are evaluating the potential for water re-use on site to supplement irrigation systems. Lennar is committed to following stormwater policies enacted by the City of Chanhassen and the Minnesota Pollution Control Association (MPCA). Plans have been submitted to the Riley Purgatory Watershed to allow for the simultaneous review of stormwater management designs. Impervious Surface – Lennar recognizes the importance of managing the runoff of hard surface areas. To help regulate standards we have created the following table to set average thresholds for each sized homesite. Note: A more detailed table specific to each homesite has been provided with the other submission materials. To help inform customers of these standards Lennar intends to provide each customer with a copy of their lot certificate that includes the current impervious 4 area, the maximum impervious area allowed, and the remaining impervious area left for future improvements such as patios, 4-season porches, and pools. Flexibility through the use of PUD Our plan requires a zoning change to PUD to allow flexibility and the relaxation of strict application of the zoning ordinance in exchange for greater environmental sensitivity and preservation of open space for public use. The items we are requesting flexibility include; lot width and area, cul de sac length, and relaxation of front setbacks along the North and South boarders. All three items are requested for consideration to allow for the preservation of open space and trees. Homeowners Association(s) A Master Homeowners Association will be established to maintain private common areas and community monuments. A Sub-Association will be created to take care of the common elements within the Villa area. The Villa will be ‘full maintenance’ in nature to include; professional management, mowing, plowing, and exterior upkeep of the homes. Owners of single family homes will be responsible for their own upkeep and maintenance subject to City Ordinance and Architectural Controls established within the Master Association. Summary Lennar has a long history of building successful Communities in the City of Chanhassen under the names Lennar, Ryland, Lundgren Bros. Construction, and Orrin Thompson Homes. We are very excited for the opportunity that lends itself through the careful development of this fantastic property and ask for your support. (US Home/Lennar) Galpin Property – 191 Gross Acres Total Homesites – 191 Approximate Developed Area – 89 acres Open Space – 50 acres Preserved wetlands – 49 acres Traditional homesites – 31 Average Lot – 90’ wide Landmark Homesites – 126 Average Lot – 65’ wide -115 75’ wide -11 Villa Homesites – 34 Average Lot – 55’ wide 5 Project Team Developer: U.S. Home Corporation, D/B/A Lennar Builder: Lennar Corporation Primary Contact: Joe Jablonski Planner/Engineer/Surveyor: Pioneer Engineering Geotechnical Engineer: Braun Intertec Wetland Specialist: Midwest Natural Resources, Inc. Landscape Architect: Pioneer Engineering Legal Council: Vantage Law Group Association Manager: TBD 6 HBMQJO!QSPQFSUZ DPNQMJBODF!UBCMF Mpu!Xjeui!Mpu!Efqui!Jnqfswjpvt!Bsfb! Mpu!Bsfb!)TG*)Gffu*)Gffu*)TG* Mpu :1!gu!MputQVE26-111:12366-611 :1!gu!Mput!!!!QVE++22-361:12366-611 76!gu!MputQVE9-561762365-511 GspouTjef!Zbse!Dpsofs TfucbdlSfbs!TfucbdlTfucbdlTfucbdlDS!228!Tfucbdl :1!gu!Mput!!!31!gu!+36!gu8/6!gu31!gu61!gu 76!gu!Mput!36!gu!36!gu8/6!gu31!gu61!gu Xfumboe!Cvggfs!Tfucbdl!31!gu/ +!36!gu!xjui!Tjefxbml ++Mput!212.222 Mpu!Xjeui!Mpu!Efqui!Jnqfswjpvt!Bsfb! Mpu!Bsfb!)TG*)Gffu*)Gffu*)TG* :1!gu!MputMpu 50118,0921001775,500 50217,455901675,500 50315,030901675,500 50422,829902495,500 50524,572902495,500 50616,733901755,500 50718,427902015,500 50817,037901425,500 50923,848901595,500 51020,017901375,500 51118,801901565,500 51217,844901675,500 51315,032901675,500 51415,030901675,500 51516,6671001675,500 51615,574901755,500 51715,514901755,500 51815,482901745,500 51915,576901745,500 52015,300901705,500 52115,300901705,500 52215,300901705,500 52315,440901725,500 52415,882901685,500 52516,629901365,500 52622,359901405,500 52727,426901435,500 52816,764901605,500 52915,371901655,500 53044,983901655,500 53147,788901255,500 Mpu!Xjeui!Mpu!Efqui!Jnqfswjpvt!Bsfb! Mpu!Bsfb!)TG*)Gffu*)Gffu*)TG* :1!gu!MputMpu 10119,8971351435,500 10213,371901485,500 10313,297901485,500 10413,297901485,500 10513,297901485,500 10613,297901485,500 10713,297901485,500 10813,297901485,500 10914,599901485,500 11014,840901485,500 11125,529901485,500 Mpu!Xjeui!Mpu!Efqui!Jnqfswjpvt!Bsfb! Mpu!Bsfb!)TG*)Gffu*)Gffu*)TG* 76!gu!MputMpu 3019,993781254,400 3028,450651254,400 3038,450651254,400 3048,450651254,400 3058,450651254,400 3068,450651254,400 30711,132651254,400 30813,748781314,400 3098,925651294,400 31012,282651264,400 3118,607651254,400 3128,126651254,400 3138,257651254,400 3148,795651304,400 3159,683651424,400 31612,836781254,400 31712,591781504,400 31810,414651454,400 31910,228651454,400 32011,448651454,400 32113,180651474,400 32212,052651454,400 32311,853651424,400 32410,767651424,400 3259,524651394,400 3269,135651324,400 3278,609651324,400 3288,609651324,400 32910,232651324,400 3309,750651254,400 3319,478651254,400 33210,900651254,400 33316,107781254,400 33411,215781364,400 33510,404651534,400 33611,607651674,400 33710,622651424,400 33811,545651334,400 33914,532651254,400 34012,761651254,400 34113,019651254,400 34210,858651254,400 34310,887651634,400 34410,502651524,400 3459,306651344,400 34610,263781254,400 34710,020781254,400 3489,385651354,400 34910,984651544,400 35010,228651264,400 3518,474651264,400 3528,474651254,400 3538,776651254,400 3548,864651254,400 35513,586651314,400 35614,313651304,400 35712,790651324,400 35812,963651254,400 35914,449651454,400 36011,360651264,400 36111,011781254,400 36210,508651424,400 36311,458651454,400 36413,033651304,400 36512,790651304,400 36612,940651324,400 36712,790651304,400 3689,728651314,400 36910,036651404,400 37010,303781254,400 3718,933651304,400 3729,242651304,400 3739,242651304,400 3749,242651304,400 3759,236651304,400 3768,450651304,400 3778,450651304,400 3788,450651304,400 3798,450651304,400 3808,450651304,400 3818,801651304,400 38215,319951304,400 38311,772781454,400 3849,453651454,400 3859,780651454,400 3869,898651344,400 3879,263651304,400 3888,450651304,400 3898,450651304,400 3908,450651304,400 3918,450651304,400 3928,450651304,400 3938,749651304,400 3949,189651304,400 3959,390651304,400 3969,313651304,400 3978,922651344,400 39812,754781304,400 3998,474651304,400 4008,450651304,400 4018,450651304,400 4028,450651304,400 4038,450651304,400 4048,450651304,400 40510,504651304,400 40611,092651304,400 4078,819651304,400 4088,450651304,400 4098,729651304,400 41012,658781314,400 41110,192781274,400 4129,559651274,400 4139,104651454,400 4149,702651374,400 41514,151651354,400 4169,676651354,400 4178,779651304,400 4188,570651304,400 4199,103651364,400 4209,344651434,400 4219,170651434,400 42210,929781324,400 42312,265781424,400 4249,984651304,400 42510,465651304,400 42611,434651594,400 42712,108651704,400 42812,591651784,400 42912,589651784,400 43012,101651704,400 43110,764651304,400 4329,554651304,400 43311,046781284,400 43412,618651414,400 43514,656652124,400 43614,357652484,400 43714,285652484,400 43813,661652004,400 43912,931651344,400 Mpu!Xjeui!Mpu!Efqui!Jnqfswjpvt!Bsfb! Mpu!Bsfb!)TG*)Gffu*)Gffu*)TG* 66!gu!MputMpu 20111,262551153,400 2028,851551483,400 2038,645551463,400 2048,659551463,400 2058,894551493,400 2069,079551563,400 2079,043551653,400 2088,470551323,400 20913,623551153,400 21010,635551373,400 21111,580551393,400 21210,688551323,600 21313,820551243,600 2149,059551643,400 2157,285551323,400 2167,285551323,400 2177,488551333,400 2189,065551313,400 2198,605551243,400 2206,824551223,400 2217,222551403,400 2228,456551683,400 22311,920551763,400 22410,548551283,400 2257,164551313,400 2269,284551273,600 2278,832551263,600 2286,875551253,400 2296,875551253,400 2306,875551253,400 2316,875551253,400 2326,875551253,400 2337,651551263,400 23410,745551423,400 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Wbmfodjb! WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO B C D E MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Wbmfodjb! WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO 2-647!Tr/!Gu/! Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf! sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz! eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe! xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf!bhsffnfou!gps! bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t! Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-! ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs! ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t! sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz!dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi!bsf! opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif! sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot! xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe! trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme! opu!cf!vtfe!bt!sfqsftfoubujpo!pg!uif!ipnf“t! qsfdjtf!ps!bduvbm!tj{f/!Boz!tubufnfou-!wfscbm! pg!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!tj{f!pg!boz!ipnf!jt! b!tipsuiboe!eftdsjqujpo!pg!uif!nboofs!jo! xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe! tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/! Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf! boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju! Mfoobs/dpn!ps!tff!b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou! mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft! xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf! qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!3126!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif! Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif! Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe! tfswjdf!nbslt!ps!tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/! Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs! —!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs! Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/! Mjd!$!CD112524/)27854*!507028 Nbjo!Mfwfm 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf! 711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Wbmfodjb! WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpot 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27854*!507028 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Wbmfodjb! WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpobm!Gjojtife!Cbtfnfou 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27854*!507028 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Pygpse WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO B C D E MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Pygpse WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO 2-652!Tr/!Gu/! Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf! sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz! eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe! xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf!bhsffnfou!gps! bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t! Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-! ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs! ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t! sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz!dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi!bsf! opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif! sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot! xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe! trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme! opu!cf!vtfe!bt!sfqsftfoubujpo!pg!uif!ipnf“t! qsfdjtf!ps!bduvbm!tj{f/!Boz!tubufnfou-!wfscbm! pg!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!tj{f!pg!boz!ipnf!jt! b!tipsuiboe!eftdsjqujpo!pg!uif!nboofs!jo! xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe! tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/! Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf! boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju! Mfoobs/dpn!ps!tff!b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou! mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft! xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf! qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!3126!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif! Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif! Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe! tfswjdf!nbslt!ps!tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/! Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs! —!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs! Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/! Mjd!$!CD112524/)27858*!507028 Nbjo!Mfwfm 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf! 711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Pygpse WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpot 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27858*!507028 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Pygpse WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpobm!Cbtfnfou 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27858*!507028 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Cvdljohibn WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO 2-:41!Tr/!Gu/! Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf! sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz! eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe! xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf!bhsffnfou!gps! bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t! Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-! ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs! ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t! sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz!dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi!bsf! opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif! sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot! xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe! trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme! opu!cf!vtfe!bt!sfqsftfoubujpo!pg!uif!ipnf“t! qsfdjtf!ps!bduvbm!tj{f/!Boz!tubufnfou-!wfscbm! pg!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!tj{f!pg!boz!ipnf!jt! b!tipsuiboe!eftdsjqujpo!pg!uif!nboofs!jo! xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe! tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/! Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf! boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju! Mfoobs/dpn!ps!tff!b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou! mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft! xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf! qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!3126!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif! Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif! Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe! tfswjdf!nbslt!ps!tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/! Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs! —!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs! Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/! Mjd!$!CD112524/)27857*!507028 Nbjo!Mfwfm 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf! 711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Cvdljohibn WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO B C D E MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Cvdljohibn WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpot 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27857*!507028 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Cvdljohibn WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpobm!Cbtfnfou 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27857*!507028 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Cbsdfmpob WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO 2-742!!Tr/!Gu/! Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf! sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz! eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe! xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf!bhsffnfou!gps! bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t! Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-! ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs! ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t! sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz!dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi!bsf! opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif! sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot! xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe! trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme! opu!cf!vtfe!bt!sfqsftfoubujpo!pg!uif!ipnf“t! qsfdjtf!ps!bduvbm!tj{f/!Boz!tubufnfou-!wfscbm! pg!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!tj{f!pg!boz!ipnf!jt! b!tipsuiboe!eftdsjqujpo!pg!uif!nboofs!jo! xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe! tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/! Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf! boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju! Mfoobs/dpn!ps!tff!b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou! mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft! xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf! qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!3126!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif! Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif! Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe! tfswjdf!nbslt!ps!tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/! Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs! —!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs! Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/! Mjd!$!CD112524/)27855*!50728 Nbjo!Mfwfm 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf! 711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Cbsdfmpob WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO B C D E MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Cbsdfmpob WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpot 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27855*!50728 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Cbsdfmpob WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpobm!Gjojtife!Cbtfnfou 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27855*!50728 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Csjhiupo WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO 2-75:!Tr/!Gu/! Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf! sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz! eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe! xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf!bhsffnfou!gps! bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t! Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-! ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs! ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t! sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz!dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi!bsf! opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif! sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot! xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe! trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme! opu!cf!vtfe!bt!sfqsftfoubujpo!pg!uif!ipnf“t! qsfdjtf!ps!bduvbm!tj{f/!Boz!tubufnfou-!wfscbm! pg!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!tj{f!pg!boz!ipnf!jt! b!tipsuiboe!eftdsjqujpo!pg!uif!nboofs!jo! xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe! tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/! Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf! boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju! Mfoobs/dpn!ps!tff!b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf! Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou! mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft! xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf! qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!3126!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif! Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif! Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe! tfswjdf!nbslt!ps!tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs! Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/! Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs! —!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs! Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/! Mjd!$!CD112524/)27856*!507028 Nbjo!Mfwfm 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf! 711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Csjhiupo WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO B C D E MFOOBS/DPN :63.35:.4111 ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Csjhiupo WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpot 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27856*!507028 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN ¯ MFOOBS Uif!Csjhiupo WJMMB!DPMMFDUJPO Pqujpobm!Cbtfnfou 27416!47ui!Bwf/!O/!!Tvjuf!711-!Qmznpvui-!NO!66557 Fmfwbujpot!pg!b!ipnf!nbz!wbsz!boe!xf!sftfswf!uif!sjhiu!up!tvctujuvuf!boe!0ps!npejgz!eftjho!boe!nbufsjbmt-!jo!pvs!tpmf!pqjojpo!boe!xjuipvu!opujdf/!Qmfbtf!tff!zpvs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!boe!ipnf!qvsdibtf !bhsffnfou! gps!bduvbm!gfbuvsft!eftjhobufe!bt!bo!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!gfbuvsf-!beejujpobm!jogpsnbujpo-!ejtdmptvsft-!boe!ejtdmbjnfst!sfmbujoh!up!zpvs!ipnf!boe!jut!gfbuvsft/!Qmbot!bsf!bsujtu“t!sfoefsjoht!boe!nbz! dpoubjo!pqujpot!xijdi! bsf!opu!tuboebse!po!bmm!npefmt/!Mfoobs!sftfswft!uif!sjhiu!up!nblf!dibohft!up!qmbot!boe!fmfwbujpot!xjuipvu!qsjps!opujdf/!Tubufe!ejnfotjpot!boe!trvbsf!gppubhf!bsf!bqqspyjnbuf!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!vtfe!bt! sfqsftfoubujpo! uif!nboofs!jo!xijdi!uif!trvbsf!gppubhf!xbt!ftujnbufe!boe!tipvme!opu!cf!dpotusvfe!up!joejdbuf!dfsubjouz/!Hbsbhf!tj{ft!nbz!wbsz!gspn!ipnf!up!ipnf!boe!nbz!opu!bddpnnpebuf!bmm!wfijdmft/!Wjtju!Mfoobs/dpn! ps!tff! b!Mfoobs!Ofx!Ipnf!Dpotvmubou!gps!gvsuifs!efubjmt!boe!jnqpsubou!mfhbm!ejtdmbjnfst/!Uijt!jt!opu!bo!pggfs!jo!tubuft!xifsf!qsjps!sfhjtusbujpo!jt!sfrvjsfe/!Wpje!xifsf!qspijcjufe!cz!mbx/!‡Tpvsdf!.!CBUD-!31 26!Upq! 36!Cvjmefst!Mjtu/!Dpqzsjhiu!ª!3128!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo/!Bmm!sjhiut!sftfswfe/!Mfoobs-!uif!Mfoobs!mphp-!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!boe!uif!Fwfszuijoh“t!Jodmvefe!mphp!bsf!V/T/!sfhjtufsfe!tfswjdf!nbslt!ps! tfswjdf!nbslt!pg!Mfoobs!Dpsqpsbujpo!boe0ps!jut!tvctjejbsjft/!V/T/!Ipnf!Dpsqpsbujpo!e0c0b!Mfoobs!—!Mjdfotf!Op/!31575982/!Mfoobs!Tbmft!Dpsq/!—!Csplfs/!NO!Cmes/!Mjd!$!CD112524/)27856*!507028 :63.35:.4111 MFOOBS/DPN /ğƩǝĻƩ /ƚǒƓƷǤ tǒĬƌźĭ ‘ƚƩƉƭ ЊЊЌЏЉ IźŭŷǞğǤ ЋЊЋͲ {ǒźƷĻ Њ /ƚƌƚŭƓĻͲ ab ЎЎЌЋЋ December 28, 2018 City of Chanhassen, c/o Paul Oehme, P.E. Public Works Director/City Engineer 952-227-1169 poehme@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Re: Development / Access Review Comments: Nelson Property Preliminary Plat on CR 117/Galpin Blvd. Thank you for the opportunity to review the subject development in the City of Chanhassen. Consistent with the County Comprehensive Plan and County Codes, the following are comments and recommended conditions of approval and as potential requirements for any necessary permits to be issued for the project: 1. The subject plat and development has been reviewed against several other major planning and infrastructure projects, with the result that several changes and/or cross-checks of the subject plat will be required. CR 117/Galpin Blvd. is planned as turn back project and studied as part of a Highway 117 Corridor Study. Galpin Blvd is also Comprehensive Plan as an Urban/Urbanizing Collector, with a guided access spacing of 1/4- mile full access and 1/8-mile secondary access. In addition, a draft master stormwater and pond management was developed, based on planned development and road design elements. 2. In terms of access management, the proposed accesses across from Hunter Dr. and Longacres Dr. meet the guideline for full access. These two access points are also identified in the Highway 117 Corridor Study for full access. 3. In terms of access management, the access across from Wynsong Ln. meets the 1/8 spacing guideline for a secondary access. Note that this access could be restricted to a right-in/right- out access in the future. As such, it is recommended the City and developer consider a local through road connection instead of the proposed cul-de-sac. As a condition of the secondary access across from Wynsong Ln, the driveway from parcel no. 250100400 will need to be removed from CR 117/Galpin Blvd. and connect to the proposed new local road. 4. Exclusive left turn and right turn lanes should be required at all full access points across from Hunter Dr. and Longacres Dr., and if full access allowed at Wynsong Ln. Left turn lanes are preferred over right turn lanes if space is a premium. These are shown conceptually in the preferred alternative from the Highway 117 Corridor Study. The Hunter Drive location looks like it will need additional right of way and / or special design transitions to the south to fit the recommended turn lane lengths and transition tapers. DBSWFS!DPVOUZ! hŅŅźĭĻ ΛВЎЋΜ ЍЏЏΏЎЋЉЉ ΋ Cğǣ ΛВЎЋΜ ЍЏЏΏЎЋЋЌ ΋ ǞǞǞ͵ĭƚ͵ĭğƩǝĻƩ͵ƒƓ͵ǒƭ 5. Right of way dedication will be required along the east side of CR 117/Galpin Blvd. per the above considerations, the Highway 117 Corridor Study, and the typical roadway sections . The Corridor Study identifies specific right of way needs and the plat will need to follow and be consistent with the preferred roadway alternative. The right of way will need to tie into the existing highway right of way north and south of the proposed development. The preliminary and final proposal will need to be reviewed and approved as to form and content by the County Surveyor. Specifically, given that most all of the existing corridor is platted at approximately 100-ft total right of way could also be a total of 100 ft total or 50-ft on center. The typical roadway section for a 2-lane urban undivided with continuous left turn lane (intersection) should be followed and revised to fit in the 100-ft right of way planned, with an exact cross-section to be reviewed and approved by the County and City. The recommended cross-section could run as follows from west to east: 1--trail-5- -----left turn lane; 12-thru ---gutter; 5--trail; 1-offset (with variations in offset and/or blvd). Potentially, the right turn lanes could be shared Thru/Right Turn Lanes as exclusive left turn lanes are preferred over right turn lanes if space is a premium. It could be that the left turn lane or center left turn lane could be left out of the section Wetland is existing to keep the road narrower in this section. From the Corridor Study centerline stationing reference numbers, it looks like the typical left turn lane is about 600-800-feet long, such that the LT lane at Hunter Drive falls at Sta 32+00 to Sta 40+00; and the LT lane at Longacres Dr falls at Sta 40+00 to Sta 48+00; and so on to the north. More exact design layouts can verify some of these details. 6. The technical details of the plat, its boundaries and form(s) will need to be reviewed and approved by the County Surveyor. 7. The s final grading plans, ponds, and right of way along CR 117/Galpin Blvd. will need to be reviewed and approved to show how this is set up for the potential future CR 117/Galpin Blvd. reconstruction. A cross reference of grading plans, profiles, and respective cross sections should be provided at key locations such as intersections, ponds, or other special features. 8. A new a draft master stormwater and pond management will need to be developed for this plat and area, based on planned development, road design elements, and the draft ponds planned will need to be verified accordingly. 9. Prior to any work affecting or on County highways or in County right of way, the applicant shall coordinate plans with the County Engineer and obtain a Utility or Excavating/Filling/Grading Permit(s) from Carver County Public Works: (http://www.co.carver.mn.us/how-do-i/apply-for/a-permit). Final details of locations, grades, and profiles affecting County roads as well as any utility connections will need to be reviewed and approved prior to any permits. Ћ ΋ tğŭĻ 10. Any damages, modifications, or changes incurred on County highways from current or approved conditions will need to remedied or updated at development expense, including costs incurred by the County. These are comments at this time. If you have any questions or need further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me at dmccormick@co.carver.mn.us or by phone at (952) 466-5208. Sincerely, Dan McCormick, P.E. PTOE Transportation Manager Carver County Public Works Ќ ΋ tğŭĻ From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Galpin Property - In Opposition to the PUD Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:07:59 AM From: Danlye Jones <danlye@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2019 9:29 PM To: City Council <Council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Galpin Property - In Opposition to the PUD Dear CouncilMembers & My Fellow Chanhassen Citizens, Thank you for your efforts to gather public opinion regarding the proposed development of the Galpin property. I would like the city to preserve the Galpin property and I oppose the PUD. My husband and I have called Chanhassen home for 11 years. We are raising our little girl here. I grew up swimming and fishing at Lake Ann during summerswhile visiting my grandmother long before this was my home. This land needs to stay pristine to preserve our city's treasure, Lake Ann, for my child, your children, and future generations. Prince wasa fan of Joni Mitchell. When I think about the land being developed, I think of her song lyrics "Don't it always seem to go, that you don't know what you got 'til it's gone". Let's not pave paradise. We can do the right thing and preserve this land for us and for generations to come. Thank you, Danlye Jones 7026 Pima Ln Chanhassen, MN 55317 From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Galpin Property PUD - Oppose Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:31:18 AM From: Becca Brandt <becca.brandt@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, March 11, 2019 8:25 AM To: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Fwd: Galpin Property PUD - Oppose ---------- Forwarded message --------- From: Becca Brandt<becca.brandt@gmail.com> Date: Mon, Mar 11, 2019 at 8:23 AM Subject: Galpin Property PUD - Oppose To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us <council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>, kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.is <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.is> Hello - Me and my family recently moved to Chanhassen (7601 Walnut Curve) from Minneapolis. The appeal of the area and the community was and is the trees, open land, park space, and nature that surrounds us. Please reject the PUD plan. The high density in this community would instantaneously and permanently eliminate the appeal that brought us here. Becca Swanson -- Becca Brandt -- Becca Brandt From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Galpin Site Preliminary Plat & Rezone PUD Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:08:33 AM Attachments:image001.png image002.png From: matthew.myers@mchsi.com <matthew.myers@mchsi.com> Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2019 9:04 PM To: Ryan, Elise <ERyan@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Coleman, Julia <JColeman@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Campion, Dan <DCampion@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; McDonald, Jerry <JMcDonald@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Tjornhom, Bethany <BTjornhom@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Galpin Site Preliminary Plat & Rezone PUD Dear Mayor Ryan and the Chanhassen City Council, I urge the council to reject the current PUD and density transfer. The PRN Galpin property is unique piece of land. It is the only remaining virtually untouched land of hills and wetlands left in the City of Chanhassen. There are many more acres of farmland that could be developed into housing subdivisions. The topography has been changed and the trees stripped from the farm land The PRN Galpin property was never farmed because of its topography and wetlands. These features also make the land less than ideal for a housing sub division on the scale of the current proposal. I am not opposed to the development because of the proximity to my house. I oppose it on behalf of the future citizens of Chanhassen. I want people in 2069 to look back and praise the foresight of the City of Chanhassen for saving the entire piece of land and thus keeping Lake Ann clear. I worry about the wildlife that survive in the wetlands and woods. While the PUD saves the wetlands down by the lake, it destroys the wetlands and the trees on the south hill. The Lennar plan clearly shows streets laid right on top of a wetland. The property has been a de facto nature preserve for more than a decade. There is an abundance of wildlife on the site that would be displaced or wiped out. There are deer, coyotes, turkeys, opossums, and at least 5 different types of woodpeckers There is a pair of pheasants that have nested on the south hill for at least the last 3 years. The decision before you on Monday will affect Chanhassen for decades. I know the PRN Estate andLennar have timelines, however, that does not mean the citizens and elected officials of Chanhassen have to meet those deadlines. I urge the council to reexamine the Comprehensive Plan and find a better use of the land. Be creative and innovative. Reach out to othergovernmental bodies and create a partnership for the purchase and long- term preservation of the land. Please put a referendum to the vote of the citizens of Chanhassen, the people you were elected to serve. No future City council will be able to make a decision like this one. This type of land will not exist any more in Chanhassen for the City to step in and save for future generations. I respectfully ask you to do your duty to serve and preserve Chanhassen. Sincerely, Matthew Myers 7421 Windmill Drive Chanhassen MN From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Galpin Site PUD Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:08:51 AM Attachments:8581.910000182688 From: Daly Myers <daly.myers@mchsi.com> Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2019 8:44 PM To: Ryan, Elise <ERyan@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Coleman, Julia <JColeman@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Campion, Dan <DCampion@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; McDonald, Jerry <JMcDonald@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Tjornhom, Bethany <BTjornhom@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Galpin Site PUD My favorite book is "The Lorax" by Dr Seuss. I wanted my mother to read it to me every night. The final message of the book is: "Unless someone like you cares a whole awful lot, nothing is going to get better. It's not." I urge each city council member to read this book prior to voting on the destruction of the tress and land on Galpin Blvd. Daly S. Myers Chanhassen MN From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Galpin/Lennar development Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:32:59 AM From: Hoffman, Todd <thoffman@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Sent: Monday, March 11, 2019 8:32 AM To: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: Steckling, Jean <jsteckling@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: FW: Galpin/Lennar development From: Lynne PILGRIM <lpilg@msn.com> Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2019 8:26 PM To: Hoffman, Todd <thoffman@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Fwd: Galpin/Lennar development Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Lynne PILGRIM <lpilg@msn.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 8:32:16 PM EDT Subject: Fwd: Galpin/Lennar development Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: LPILG@msn.com Date: March 10, 2019 at 8:15:57 PM EDT To:eryan@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Cc: dcampion@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, jcoleman@cichanhassen.mn.us, jmcdonald@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, btjornhom@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Subject: Galpin/Lennar development Good evening Mayor Ryan and Chanhassen City council members, Tomorrow night is a major council meeting for many Chanhassen residents. It is always difficult toface the reality that the area you moved your family to and now call home will greatly change in the near future. Those of us who moved here years ago bought our homes that were surrounded by farms, woods, lakes andother scenic views. Our children played in these areas. We loved the silence and the peace these areas offered us. We walked the paths through the woods and around the water. We appreciated the beauty of the land. However, we were always aware that those areas could and would be developed some day. That was the future for Chanhassen. Our one hope was that we could help to choose the best type of development. As you are aware, Chanhassen Estates fought the first ideas on the land to the west. We did not want a Mobil home park or slab homes. What was finally approved was a neighborhood of single family homes. Likewise our neighborhood joined with Eden Prairie to fight the Hennepin County idea for a garbage dump on what is now the Wynfield neighborhood, just off Dell Road. That area instead became a lovely area of family homes. Our voices were heard but we always accepted the fact that our voices could only express dislike to a point and that development would happen. We just wanted the best for our area and for Chanhassen in general. The Chanhassen city council has a purchase agreement with an opportunity to gain a great addition of 54 acres to our park land. The builder can do as its chooses without the city picking a plan that helps allresidents of thecity. It is very narrow minded of a neighborhood to think it can choose what is best for everyone in our town. We are a great community with people from all areas and economic backgrounds. We need to look for what is best for everyone, not just one special area. The city is not buying the land. Aprivate party is not buying the land. The neighborhood is not buying the land. A developer has apurchase agreement on the land. Let’s work with the developer and accept what is best for everyone In Chanhassen. Let’s supportthe plan that includes 54 lovely areas for everyone to share and enjoy. Lynne and Ron Pilgrim 8026Dakota Ave 612-202-1632 Sent from my iPad From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Please reject the PUD and density transfer Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:08:12 AM From: Christine Butterfield <cmcbutterfield@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2019 9:06 PM To: City Council <Council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Please reject the PUD and density transfer Mayor Ryan and Chanhassen City Council, We are urging you to reject the current PUD you are scheduled to vote on tomorrow. This is not what the residents of Chanhassen want. There are so many more options beside the few thatLennar is providing. We realize they are trying to negotiate with gifting a portion of the land to the City. Theexchange is dense housing, clearing beautiful big woods, rolling hills, and displacing more wildlife. In the short 6 years we have lived in Chanhassen, we have watched this same thing happen in our back yard withthe development on Lakeway Dr and Anthem in the Park on the north side of Lake Lucy. We movedhere from Eden Prairie and while we loved coming to this community, we feel it lacks walking trails that don't run along a road and housing developments. We lived near Starring Lake and the trails around that lake are amazing and highly used. We are now facing a once in a lifetime opportunity to potentially capture a similar setting as Starring Lake. I believe manycitizens would agree. Has there been discussions about the City potentially buying a portion of this land around the lakes? Has the City talked to a spokesperson from Prince's estate regarding a discount on the land in exchange for an added memorial for Prince on the property? Another place the Prince fans from all over the world can go and enjoy while they also visit Paisley Park? They not only see the inside of his home, but also can see the beauty of the landscaping where Prince called his home? What are the options on voting for a referendum, or applying for a loan? This would allowfor a developer to pay less for their portion of land and could comply with the 2040 Comprehensive plan. Please don't allow Lennar to turn our beautiful land into another cookie-cutter dense housing subdivision. The City just approved a large apartment building in the middle of downtown. We don't need more dense housing, we need less. We appreciate all the work you do and know it's not an easy job. We urge you to please work a little harder to make this development great. Thank you, Christine and Jason Butterfield 6626 Pointe Lake Lucy From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Prince"s property on Galpin Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:06:35 AM From: K B <kabl1@msn.com> Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2019 8:38 PM To: City Council <Council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Prince's property on Galpin Hi, I live in Chanhassen and have lived in Chanhassen for 23 yrs. I am concerned about the developement of Prince's property on Galpin Blvd. I reviewed both proposed options, PUD and Concept plan. The Propsed PUD is better than the concept plan but neither is acceptable. We need to leave areas such as this for wildlife. All pieces of land do not need to be developed. I moved to Chanhassen originally because of more open spaces and now that is becoming less and less. Prince owned this land for many years possibly to keep it as is, not to be developed. Think of what he would have liked. Develop a park for everyone to enjoy as a wild area. Please make the right decision in this and hear what the community is saying. Do not develop this land because someone wants their profit. Think of what is right. Think about/research what developing this land will do to the lakes, such as runoff from fertilizer, chemicals, etc. We need green areas, trees, especially old growth forests for future generations to come and enjoy. I seen to much of this destroyed over the years, beautiful areas, old oak trees, replaced with a housing community, one example housing development on Lyman Blvd years ago to the current development around the lake off Lyman and 101, and many more. Thank You, Karen Blenker From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: PRN Galpin Property Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:07:37 AM -----Original Message----- From: Dake Chatfield <dake.chatfield@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, March 11, 2019 7:34 AM To: City Council <Council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: PRN Galpin Property Dear Mayor Ryan and City Council members, My name is Dake Chatfield and I live at 2200 Majestic Way in Chanhassen. I border the south side of the proposed development property in the Royal Oaks neighborhood. My family and I have lived there for 18 years. I am located at ground zero between this property development and the Galpin boulevard reconstruction. I have attended every city planning and council meeting on this topic. I recognize the difficulty and importance of this decision. I have thought long and hard about this and tried to determine what I would do if this were my decision. I’ve always wondered what would become of this land when he was gone. I’ve imagined many things from a golf course, a park land, some sort of memorial space with an amphitheater, or something like Matt Myers has been envisioning in his comments. The worst possible scenario I can imagine is clear cutting all of that old growth forest, leveling those rolling hill acres, and putting in a high density housing subdivision. Therefore, I would ask that you vote No to this PUD proposal and reject these development plans. I respect and appreciate the amount of work that has gone into this plan by the developer, Kate, and city staff. I think the concept of preserving a park land west of Lake Ann is enticing. I am an avid outdoorsman, and nobody would benefit more from that space more then me and my family. But it is not worth the cost of building a high density development on the remaining space. My comments and feedback so far on this development have been to minimize the impact on the environment, minimize the loss of old growth forest, and to preserve a buffer between the existing neighborhoods and the development. None of that has been addressed with this proposal. Nobody has reached out to me to seek my opinion in this manner, short of the city council meetings. My recommendation is that we try to preserve the property as-is as much as possible. And if we cannot do that, only develop the open land with low density and do not cut down all the trees and grade the land. The last thought I will leave you with is to ask that you think about what he would have wanted for this property. Surely his importance to the community and the impact he’s had across the world should have some weight on his legacy. I have to think that there is no way a high density housing development would have been his choice. Let’s find another option for this property and pay him respect. Dake Chatfield From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Statement opposing the Galpin Project Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:07:48 AM -----Original Message----- From: Kristen <kjkelroy@yahoo.com> Sent: Sunday, March 10, 2019 10:32 PM To: City Council <Council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Statement opposing the Galpin Project Dear City Council, I’m writing to let you know that I oppose the proposed PUD for the Galpin project. I by no means have a “not in my backyard” mentality...because growth and development is bound to happen. However I do believe that the builder/buyer of the land can and should do better to preserve the beauty of Chanhassen. I would like to see minimal tree removal and something that better addresses the increased traffic that is bound to come from dropping in a new development. I feel as though Mayor Elise Ryan has been thoughtful in hearing people out and am confident she has the best interest for keeping Chanhassen unique and beautiful. I encourage you press for better as well and do not pass the PUD. Thank you for your time. Sincerely, Kristen Nordberg 2126 Majestic Way Chanhassen, MN 55317 Sent from my iPhone From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Citizen Letter - PUD Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 6:31:03 PM Attachments:Citizen Letter_PUD_Christian Myers.docx ATT00001.htm Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: "Christian Myers" <christian.myers@mchsi.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 6:22:46 PM CDT To: <'eryan@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'>, <'dcampion@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'>, <'jcoleman@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'>, <btjornhom@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'>, <'jmcdonald@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'> Cc: <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Citizen Letter - PUD Please see the attached letter for my concerns about the recently proposed development. Thank you for your time and attention. Thank you, Christian Myers 612.964.9061 From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Developing Prince’s property Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 4:53:57 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Linda W <lindawilkes@live.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 4:52:00 PM CDT To: "kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us" <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Fwd: Developing Prince’s property Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Linda Wilkes <lindawilkes@live.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 4:49:50 PM CDT To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Subject: Developing Prince’s property To our Mayor and City Council, This is such a bad idea! It will destroy the lakes and park. We do not need more housing especially in that beautiful little oasis in the middle of Chanhassen. Why can’t it just stay a park that all can enjoy instead of polluting the whole area. The city should buy it and I for one think that our exorbitantly high taxes be used for what residents want. Especially when it comes to preserving our dwindling natural areas. Please find an alternative option to this disastrous plan. We the people want a say in this endeavor. Start a go fund me with residents and see what happens. Linda Wilkes Sent from my iPad From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Email RE: Galpin Development Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 8:11:52 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Richard Sit <richardsit32@gmail.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 8:10:29 PM CDT To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, eryan@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Cc: kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, Andrea Sit <andrea.i.h.sit@gmail.com> Subject: Email RE: Galpin Development March 10, 2019 Dear Mayor Ryan and the Chanhassen City Council, We urge the Chanhassen City Council to reject the current PUD and density transfer development plans proposed by Lennar. The Galpin Development property is a unique piece of land and offers a rare opportunity to preserve and enhance the Lake Ann area and nearby Chanhassen neighborhoods for current and future generations. The Galpin Development property is the only remaining virtually untouched land of hills and wetlands left in the City of Chanhassen. There are other less unique pieces of land that could be developed into housing subdivisions. For example, there are many more acres of farmland already stripped of trees and of which the topography has already been changed. The Galpin Development property was never farmed and retains its original topography, wetlands, and Big Woods. These features also make the land less than ideal for a housing subdivision on the scale of the current proposal. We oppose this development on behalf of the current and future citizens of Chanhassen. This plan is contrary to Chanhassen’s 2040 Comprehensive Plan which calls for the protection of significant wooded areas. We and our children cherish the wildlife, wetlands, and trees that make up this land, and we strongly urge you to preserve this pristine area of land and wetlands for current and future generations. This plan strongly resembles the destruction of a beautiful forest and wildlife habitat in the movie, The Lorax. It is beyond heartbreaking to imagine this beautiful land torn up, filled in, and bulldozed. Also, Lennar’s plans for preserving existing trees and wetlands and the proposed tree buffers along the North and South borders of the Galpin Development property are grossly inadequate to meet the goals of Chanhassen’s 2040 Comprehensive Plan and to maintain the existing character of the nearby neighborhoods. We moved here in 2016 from Shorewood because of the open spaces, woods, and natural beauty, and if this plan goes through, we will be forced to move again to remove ourselves from the heartbreak of seeing this land desecrated. We are also concerned about the ever-increasing traffic volume on Galpin Boulevard between Highways 5 and 7. In addition, it is already hazardous to turn right (Eastward) onto Highway 7 with cars crossing two lanes of traffic to get to Excelsior and holding up the line of traffic waiting behind them to get onto Highway 7. People take chances pulling onto Highway 7 when there are cars lined up behind them. We have both witnessed near- accidents occurring here. Thank you for hearing our concerns. We hope that you make the correct decision. Sincerely, Andrea and Richard Sit 1957 Topaz Drive Chanhassen, MN 55317 andreaihsit@gmail.com richardsit32@gmail.com From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Galpin Property Development Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 4:16:59 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Jennifer Smolka <jenlynnsmolka@gmail.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 4:09:17 PM CDT To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Subject: Galpin Property Development To whom it may concern, I am a resident of Chanhassen who is writing to you today to oppose the new housing development around Lake Lucy and Lake Ann, as this area is vital for wetlands and wildlife, and once it is developed, it cannot be restored. Wetlands and the lands surrounding them work together to provide ecological benefits for our community - benefits that are undermined when land is razed for development, obliterating wildlife corridors and interrupting habitats and food chains necessary to preserve the ecosystem as a whole. Wetlands provide flood and erosion protection, water quality improvement, and climate stability. Wetlands are also the breeding ground for dragonflies, which provide us with a natural form of mosquito control. I work with and am a board member of the Frankfurt Zoological Society, an international NGO based in Germany and Washington DC with over 30 conservation projects in 18 countries around the world, whose mission is to preserve critical ecosystems and biodiversity. But conservation must begin in our own backyards. Because if we allow ourselves to destroy our resources - one area at a time - eventually the benefits provided to us by these irreplaceable natural habitats will be gone. Minnesota leads the nation in conservation stewardship. It is my hope that the City of Chanhassen will safeguard the future of our community's environment by choosing be a leader in conservation now. Sincerely, Jennifer Smolka 500 Trap Line Lane Chanhassen From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Galpin property PUD Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 3:21:57 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Vanessa Martin <Vanessa_Martin@jjtaylor.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 3:11:26 PM CDT To: "council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us" <council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: "kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us" <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Galpin property PUD Hello, my name is vanessa martin. We live at 2325 hunter drive Chanhassen mn. I strongly oppose the PUD, please take into consideration those who have purchased for the beauty and quality of life that is in jeopardy. Vanessa Get Outlook for Android Disclaimer The information contained in this communication from the sender is confidential. It is intended solely for use by the recipient and others authorized to receive it. If you are not the recipient, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, copying, distribution or taking action in relation of the contents of this information is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. This email has been scanned for viruses and malware, and may have been automatically archived by Mimecast Ltd, an innovator in Software as a Service (SaaS) for business. Providing a safer and more useful place for your human generated data. Specializing in; . Security, archiving and compliance. To find out more Click Here From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Galpin Property Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 5:56:22 PM Attachments:image001.png Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: <michelle.myers@mchsi.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 5:54:59 PM CDT To: "'Councilman Jerry McDonald'" <'jmcdonald@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'>, "'Councilwoman Bethany Tjornhom'" <'btjornhom@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'>, "'Councilwoman Julia Coleman'" <'jcoleman@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'>, "'Councilman Dan Campion'" <'dcampion@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'>, "'Mayor Elise Ryan'" <'eryan@ci.chanhassen.mn.us'> Cc: <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Galpin Property The beauty of nature’s bounty…. And we are about to lose it all. That’s is unless, you as our Chanhassen City Council preserve it for future generations. So many people think this is an either/or with the Lennar plans. They don’t seem to understand we can choose not to succumb to big builders and we can choose to ask for more. The quality of life in Chanhassen will change for the worse if we have to contend with 181 more homes confined to such a small space. The lakes and habitats will be adversely affected by the destruction of the land. Water quality will diminish and wildlife will be permanently displaced. There must be other options to leave hope for the future. Require more of builders looking to build in Chanhassen. Innovation and compassion are not mutually exclusive. Please consider rejecting Lennar’s proposals as they are now. Thank you, Michelle Myers 7421 Windmill Drive Chanhassen, MN From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: I oppose the Galpin PUD Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 5:55:14 PM Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Tami Gottschalk <tamig66@gmail.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 5:24:54 PM CDT To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Cc: kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Subject: I oppose the Galpin PUD Dear Chanhassen City Council, I respectfully urge the council to reject the current PUD and density transfer. The PRN Galpin property is unique piece of land. My husband and I built our home facing the property 20 years ago. We truly enjoy the beauty of the minimally touched property. It is the virtually the only untouched land of hills and wetlands left in the City of Chanhassen. There are many more acres of farmland that could be developed into housing subdivisions if the housing need is so great. I worry about the wildlife that live in those wetlands and woods within this property. While the PUD saves the wetlands down by the lake, it destroys the wetlands and the trees on the south hill. The property has been a de facto nature preserve for more than a decade. There is an abundance of wildlife on the site that would only be displaced or wiped out. There are deer, coyotes, turkeys, ducks and opossums. The scale of the current proposal scares me. Along with the apartments going in downtown, I am concerned about the strain on the schools. I also worry about the increased traffic this proposed development will bring; understanding the new and improved roadway. Still too much traffic going at unreasonable speeds. I know the PRN Estate and Lennar have timelines but that does not mean the citizens and elected officials of Chanhassen have to meet those deadlines. Please consider what is before you on behalf of me, my family and my neighbors. No future City council will be able to make a decision like this one. This type of land will not exist any more in Chanhassen. Please put a referendum to the vote of the citizens of Chanhassen, the people you were elected to serve. Thank you, Tami Gottschalk 2197 Majestic Way Chanhassen MN From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: I oppose the PUD on Galpin Rd Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:52:55 AM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Jacqueline Tyson <jactyson03@me.com> Date: March 11, 2019 at 8:41:08 AM CDT To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Cc: Chanhassen City Planner <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: I oppose the PUD on Galpin Rd As a long time resident of the Longacres community in Chanhassen, I just want to share with you that I oppose the current PUD for the former property owned by Prince. As it is proposed, in the very least, this PUD will increase traffic through my neighborhood and along Galpin Road. However I feel it will have a larger negative impact on the city of Chanhassen at large. I’m not convinced the city has explored all the ways this PUD will impact our community. Please take the time to evaluate, and let developers know we demand more from them - access to Lake Ann, less density and perhaps most importantly less destruction of our beautiful landscape - we don’t want all the trees removed & land flattened for more homes!!! Concerned residents, Jacqueline & George Tyson 7414 Moccasin Trail Chanhassen Sent from my iPhone From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Oppose the PUD! Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 3:08:37 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: C Jerdee <cjerdee@gmail.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 2:49:14 PM CDT To: "council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us" <council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>, "kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us" <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>, "mayor@ci.chanhassen.mn.us" <mayor@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Oppose the PUD! Craig Jerdee, 6621 Chestnut Ln 55317 here I oppose the PUD and urge you to do the same. Make Lennar or whomever stands to develop and profit from the development work harder to come up with a better plan. I’d love to see a non-development option, and sell bonds to fund the city the purchasing the land for all to enjoy. We’ll never have another opportunity to do this! Now is the time! If you vote for the PUD, we, the voters, will make sure to remember that come election time. From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Oppose Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 3:08:20 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Natalia Sander <nataliasander@me.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 2:54:28 PM CDT To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Cc: <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Oppose The proposed PUD is NOT the right thing for the residents of Chanhassen Please vote No Natalia Sander 6671 Amberwood Lane Thank you. Natalia N. Sander- Realtor Edina Realty- Minnetonka (612) 850-7737 Http://nataliasanderhomes.com Your referral is the best compliment I can earn! From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Prince / Lennar Proposed Development Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 3:07:55 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Mark Seefeldt <maseefeldt@gmail.com> Date: March 9, 2019 at 1:06:40 PM CST To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Cc: kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Subject: Prince / Lennar Proposed Development Dear Chanhassen Council, Will the plans impact me? A little with increased traffic and infrastructure usage, but my yard doesn’t touch the proposed development property. I live a block south of the proposed development. I have a line of tall spruce trees in my backyard separating my backyard from the neighbors. That was one of the reasons we bought our house. If those trees were not there, we would not have purchased. Am I strongly against either plan? No. Will we all get over it? Yes. Time heals all wounds. Which plan is the right choice? Neither in my opinion. This shouldn’t be a quid pro quo. If Lennar wants to only develop the western half of the property, then the density should fall in line with the master plan and zoning requirements that the city has set. If Lennar is a good developer and wants to keep developing in Chanhassen, then they’ll recognize the voice of the community and not develop the eastern half close to Lake Ann. There is better plans and options out there that haven’t been brought to the table yet. I urge you to vote no to Lennar’s density transfer plan. Put the decision about developing the full property (while meeting density requirements) back on to them. They’ll find a better solution or someone else will. Thank you, Mark & Jennifer Seefeldt 7470 Tulip Court 952-297-2645 From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Prince Property - Vote NO on Lennar Development Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 3:08:10 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Rebecca Nay <nay.rebecca@gmail.com> Date: March 9, 2019 at 1:37:29 PM CST To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Cc: kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Subject: Prince Property - Vote NO on Lennar Development I am one of the area residents who have enjoyed the beautiful Prince property around Lake Ann and Lake Lucy for many years, I am thankful to Prince who allowed the public to enjoy his land. Ibeg the city to say no to the Lennar development andallow the area residents to continue to enjoy one of the last remaining nature areas in the city. It would take away trees, pollute the lakes, increase noise and traffic congestion, and overall will ruin a once peaceful and beautiful oasis. -Rebecca Nay From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Prince Property proposal Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:52:42 AM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Abby Ellis <abby.ellis11@gmail.com> Date: March 11, 2019 at 8:33:29 AM CDT To: btjornhom@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, "council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us" <council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>, dcampion@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, eryan@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, jcoleman@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, jmcdonald@ci.chanhassen.mn.us, "kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us" <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: Neil Ellis <neil.ellis4@gmail.com> Subject: Re: Prince Property proposal Hello all! I am not opposed to A development, but AM opposed to Lennars scare tactics to get the city to do what they want. I am IN FAVOR of the city exploring more responsible and thorough propsals that have full transparency into the end result. There are way too many unknowns in this proposal that Lennar has simply ignored, despite many requests by council to research and provide details. The city owes it to the current residents of Chanhassen and the Comprehensive Plan to uphold the higher standards Mayor Ryan mentions and require detailed information of ANY development proposed here. I hope you do the right thing and insist on this by voting ‘NO’ tonight. Thank you! Abby and Neil Ellis 7284 Bent Bow Trail On Tue, Mar 5, 2019 at 10:42 PM Abby Ellis <abby.ellis11@gmail.com> wrote: Good evening, I was one of many Chanhassen residents who attended the city planning session tonight. It is great to see so many people engaged in this process and voice their opinions respectfully. I was excited to hear an update on the inevitable development. Boy did Lennar disappoint! Still 181 homes, still only the Concept Plan and the same PUD Plan that was proposed last time, only very slight variations were made. If I were Mayor and Council, I would be extremely frustrated with the amount of time and resources spent by city and staff without the results that were asked for on several occasions. Many of the residents who spoke tonight were in support of the proposed PUD. The vast majority of them did so with the position of 'but what would the alternative be' and 'we don't want to risk losing the opportunity to have the area west of Lake Ann'. The many nature-lovers stated that the current proposal would preserve the land around the lake for the wildlife that inhabits the area currently. I am concerned that the wildlife would be forced out during the 2+ years construction of the area, excavating the land, altering the entire topography of the landscape, tree removal, noise and air pollution, etc. Perhaps wildlife would return once all is settled, but that is a lot of disruption to a thriving ecosystem. I am unclear on how the density transfer works. If it is literally the transferring of existing trees from the area to be developed to the western edge of the lake and buffer areas, how viable is that? Will the mature trees really survive when transplanted? Our soil is not the greatest here and I have trouble believing that 20'-30' trees that have rooted where they are will sustain if migrated around the property. How about an expert opinion from a horticulturist or an unbiased authority to weigh in on that? Regarding the increase to traffic and the plan for Galpin Blvd...how could this NOT be incorporated in this project? Many residents voiced their concerns about the traffic increase and safety issues that currently exist, let alone with approximately 362 drivers (2 per household) added to the mix. There are already concerns about traffic congestion and visibility. Of the 3 entrances proposed off Galpin, 2 of them feed directly to/from Longacres neighborhood. There will absolutely be an increase of traffic running through our neighborhood for access to 41. What does the city's plan include to address those concerns of our neighborhood's safety? Here's a big unknown...is the land that Lennar is "gifting" to Chanhassen even able to be developed? Do we even have to worry about that if Lennar's proposal is not accepted? There were varying opinions on that tonight, but none of them official. Why don't we have an unbiased analysis on that aspect of this plan? That would answer a lot of questions that residents have. Some of the residents brought up good points about the area that would be a continuation of the park around Lake Ann, that it would mainly serve as a draw to the new development. Unless there is public parking spaces and areas for people to gather, similar to the existing Lake Ann park, it's simply a bonus to the people who purchase homes in the development and not a realistic benefit to the other residents of Chanhassen. So their newly constructed homes reduce the value of homes for currently established residents AND they get the benefit of 54+ acres in their backyard that we have generously persevered for their enjoyment and their property values? That doesn't live up to the commitment to the current residents of Chanhassen that I would hope to be considered. Several speakers provided historical perspectives and are clearly proud Chan residents. I appreciate their wise decisions made decades ago in purchasing and preserving the land in this community that we are so passionate about. Many comments have been made about this shouldn't be an 'either/or' proposition and it isn't! Decisions of this magnitude should not be made under pressure from a company that has their own best interest, AND PROFIT, as the highest priority. The city of Chanhassen doesn't owe Lennar an agreement to one of their two proposals. Lennar owes it to the city of Chanhassen and it's residents to present a responsible, sustainable proposal that supports this community's values. Mayor Ryan - I really appreciated your public letter in response to other council members public appeal for this proposal. I am proud that we have elected officials in place now who are listening to residents and fulfilling the comprehensive plan. Please keep up the commitment and the good work. The right proposal is out there for Chanhassen, but it has not been presented yet or this would be a done deal already. There are too many unanswered questions to make a well-planned decision. See you on March 11th! Abby Ellis On Tue, Feb 12, 2019 at 7:16 AM Abby Ellis <abby.ellis11@gmail.com> wrote: Good morning! I appreciate the time council and the planning commission has invested in this proposal. I joined the Facebook group regarding this and provided my comments from the meeting last night. I’d like to share them with you: Mayor Ryan mentioned that, of the feedback she received, the vast majority of residents recognized that the land would be developed (vs left alone), but would like to see a plan that is more “responsible”. I have the impression that she is not pleased that Lennar is coming back with minimum changes in the several revisions to date. It appears that Lennar is getting irritated and was nearly threatening the council regarding the land around Lake Ann. Personally, I think it feels like blackmail. What I don’t understand is why the city is in this position to HAVE to accept a proposal from Lennar or lose the Lake Ann land. Doesn’t the city have final say with permits and zoning to allow/not the land to be developed? How is it that Lennar is coming from an ‘upper hand’ position? Perhaps this is just the way these deals are when developers obtain an agreement to purchase as they have. Excuse my lack of familiarity with the process. But I keep scratching my head like, ‘how did we get here’? I appreciate that Mayor Ryan is clearly listening to residents surrounding the perimeter of the land and voicing their concerns as well as referring to the Comprehensive Plan and keeping that commitment in the forefront. There are more details that need to be addressed: Traffic along Galpin - it was stated that the city has a plan in place already to upgrade Galpin. How does this coincide with plans/changes to the proposals from Lennar? How does the city plan to address the through traffic that will occur on Longacres Drive b/w Galpin and 41? It will become busy like Lake Lucy Rd. vs the quieter neighborhood street it is currently. How do the current residents, who have invested in Chanhassen’s economy and property tax base, deal with the loss in home values when compared to these new homes at the same price point as homes that are 20 years old? Where is the commitment to the existing home owners who have invested in their homes and this community for decades? Soliciting feedback from other residents is great and the right thing to do. However, the residents who are not directly impacted by the process of construction, the drastic change of the quality of life and decrease in home values, may focus on preserving the Lake Ann land without considering how this development will negatively impact those of us who live surrounding the area. I continue to believe that there is still an opportunity for better compromise. The city should not have to be forced to make a decision on Lennar’s timeline with their contract to purchase. If Lennar wants to move ahead, they should have made the adjustments requested by staff and the council previously vs the minimum effort. I’d like to see the city taking a stronger approach to ensure a responsible decision, taking as much time as that requires, in order to uphold Chanhassen’s commitment to the Comp Plan and the current residents. I look forward to the city planning meeting that is on March 5 and the city council meeting on March 11. Thanks!!! Abby Ellis On Mon, Feb 11, 2019 at 8:47 AM Abby Ellis <abby.ellis11@gmail.com> wrote: We are current residents of Longacres and I have been a Chanhassen resident for over 15 years. What we appreciate about our city are the green spaces, the sense of community and the commitment our city council has to maintain the integrity of our special place to live. I have involved myself in community events and previous proposals in front of city council, most actively when Wallmart had a proposal in front of our council. I was a member of the Chanhassen First volunteer group who helped organize the residents who were opposed to the proposal. I am proud that my contribution encouraged the city council to make the right decision on this proposal. Our concern about this Lennar proposal is that it does not follow the commitment the city council has made to the residents of Chanhassen. We attended the city planning commission meeting on Jan 15 and were disappointed in the result. It appears that Lennar is attempting to bribe the city to meet their proposal in exchange for the 50 acres around the northwest area of Lake Ann. The developer representing Lennar could not speak to the sustainability efforts that would be made, and that is very concerning for our environment. The extensive loss of a variety of mature trees, wildlife that depends on the ecosystem and the aesthetics of the topography of the land would be catastrophic. We are also very concerned about the increase in traffic through our neighborhood and the decrease in our home values. We are not opposed to development of our area, recognizing that we have a jewel of a city and this is attractive land for development. We ask the city council to stay committed to the current residents who have contributed to the economy and quality of this community. There must be other options to explore that will enable the long-term plan, so carefully developed by our city leaders, to continue to support our values. Thank you, Abby and Neil Ellis 7284 Bent Bow Trail From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Prince Property: proposed development Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 8:11:24 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Stephanie Rutledge <p-s.rutledge@mchsi.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 8:09:06 PM CDT To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Cc: <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Prince Property: proposed development Dear Chanhassen City Council: Is the proposed PUD the right thing for the residents of Chanhassen? We vote NO! Thank you. Sent from Patrick and Stephanie Rutledge 7568 Walnut Curv From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Prince PUD Date:Sunday, March 10, 2019 4:53:34 PM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: Tom’s New Gmail <7381tbell@gmail.com> Date: March 10, 2019 at 4:41:49 PM CDT To: council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Cc: kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Subject: Prince PUD Dear Council, As I have emailed most of you about different dimensions of the PUD request by Lennar, I’d like to one more time reiterate that I’m against the proposal. Among my concerns is that though the request has been made several times, Lennar has never definitively shown that the parkland they want to give to the city is, in fact, buildable for 50 single family homes. The density transfer is predicated on that fact. If the PUD is granted, there should be more protections provided for those who are most affected. If the PUD is denied, the city should figure out a way to purchase some of the land as parkland. Tom Bell 7381 Fawn Hill Rd Longacres Sent from my iPhone From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:Fwd: Proposed Development of Galpin property Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 8:53:31 AM Sent from my iPad Begin forwarded message: From: mary beth johnson <mbsilbs@me.com> Date: March 11, 2019 at 8:45:35 AM CDT To: kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us Subject: Proposed Development of Galpin property To whom it may concern, my family and I believe the currently proposed Galpin PUD is NOT the thing for the residents of Chanhassen. We are strongly opposed to this plan for Princes property based on the density of proposed new homes and it’s negative impact on our open/green spaces, traffic, school systems and the financial impact it will have on the bordering neighborhoods of similarly priced homes. Thank you for your consideration of our concerns. Mary Beth Silbernagel 7492 Bent Bow Trail Chanhassen, MN 55317 612-245-9759 From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Galpin Property Development Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 10:05:46 AM From: Ryan Erickson <ryanaerickson@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, March 11, 2019 9:55 AM To: City Council <Council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Galpin Property Development To whom it may concern, I am a resident of Chanhassen who is writing to you today to oppose the new housing development around Lake Lucy and Lake Ann. As a recent addition to the Chan community (I moved here 2 years ago), I moved here specifically because of the wetlands and wildlife. Wetlands and the lands surrounding them work together to provide ecological benefits for our community - benefits that are undermined when land is razed for development, obliterating wildlife corridors and interrupting habitats and food chains necessary to preserve the ecosystem as a whole. Wetlands provide flood and erosion protection, water quality improvement, and climate stability. Wetlands are also the breeding ground for dragonflies, which provide us with a natural form of mosquito control. In addition to the science behind the need to protect our wetlands and woodlands, they provide a beauty to the area that prompted me to choose to become a member of Chanhassen instead of so many other spots in the Minneapolis/St Paul area. I would hate to see Chan lose what makes it so great. Sincerely, Ryan Erickson 500Trap Line Lane Chanhassen From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Galpin Property Letter Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 11:44:39 AM From: Mars Chatfield <mars.chatfield@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, March 11, 2019 11:42 AM To: City Council <Council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us>; Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Galpin Property Letter Dear Mayor Ryan and City Council members, My name is Marsden Chatfield and I live at 2200 Majestic Way in Chanhassen. I border the south side of the proposed development property in the Royal Oaks neighborhood. I have lived at this location for the past 18 years. I am located at ground zero between this property development and the Galpinboulevard reconstruction. I moved into this house when I was one year old and have been living here my entire life. While I may not yet be an experienced member of society with decades of residency under my belt, I feel as though my 19-year-old opinion should still be considered, if not taken with more weight than others’; I am the fruit that Chanhassen has produced. I love this town with all of my heart, and will continue to love it whether or not you develop this property into a neighborhood. So rather than boring you with an emotional memoir telling the experience that this property has allowed me, I write this letter to you in the name of logic and common sense- I hope that you will find this more relevant to your decision. While I am not an economist or city planner, not (yet) a financial analyst or environmentalist, I am still able to recognize the foolishness of your proposal- simply as an observer. It is true that I live at ground zero and that this place means a lot to me, but even if it were not this way I could still see the golden opportunity that is being overlooked; how could I miss it? Chanhassen, MN: a small, developing suburb just outside of Minneapolis is graced by one of the largest icons in all of music history, who personally advocates and shares his love of the town, an ideal situation for a newer suburb who possesses no deep roots in culture, little to no historic value, and lots of open space. After the passing of this beloved star, the town of Chanhassen is swamped by tourists from all across the country who hope to see the place where their idol spent most of his time- tourism which brings in thousands of dollars for local businesses, further promoting Chanhassen’s booming economy. Now, here’s the part that doesn’t make any sense to me. The city of Chanhassen receives the beautiful, sprawling property that Prince himself had purchased and built his private residence on. While the home is now destroyed, the acres of rolling hills and beautiful wildlife still persist, untouched by any industrial development or manmade infractions. Chanhassen is essentially given a ‘Graceland’; an opportunity to dig its feet into national history for decades to come. What boggles my mind is that, rather than milking Prince for as many cultural sites and memorials as possible while simultaneously pleasing the citizens of their town, my city council would rather flatten that gorgeous plot of nature and cover it in concrete; stimulating the local economy briefly and destroying both a natural gem and a potential heritage site forever. This proposed development makes sense, don’t get me wrong-it just makes sense right now. In a growing suburb, you will increase the overall property value, bring in more citizens which in turn inflate the local economy; businesses make more money, you all earn more taxes-- our city will become better, I understand that. I just wish that you could recognize the potential gold mine you have here, if things were handled the right way. Chanhassen could become nationally realized as ‘Prince’s town’; the Motown of Minnesota, the Graceland of the Great Lakes- yet my city is focused on short term gains and development rather than establishing Chanhassen as a city to withstand the test of time, a city to be taught about in schools around the country for years to come. Thirty years from now, what do you expect of this neighborhood? The houses will remain full, the foundations sound, the streets paved- I expect you will do a good job on construction. However after thirty years, the neighborhood will lose its glimmer. Take a look at neighborhoods built in the 1980’s and 1990’s- these neighborhoods are no longer the apple of the homebuyer’s eye, instead they are typically considered options which are safer for buyers’ checkbooks; temporary homes to be lived in until income increases. In the year2050 aneighborhood on this land will be approaching its demise, whereas a city park will likely only have increased in beauty and value; an oasis of natural delicacy in a city which willpresumably be much larger than it is today. All in all, my point is this: in pursuit of economic prosperity, environmental conservation, cultural enhancement, residential happiness, and respect for the deceased and his family, the city of Chanhassen ought not develop a neighborhood on the property adjacent to Galpin Boulevard, nor on any of the properties previously owned by Prince and company. The city should, however, recognize the potential value of these properties and improve them to serve not only as amenities to the townspeople and tourists, but also to honor a great neighbor who we miss dearly. I hope that this letter does not fall on deaf ears, and that my council will act in favor of the city it represents rather than the expansion of its treasury. Marsden Chatfield From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Lennar Development (Prince Property) Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 10:43:13 AM From: Susan Mcallister <smcallister7510@gmail.com> Sent: Monday, March 11, 2019 10:37 AM To: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Lennar Development (Prince Property) Dear Madam Mayor, City Council, I have lived in Chanhassen for 58 years, since 1959, and when we arrived it was just a "hick town" as my mother would refer to it. I have seen almost all the rural areas disappear to development over time. I watched the video for public comment at the Planning Commission Meeting when it popped upon my phone. Because I now reside in Waconia I unfortunately didn't know about it until it was too late which was the day after. I just want to comment on the numerous residents who don't want it abutting their homes. The reality is, they don't "own" their view so if they don't want to look at it, then unfortunately they haveto buy their view, becausedevelopment is inevitable and obviously clustering is the only way to preserve the beautiful greenspace we find in this property and all others going forward. I hope you adopt the plan as shown because it is very sensitive to the site. I think the developer, along with the planning department has done an absolutely wonderful job putting this together. Please make sure though, that every tree in the 54 acres is protected and that it is not tobe accessed by car, that the only way to access the 54 acres is by foot. Also, if there is ANY possibility to protect a few of the old growth trees in the clustered section of the planthat wouldbe wonderful. I realize this might not be possible due to the regrading that will happen. Lastly, I would ask the developer to name it Purple Meadows. Sincerely, Susan McAllister 100West 3rd Street #302 Waconia, MN 55387 952.228.4511 From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Prince Property Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 1:05:36 PM From: Juli Gempler <juliannagem@yahoo.com> Sent: Monday, March 11, 2019 1:04 PM To: City Council <Council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Prince Property We oppose the PUD development. We are at 1877 Topaz Drive. We have lived here for 14 years and feel there needs to be other options for the property that preserves and protects the natural beauty and resouces it provides. Please take into considerstion the people, the residents that call this area home. This is a unique opportunity to do the right thing, step out of the box and vote no. Thank you for all of your efforts and considerstion, Juli and Mark Gempler Sent from Yahoo Mail on Android From:Aanenson, Kate To:Meuwissen, Kim Subject:FW: Proposed Development Galpin Blvd. Date:Monday, March 11, 2019 10:28:21 AM From: Connie Moore <CMoore@mclindengrp.com> Sent: Monday, March 11, 2019 10:14 AM To: Aanenson, Kate <kaanenson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Subject: Fwd: Proposed Development Galpin Blvd. Begin forwarded message: From: CONNIE MOORE <cmoore@mclindengrp.com> Subject: Proposed Development Galpin Blvd. Date: March 11, 2019 at 9:53:01 AM CDT To: <council@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Cc: <kaanerson@ci.chanhassen.mn.us> Dear Council Members and City Planner, First and foremost, thank you for your service. We have been residents of Chanhassen for 24 years and have experienced tremendous growth and prosperity. We have felt that the leadership of Chanhassen has had it’s residents best interest at heart. We are opposed to the current development under discussion due to the density and the impact it will have on the community. In making your decision, please consider the affect it will have on green space, traffic, schools and community as a whole. Thank you for your consideration. Dave and Connie Moore 7330 Moccasin Trail Chanhassen, MN 55317 2019 Commissions Interview Schedule FIRST MEETINGS IN APRIL: Planning Commission - April 2, 2018 Environmental Commission - April 10, 2019 Senior Commission - April 18, 2019 Park & Rec Commission - April 23, 2019 City Council InterviewsEnvironmental Commission Interviews - February 13 February 25 (Monday):6:00Brian Smith (PRC 2nd Choice) 8:00Bhakti Modi (SC)6:15Ross Reeves (PRC 2nd Choice) 8:15Alice "Lisa" Lyon (SC)6:30 8:306:45Andrew Allen-NO SHOW 8:45Gerald Cook (PC)7:00Jeff Harken 9:00Laura Skistad (PC & PRC) 9:15 Planning Commission Interviews - February 19 9:30Andrew Aller (PC incumbent-coming from airport may be earlier)1stAntonio J. Fricano (SC 2nd Choice) 2ndBala Chintaginjala-NO SHOW WITHDRAWN February 26 (Tuesday): 3rdDouglas Reeder (PRC 2nd Choice) 5:00Sandy Sweetser (PRC)4thGerald Cook 5:15Bill Hickey (PRC)5thLynn Pelto WITHDRAWN Annette Stock-Lind 5:30Natalia Sander (PC-NO SHOW AT PC INTERVIEW) WITHDRAWN 6th 5:45Laurie Susla (PC)7thNatalia Sander-NO SHOW 6:00Jeff Harken (EC)8thJohn Kunitz 6:15Lynn Pelto (PC) WITHDRAW 9thLaurie Susla 6:30Steve Weick (PC incumbent)10thLaura Skistad (PRC 2nd Choice) 6:45Annette Stock Lind (PC) 7:00BREAKSenior Commission Interviews - February 21 7:15Rick Echternacht (PRC incumbent)4:10Ruth Lunde 7:30Cole Kelly (PRC incumbent)4:30Jim Camarata 7:45Haley Pemrick (PRC)4:50Alice "Lisa" Lyon 8:00Drew Allen (EC-NO SHOW AT EC INTERVIEW)5:10Bhakti Modi 8:15Brian Smith (EC & PRC)5:30Mike Schachterle 8:30Antonio Fricano (PC & SC)5:50Antonio Fricano (PC 1st Choice) 8:45Ruth Lunde (SC) 9:00Jim Camarata (SC)Park & Rec Commission Interviews - February 26 5:45Bill Hickey March 11 6:00Laura Skistad 4:30Doug Reeder (PC & PRC)6:15Sandy Sweetser 4:45John Kunitz (PC)6:30Doug Reeder 5:00Bill Chappell (EC incumbent)6:45Ross Reeves 5:15Mike Schachterle (SC)7:00Brian Smith 5:30Ross Reeves (EC & PRC)7:15Haley Pemrick 5:45Matt Kutz (PRC-OUT OF COUNTRY FOR PRC INTERVIEW) 6:00Discuss Commission Appointments Incumbents All commission appointments will take place at the March 11, 2019 City Council Meeting 2018 Planning Commission Attendance Record Percentage of July 3 May 1 June 5 April 3 July 17 May 15 June 19 April 17 Attendance March 6 August 7 Otober 2 January 2 March 20 August 21 January 16February 6 October 16 February 20 December 4 November 6 September 4 November 20 September 18 Andrew Aller 1111111111111193% 4/10 - 4/19 Mark Undestad 0000110111001147% 4/5 - 4/20 Steven Weick 1010111110110167% 4/13 - 4/19 John Tietz 1111111101011180% 4/15 - 4/20 Mark Randall 1101101111111180% 6/16 - 4/21 Michael McGonagill 1110011101047% 4/18 - 4/21 Nancy Madsen 1111111111111193% 4/15 - 4/19 Total Attended54040050076506606556060 Number of meetings to 15 date: red means no meeting PARK & RECREATIONCOMMISSION APPLICATIONS SUMMARY PARK & RECREATION COMMISSION – 2019 Terms Expiring: Cole Kelly (Reapplied) COMMISSIONCOUNCIL Rick Echternacht (Reapplied) RANK RANK Steve Scharfenburg (Resigning with one year left in his term) Grant Schaeferle (Youth Representative-no longer eligible) Cole Kelly, 1556 Bluebill Trail1 Rick Echternacht, 8746 Flamingo Drive 2 Sandy Sweetser, 9132 Springfield Drive 3 Applicants Haley Pemrick,7608 Erie Avenue4 Bill Hickey, 6301 Elm Tree Avenue--- Matt Kutz, 1080 Lyman Court--- Brian Smith, 7610 Great Plains Blvd. Apt. 201 5 st (EC 1 choice) Ross Reeves, 8471 Swan Court --- st (EC 1 choice) Alternate Douglas Reeder, 590 Broken Arrow Road --- st Applicants (PC 1choice) Laura Skistad, 2284 Stone Creek Lane West --- st (PC 1choice) Natalia Sander, 6671 Amberwood Lane (WITHDRAWN) --- Youth None --- Applicants First Ranked by: April 23 Meeting Steve Scharfenberg, Meredith Petouvis, and Karl Tsuchiya, in April Vacancies Two3-Year Terms/ One 1-Year Terms 1. 3-Year Terms (2) 2. 1-Year Term 1. (1) g:\\commission\\2019\\park & recreation commission matrix.docx ENVIRONMENTALCOMMISSION APPLICATIONS SUMMARY ENVIRONMENTALCOMMISSION – 2019 Terms Expiring: COMMISSION COUNCIL Bill Chappell (Reapplied) RANK RANK Wayne Benbow Bill Chappell, 8736 Stonefield Lane (Incumbent)1 Jeff Harken, 7020 Derby Drive 2 Brian Smith 3 Applicants Ross Reeves 4 Drew Allen5 Alternate None--- Applicants Ranked by: Environmental Commissioners Keith Butcher, Don Vasatka, First April 10 Greg Hawks, Wayne Benbow, and Kristin Fulkerson. Rachel Popken was Meeting absent. in April Vacancies Two3-Year Terms 1. 3-Year Terms (2) 2. g:\\commission\\2019\\environmental commission matrix.docx SENIORCOMMISSION APPLICATIONS SUMMARY SENIOR COMMISSION – 2019 Terms Expiring: COMMISSION COUNCIL Jackie Engel RANK RANK Cheryl Ayotte Jim Camarata, 6340 Oxbow Bend1 Ruth Lunde, 6721 Hopi Road3 Alice “Lisa” Lyon, 889 Kimberly Lane4 Applicants Bhakti Modi, 8663 Flamingo Drive 5 Mike Schachterle, 2852 Century Trail 6 Antonio Fricano, 980 Lake Lucy Road Alternate 2 st (PC 1choice) Applicants Ranked by: Senior Commissioners Barbara Nevin, Jerry Cerchia, and First April 18 Mack Titus. Commissioners Dorina Tipton and Carol Buesgens were Meeting absent. in April Vacancies Three 3-Year Terms 1. 3-Year Terms 2. (3) 3. NOTE: The Senior Commission has the option to appoint a total of 7 or 8 commissioners per Section 2.46-11 (b) of the City Code. g:\\commission\\2019\\senior commission matrix.docx 2018-2019SENIOR COMMISSION ATTENDANCE RECORD AprMayJuneJulyAugSeptOctNovDecJanFebMarPercent of Commissioner 201815201620191521182115Meetings Attended Dorina A. Tipton XX X XXXX 100% Cheryl AyotteXXXAXXA71% Carol BuesgensXXXXXXA85% Barbara NevinXX X XXXX 100% Mack TitusXX X AXXX 85% NO MEETINGNO MEETINGNO MEETINGNO MEETING Jackie Engel XX X XXXX 100% Jerry Cerchia XX X XXXX 100% \\\\cfs5\\cfs5\\shared_data\\plan\\sj\\sc\\attendance\\2018.docx  !"#$%&'(')*+ ;2+<$%)(%='#+%>%?!@@'-(%)(%;2+<%A!@)+- ,$+-.01'$2)!-" &-/"#+0.%34546758%%8.79%:  !"#$%) *+%,#$%) *+%,#$'-  !"#&'(  !"#0-%1*( )%.+# !"/ %7H77%53H7G 5I7G39B&,C*D2'E-'D2/$%!- -'%FG867646546758 %7H77%KGH77 5I7G3K; !J+#; !"#-($/0+%J+#+-/"'-(%;*/"/%&BB;7646546758 %7H77%9L5HG5 5I7G3I&+#+-;2+;2+*$+'%&+#+-$+"7646546758 %7H77%59H77 5I7G3LM;NCM;7646546758 %7H77%33H69 5I7G38M;NCM;7646546758 %7H77%I5H77 5I7GG7M *0B(""B(""+##+%M *0#7646546758 %7H77%5TKL9H8G 5I7GG5;OAOAO;OANOC&PQAN%OAOCRS%:QAAOR?;P7646546758 %7H77%K3IHGK 5I7GG6; !J+#; !"#-($/0+%J+#+-/"'-(%;*/"/%&BB;7646546758 %7H77%5T9K6H97 5I7GG3OUBOC?OUBOC?%V%??P;QNO?%QA;7646546758 %7H77%5T356H97 5I7GGGRPRS:AR %R(@"'$#/$7646546758 %7H77%3L7H59 5I7GG9QA=BQRQA=,?NCQB%BQRUNQAR%?,&&BS%QA;7646546758 %7H77%53H77 5I7GGKWPU:C:'-(""%W 2"$ "7646546758 %5T39KH77%7H77 5I7GGIXOARCXOAAO=S%V%RCJOAT%;UCNOCO=7646546758JPQ= %7H77%88GH77 5I7GGLBO:QABOR,O%PY%:QAAO?PN%;QNQO?7646546758 %7H77%8LHL9 5I7GG8:=RB:==OA%RBANOC%UA?OA%BB&7646546758 %7H77%5G6HLI 5I7G97:;X:O=:X+$$ "%:+0/'*>?!-E/'*%Q"7646546758 %7H77%59TG5GHKL 5I7G95:Q=;P,:Q=%;P,ANS%;PP&7646546758 %7H77%3L8H77 5I7G96:/"!&-+:/"!#+@'"%&-+$$7646546758 %7H77%5TIG6H35 5I7G93:PC?B:PCNPA%?BN7646546758 %7H77%KGT65KHI5 5I7G9G:NQ=Q?:NQ%=Q?NCQM,NQAR%QA;7646546758 %7H77%56TL85H93 5I7G99CQNCOCQAMPZ%NCOO%;P:&AS7646546758 %7H77%G7LH77 5I7G9KC?::Q;U:/2 "%C'$@!$$+"7646546758 %7H77%95KH97 5I7G9I?QRA?P?QRA?P,C;O7646546758 %7H77%69H77 5I7G9L?QAA=PA= "%?/""/E+-7646546758 %7H77%6TI97H77 5I7G98?P,?,M? !#21+$#%?!)!-)'"%&!)*/$2/"E7646546758 %7H77%53H77 5I7GK7?,BB&NC&'#-//'%?!**/\['"7646546758 %7H77%67H8K 5I7GK5#-/+0++'=++""%N-/+#2'-#7646546758 %7H77%KKLHIK 5I7GK6&P?N&P?N:?NOC7646I46758 %7H77%5T779H77 5I7GK3;UO;%V%UONQAR%MS%ROPCRO7646L46758 %7H77%IT377H77 5I7GKGNUOC:ON2+-@+27646L46758 %7H77%G77H77 5I7GK9C&C&7646L46758 %7H77%6KKHL7 5I7GKK:ONQC:OCQ;A%NQCO%=Q?NCQM,NPC?%QA;7646L46758 %7H77%3IIHI5 5I7GKI?&O\\,$D+"%O\]!/D@+"#7646L46758 %7H77%59H77 5I7GKLM;NCM;7646L46758 %7H77%K98HK8 5I7GK8MOC;PYMOCCS%;PYYOO%;P:&AS7646L46758 %7H77%977H77 5I7GI7M **"0M **/E%V%? "$T%Q"H7646L46758 %7H77%57H77 5I7GI5;?OW;PW;PM%;?OMOOC7646L46758 %7H77%559H8K 5I7GI6;PC:Q;PCO%V%:QA%B&7646L46758 %7H77%L3H3K 5I7GI3Y;:PNY;NPCS%:PNPC%&CN?%;P:&AS7646L46758 %7H77%KI8H7L 5I7GIGYBO&CQY*++#&-/0+T%Q"H7646L46758 %7H77%5K7H77 5I7GI9RCOZNR-+'#%Z'#+-$%Y/"'"/'*7646L46758 %7H77%5T769HII 5I7GIKUCNBQYOU'-#^ -0%B/^+%'"0%/0+"#%Q"$!-'"+%; @D'"(7646L46758 %7H77%LLH73 5I7GIIUOA;P,UOAAO&QA%;P,ANS7646L46758 %7H77%5TGKKHKI 5I7GILQ;:CNQ;:%CONQCO:OAN%A=%NC,?N>G9I7646L46758 %7H77%I39H77 5I7GI8B G8Q,PO%B '*%FG87646L46758 %7H77%5IT5I5HL3 5I7GL7:Q=;P,:Q=%;P,ANS%;PP&7646L46758 %7H77%5KH77 5I7GL5:/"!&-+:/"!#+@'"%&-+$$7646L46758 &%;2+<$%)(%='#+%>%?!@@'-(%)(%;2+<%A!@)+-%_34546758%%8.79%:`&'E+%5  !"#$%) *+%,#$%) *+%,#$'-  !"#&'( )%.+# !"/ !"#0-%1*( %7H77%53T696H77 5I7GL6:AUOB:A%=O&N%PY%UOBNU7646L46758 %7H77%KGH77 5I7GL3A;&OC?:A%A;&OC?%BQYO%QA?,CA;O7646L46758 %7H77%9KH97 5I7GLG?QRA?P?QRA?P,C;O7646L46758 %7H77%577H77 5I7GL9?N:QA?NNO%PY%:QAAO?PN7646L46758 %7H77%5T39KH77 5I7GLK?,MCN?,M,CMA%CNO%,NUPCQNS7646L46758 %7H77%IKH6I 5I7GLI,BQAO,BQAO%QA;7646L46758 %7H77%5T8G5H77 5I7GLLZQB?;PZ/**/'@$%? #$@'"%Q"7646L46758 %5T39KH77%599T9L3H78 C+D -#%N #'*%_9G%2+<$`. &%;2+<$%)(%='#+%>%?!@@'-(%)(%;2+<%A!@)+-%_34546758%%8.79%:`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`+#+30"'3(%,*0"0%&WW,7;9;:9;7:<:7:1:;A71B877N '350"TR%Ia'Y$R%D- #$%BB;FA7 , !"#3($05+%`+#+30"'3(%,*0"0%&WW,7;9;:9;7:<:7:1:;A71B877KYS !"5%K"#'.+R%N '350"T1KYS !"5%ABF77 , !"#3($05+%`+#+30"'3(%,*0"0%&WW,7;9;:9;7:<:7:1:;A71B877KYS !"5R%Ia'YR%D- #$%:<BF?A , !"#3($05+%`+#+30"'3(%,*0"0%&WW,%Q7:FBA IHWI>D%G%DDP,KJID%KL,7;9;:9;7:<Q77177771B8772#0*0#(%>'#+%D#!5(%@;7F?8 IHWI>D%G%DDP,KJID%KL,7;9;:9;7:<Q7:177771B8772#0*0#(%>'#+%D#!5(%@;7F?8 IHWI>D%G%DDP,KJID%KL,7;9;:9;7:<Q;7177771B8772#0*0#(%>'#+%D#!5(%@;7F?B IHWI>D%G%DDP,KJID%KL,%:R@A;F@7 \[,JP>O%=PJP>%&>JD%,P=&LO7;9;?9;7:<:7:1:;@71B:B7/IW%?A&D%S'3#%?8F8A \[,JP>O%=PJP>%&>JD%,P=&LO%?8F8A \[*++#&305+R%K"F7;9;?9;7:<:7:1:8Q71B:Q7\[*!05%/0+$+*%Ia-'!$#%@@%T'** "%:8@FAA \[*++#&305+R%K"F7;9;?9;7:<:7:1:8Q71B:Q7\[*!05%/0+$+*%Ia-'!$#%@@%T'** "%:8?F8Q \[*++#&305+R%K"F7;9;?9;7:<:7:1:8;71B:B7/+* %*#+3%:;`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`'*+"#0"+b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c'"0"%@AF@7 DKMLDP2>,I%@Q8F77 D0""0T+3%/ "7;9;:9;7:<:7:1:8;71B:@7='0*) a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c'35 !$%='#+30'*$%#%\[++R%,-+Y0'*%K"C+"# 3(%\[++%:77F77 DJJI%P\[%=KLLIDPJ%:77F77 D2N2>NL%>JI%2JHP>KJO7;9;?9;7:<:7:1:8:71B877;7:<%=+Y)+3$-0S%1%:$#%-'*E%:R8@AF77 D2N2>NL%>JI%2JHP>KJO%:R8@AF77 D!**0C'"%&'#300'7;9;:9;7:<:7:1:@A718A8Q>+E!"5%1%"%EE'03% E%#-+%H+'3#4%`'*+"#0"+b$%/'(%&'3#(%:8F77 D!**0C'"%&'#300'%:8F77 J-+3Y+-7;9;?9;7:<B77177771B@:7K"$!*'#0 "% YS*+#+%1%W=,%,*'0Y%QR877F77 J-+3Y+-%QR877F77 J30+#-'3#%/++""7;9;:9;7:<:7:1:;@71B:;7\[03$#%05%$!SS*0+$%;7F<A J30+#-'3#%/++""%;7F<A 2WKLI%KL,7;9;?9;7:<:7:1:A771B:87X-0#+%M3 +3(%N'T$%QAF;Q 2WKLI%KL,%QAF;Q X0**0'Y$%D #$Y'"%K"7;9;?9;7:<:7:1:A:Q1BB:7B;a:;%= )0*+%PEE0+%1%:9:;9:<%# %;9::9:<%ABQF77 X0**0'Y$%D #$Y'"%K"7;9;?9;7:<:7:1:A:Q1BB:7B;a:;%= )0*+%PEE0+%1%:9:;9:<%# %;9::9:<%ABQF77 X0**0'Y$%D #$Y'"%K"7;9;?9;7:<:7:1:A:Q1BB:7B;a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`L%/!'*%X'"6%R2P%&'T+4$%'"6%/+$.# N%,-'4T+4$%;;\\>K8M88 Q,U?%EF,2QB,A%,FQEF@%;;\\K<HML8 X (+4%E4!.%&'4#$8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9<81H;H8&0N+1FY-'!$#\\%X4'+\\%U0*%C+'*\\%/!$#%C-0+*6%LH>MKG X (+4%E4!.%&'4#$8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9<81H;H8&0N+1FY-'!$#%;>9MK< X (+4%E4!.%&'4#$%K;8ML8 ,'4-'4##8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H<H8AC%#1$-04#$\\%a+'"$\\%$7+'#$-04#%;=HM=H ,'4-'4##%;=HM=H ,'40) !%, SS++8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;<81H9K8@+4!0#I+"#%I++#0"T%1% SS++%>M88 ,'40) !%, SS++%>M88 ,'4Z+4%, !"#(8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;;>81H9<8,'4Z+4A0".%B"#+4"+#:P0)+4%1%P+)%<8;=%LH8M88 ,'4Z+4%, !"#(8<:<;:<8;=K881K8H91H9<8/'4.%P0)+4%OOE&%1%P+)%<8;=%9L8M88 ,'4Z+4%, !"#(8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;LL81H;L8E4+'#+6%C'*#%L\\GLLM8H ,'4Z+4%, !"#(%>\\KHLM8H ,/O%` Z+4"I+"#8<:;L:<8;=H881H;<>1HK89,'I+4'%6 I+%I !"#0"T%.0#%;8;M<> ,/O%` Z+4"I+"#8<:;L:<8;=H881H;<>1HK89,'I+4'%I !"#0"T%)4'.+#%G>M<L ,/O%` Z+4"I+"#8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;>81H<>8C+40'*%Q!**%? 6+4"%'6'N#+4%;8M;H ,/O%` Z+4"I+"#8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;>81H<>8X*'.%X Y%/X=%$+40'*%'6'N#+4$%<;M>= ,/O%` Z+4"I+"#%<;=M9H ,-'"-'$$+"%/0""+4%E-+'#4+8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L>81H9882 *06'(%B""%#0.+#$%;\\L88M88 ,-'"-'$$+"%/0""+4%E-+'#4+8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L>81H9882 *06'(%B""%#0.+#$%;\\H>HM;L ,-'"-'$$+"%/0""+4%E-+'#4+8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L>81H9882 *06'(%B""%#0.+#$%9;>MKL ,-'"-'$$+"%/0""+4%E-+'#4+%9\\<G8M=8 , ) 4"b$%/+*0Z+4$8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;;81H9K8,0#(%, !"0*%1%O'#+4%G=MK8 , ) 4"b$%/+*0Z+4$8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;K81H;;8C 'N\\%,4+'I+4$\\%04%P4+$-"+4$\\%E0$$!+$%>=MK> , ) 4"b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`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b$%&0WW'8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H;L87'#+4I'0"%)4+'.%1%S4 "#0+4%#4'0*%9KMKH / I0" b$%&0WW'%9KMKH /!"T'4++$8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H<H8&'"#$\\%V+'"$\\%X #$%;K<MHG /!"T'4++$8<:;L:<8;=K8;188881H<H8&'"#$\\%V+'"$\\%X #$%;K<MHK /!"T'4++$%9HHM=L FI+4T+"(%@+$N "$+%C *!#0 "$8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;<<81H;<8U1@0"T%9GMGG FI+4T+"(%@+$N "$+%C *!#0 "$%9GMGG F"Z04 E+-%C+4Z0+$%B"M8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;9<81H;L8,'*0!I%,-* 406+%;\\8<HM8G F"Z04 E+-%C+4Z0+$%B"M%;\\8<HM8G FN0%CN 4#$8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L981H;<8P 'I%X 7*0"T%&0"$%H<M>9 FN0%CN 4#$%H<M>9 P'+) .8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L981H9KL2 *06'(%6%X !#0c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d%.+(+6%1%e;8%$#'TT+4+6%N 4#$%K9GM8L PU@,F%?F@B,%BQ,%K9GM8L P4+$-7'#+48<:;L:<8;=;8;1;9;81H9K8<8;=%@ '6%C'*#%C(IN%@+T0$#4'#0 "%1%,%X!4.+%;HLM88 P4+$-7'#+48<:;L:<8;=;8;1;9;81H9K8<8;=%@ '6%C'*#%C(IN%@+T0$#4'#0 "%1%@%&0".'**'%;HLM88 P4+$-7'#+4%<=8M88 ` Z+4"I+"#%P0"'"+%USS0+4$%$$ 0'#0 "8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;981H9K8""!'*%`PU%, "S+4+"+%H<8M88 ` Z+4"I+"#%P0"'"+%USS0+4$%$$ 0'#0 "%H<8M88 2'-%, IN'"(8<:;L:<8;=K881K8H91HLL8,-* 40"+%@+'T+"#\\%,-+I.+(%@+T+"#$%H9>M<K 2'-%, IN'"(%H9>M<K 2+'*#-(D0"M I8<:;L:<8;=K881K8;=1H;L8&'N+4%# 7+*$\\%# 0*+#%N'N+4%;GHMKL 2+'*#-(D0"M I%;GHMKL 2UBCBQ`EUQ%DUF`AF@%`@U3&8<:<;:<8;=H;8188881H988&4 a%8;G18K<%A'.+%""%&'4.%FYN'"$0 "%1%$Z%S4 I%V'"%<8;=%K\\9L8M88 2UBCBQ`EUQ%DUF`AF@%`@U3&%K\\9L8M88 2 I+%/+N #8<:;L:<8;=K881K8;=1HL;8/ 4%,* $+4\\%P 'I%C+'*'"#%;==M>9 2 I+%/+N #8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;LL81H;<8&*(7 6\\%&'0"#\\%`*!+\\%,-'0"\\%C'7\\%/40**:BIN'#%D0#%H<GM>H 2 I+%/+N #8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H<>8E 4-%2+'6\\%,(*0"6+4\\%E *%X'T%L<MH< 2 I+%/+N #8<:;L:<8;=K881K8;=1H;L8,')*+%E0+$\\%O04+%@ N+%;HM8; 2 I+%/+N #8<:;L:<8;=K8;188881HLL;&R,%X!$-0"T\\%, !N*0"T%GM9< 2 I+%/+N #8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;9<81H<>82'II+4%/40**:BIN'#%/40Z+4%, I) %<>KM9> 2 I+%/+N #8<:;L:<8;=K881K8H91H;L8/+#+4T+"#\\%`4+'$+%T!"\\%@!$#%@+I Z+4%=;M<= 2 I+%/+N #%;\\8>;M>K 2 !*0-'"b$8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;;81H9K8f+'4%+"6%74'N%!N%70#-%M%6+N#%-+'6$%KGM88 2 !*0-'"b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`4+'#%&*'0"$%@+T0 "%@+T0$#4'#0 "%1%V%D+ T-%<=8M88 B"#+4"'#0 "'*%, 6+%, !"0*8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;<L81H9K8<8;=%B,,%3NN+4%`4+'#%&*'0"$%@+T0 "%@+T0$#4'#0 "%1%&%F.- *I%<=8M88 B"#+4"'#0 "'*%, 6+%, !"0*8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;<L81H9K8<8;=%B,,%3NN+4%`4+'#%&*'0"$%@+T0 "%@+T0$#4'#0 "%1%F%E+$$I'"%<=8M88 B"#+4"'#0 "'*%, 6+%, !"0*8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;<L81H9K8<8;=%B,,%3NN+4%`4+'#%&*'0"$%@+T0 "%@+T0$#4'#0 "%1%X%C!**0Z'"%<=8M88 B"#+4"'#0 "'*%, 6+%, !"0*8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;<L81H9K8<8;=%B,,%3NN+4%`4+'#%&*'0"$%@+T0 "%@+T0$#4'#0 "%1%V%2+06+*)+4T+4%;HLM88 B"#+4"'#0 "'*%, 6+%, !"0*8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;<L81H9>8,+40S0'#+%4+"+7'*$%S 4%#-+%"+Y#%9%(+'4$%;<LM88 B"#+4"'#0 "'*%, 6+%, !"0*%;\\H98M88 V,&+""+(8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H<H8V+'"$%K=M=G V,&+""+(8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H<H8O 4.%C-04#%98M88 V,&+""+(%;8=M=G V -"%2+"4(%P $#+48<:;L:<8;=K881K8;=1H;<8\[+.$%/4'0"%P* '#%KLMH= V -"%2+"4(%P $#+4%KLMH= A!"6$%_%X(+4*(b$8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;;81H9K8T '*%$+$$0 "%1%FTT%X'.+%9>M<H A!"6$%_%X(+4*(b$%9>M<H ?'(b$8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H<H8V+'"$\\%&'"#$\\%$-04#$%=;M9K ?'(b$8<:;L:<8;=K8;188881H<H8V+'"$\\%&'"#$\\%$-04#$%=;M9K ?'(b$%;G<MKH ?+"'46$8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;<<81H<=8P *60"T%D"0S+%<;M>9 ?+"'46$%<;M>9 ?FE@U&UABEQ%PU@/8<:<G:<8;=K8;188881H;H8;;;9%D0#%1%V+#%;;MH8 ?FE@U&UABEQ%PU@/%;;MH8 ?0**$%P*++#%P'4I8<:;L:<8;=K8;188881H<H8E1$-04#$\\%V+'"$\\%,4+7%<=M;G ?0**$%P*++#%P'4I8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H<H8E1$-04#$\\%V+'"$\\%,4+7%<=M;G ?0**$%P*++#%P'4I%LGM9> ?0""+$ #'%Q!4$+4(%'"6%A'"6$'N+8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H9K8Q 4#-+4"%`4++"%<8;=%9<KM88 ?0""+$ #'%Q!4$+4(%'"6%A'"6$'N+%9<KM88 ?0""+$ #'%@!4'*%O'#+4%$$ 0'#0 "8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H9K8,*'$$%1%?'4-%L1K\\%<8;=%<=8M88 ?0""+$ #'%@!4'*%O'#+4%$$ 0'#0 "8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H9K8@+S!"6%S 4%*'$$%1%I+I)+41L8M88 ?0""+$ #'%@!4'*%O'#+4%$$ 0'#0 "%<H8M88 ?0""+$ #'%E4 N-0+$%_%`0S#$8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;>;;1H;98,4'.+6%B+%#4 N-0+$%H;M<= ?0""+$ #'%E4 N-0+$%_%`0S#$%H;M<= ?Q%/+N#% S%T40!*#!4+8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;LL81H9K8?/%@+"+7'*%1%/%D $.+*'%;8M<<  !"#$%&'(')*+%1%,-+.%/+#'0*1,2%\]89:8;:<8;=%1%%=5<>%?^&'T+%L% S%;8  !"#!$%&'($$)*+,'!-$./0,/)+( )*+, ?Q%/+N#% S%T40!*#!4+%;8M<< ?Q%RAAFf%FAF,E@B,%,UU&8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9L81H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%;9KMK> ?Q%RAAFf%FAF,E@B,%,UU&8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9L81H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%H9M8L ?Q%RAAFf%FAF,E@B,%,UU&8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9L81H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%;<;MHL ?Q%RAAFf%FAF,E@B,%,UU&%98<M<> ?3QB,B&A%,U/F%,U@&U@EBUQ8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;;>81H988""!'*%- $#0"T%S++%1%0#(% 6+%=88M88 ?3QB,B&A%,U/F%,U@&U@EBUQ%=88M88 Q&%3EU%_%E@3,D%&@EC8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9<81H;<8I0$%N'4#$:$!NN*0+$%>MLG Q&%3EU%_%E@3,D%&@EC%>MLG Q 4#-+4"%E *gFc!0NI+"#8<:;L:<8;=K88188881HL982'"6%#4!.\\%`+"+4'# 4%;\\<89M;G Q 4#-+4"%E *gFc!0NI+"#%;\\<89M;G USS0+%?'Y:USS0+%/+N #8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;LL81H;<8& $#10#$\\%?'4.+4$\\%&+"0*$\\%, 4.%X '46\\%E 7+*+##+$%K;M8; USS0+%?'Y:USS0+%/+N #8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;<<81H<=8X0"6+4$%H8ML= USS0+%?'Y:USS0+%/+N #%;;;M>8 &'"+4'%X4+'68<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;;81H9K8,0#(%, !"0*%/0""+4%;=8M;= &'"+4'%X4+'6%;=8M;= &'4#$%&+ N*+8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;>81HL98/+**%A'#0#!6+%4+N*'+I+"#%$4++"%;==M=L &'4#$%&+ N*+%;==M=L &+#+4$ "%X4 #-+4$%P!"+4'*%2 I+8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;;81H9K8P!"+4'*%P* 7+4$%S 4%E 66%2 SSI'"b$%S'#-+4%G<M;9 &+#+4$ "%X4 #-+4$%P!"+4'*%2 I+%G<M;9 &0 "++4%F"T0"++40"T\\%&MM8<:<;:<8;=>8;1>8H<1H988;;G;9<%A'.+%C!$'"%E4'0*%@+-')%1%$Z%#-4 !T-%;:9;:;=%9L8M88 &0 "++4%F"T0"++40"T\\%&MM%9L8M88 & #+"#0'%?Q%C *'48<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;=81H9<8/++I)+4%<8;G%;\\9L;M;K & #+"#0'%?Q%C *'48<:<G:<8;=K88188881H9<8/++I)+4%<8;G%>LKMH< & #+"#0'%?Q%C *'48<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;K81H9<8/++I)+4%<8;G%;\\8L=M<H & #+"#0'%?Q%C *'4%9\\8>KMG9 & !"6+4b$%X'4%_%`40**8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;<81H9K8,'4Z+4%, !"#(%,0#(%?T4%I++#0"T%;GM88 & !"6+4b$%X'4%_%`40**%;GM88 & 7+4%C($#+I$8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L981H;<8&!IN%C+#1X'4%U"*(\\%C0"T*+%`40N%2'"6*+%7:4 #'#0"T%-'"6*+%GKM8; & 7+4%C($#+I$8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L981H;<8&!IN%C+#1X'4%U"*(\\%C0"T*+%`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`+4-'46#%L9M88 @ #'4(%,*!)%;8>M88 C'Ib$%,*!)8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L>81H988P4!0#\\%/+$$+4#\\%CN0"'-\\%U"0 "$%9;MHG C'Ib$%,*!)%9;MHG C+"$0)*+%A'"6%3$+%, '*0#0 "8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;H<81H9K8?'4.+#%@+'N%'"6%<8;=%P 4+'$#%X4+'.S'$#:&4 T4'I%1%D%'"+"$ "%HGM88 C+"$0)*+%A'"6%3$+%, '*0#0 "%HGM88 C ('%C!$-0%_%`40**8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;<<81H<=8/0""+4%S 4%QfF%4+7%K>M;9 C ('%C!$-0%_%`40**%K>M;9 C#'4%E40)!"+8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L981H9>8<8;=%Q+7$N'N+4%C!)$40N#0 "%H;8M<G C#'4%E40)!"+%H;8M<G C#'Z4 $%&4 N+4#0+$8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;LL81H988hH%<8;G%F'$+I+"#%S++$%S 4%N4 N+4#(%'6a'+"#%# %KG8L%`4+'#%&*'0"$%989MH< C#'Z4 $%&4 N+4#0+$%989MH< CE@EU`3@/%AA,8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;;>81H988&4 SN 0"#%FI'0*%P0*#+40"T%$+4Z0+%1%?'4%<8;=%;>9M<8 CE@EU`3@/%AA,%;>9M<8 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;LL81H988""!'*%P04+%FY#0"T!0$-+4%?'0"#+"'"+%1%A'.+%""%&'4.%9;<M88 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;;=81H988""!'*%P04+%FY#0"T!0$-+4%?'0"#+"'"+%1%A0)4'4(%KLM88 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;;K81H988""!'*%P04+%FY#0"T!0$-+4%?'0"#+"'"+%1%,0#(%2'**%;98M88  !"#$%&'(')*+%1%,-+.%/+#'0*1,2%\]89:8;:<8;=%1%%=5<>%?^&'T+%K% S%;8  !"#!$%&'($$)*+,'!-$./0,/)+( )*+, C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;<<81H988""!'*%P04+%FY#0"T!0$-+4%?'0"#+"'"+%1%P04+%/+N#%_%E4!.$%H==M88 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;<<81H988""!'*%P04+%FY#0"T!0$-+4%?'0"#+"'"+%1%P04+%/+N#%<9LM88 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;9K81H988""!'*%CN40".*+4%B"$N+#0 "% S%<%7+#%$($#+I$%1%&!)*0%O 4.$%X*6T%<HLM88 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;<<81H988""!'*%CN40".*+4%B"$N+#0 "% S%;%7+#%$($#+I%1%P04+%/+N#%_%E4!.$%;=LM88 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;;=81H988""!'*%CN40".*+4%B"$N+#0 "% S%;%7+#%$($#+I%1%A0)4'4(%;=LM88 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<;:<8;=;8;1;;K81H988""!'*%CN40".*+4%B"$N+#0 "% S%;%7+#%$($#+I:;%2 6%1%,0#(%2'**%<98M88 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC8<:<G:<8;=K881K8;=1HL98""!'*%CN40".*+4%B"$N+#0 "% S%;%7+#:;%64(%$($#+I%1%OE&%9=8M88 C3??BE%,U?&QBFC%<\\L8>M88 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;<L81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%HLM88 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9;81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%9=M8= C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;<L81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%9<M9; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%1%, )4'%L8M;; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9;81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%9=MGG C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%HKM>< C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9K81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%;GMG> C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;L<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%;9ML8 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;L981H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%>M<; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;L>81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%LM;9 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;>881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%;8MGL C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;K881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%;M<; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;LL81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%H8M<H C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;H<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%9HMLG C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%99M98 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%HKM=; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;981H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%<;M98 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;>81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%;;M<; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%9<ML> C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;H981H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%<M8L C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=<;8188881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%KM=8 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K<81K<8;1H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%<MH9 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K<81K<8<1H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%<MH9 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9K81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%;=M;; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;K81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%9ML; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;<<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%;GMK< C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;>81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%;;MGG C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K8;188881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%98M;G C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K88188881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%9=M;H C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K<8188881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%=M=K C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%K>8M9> C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=<;8188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%>M<= C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K88188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%;8=ML< C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K8;188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%;8=ML< C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K<8188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1?'4-%<8;=%=M88 C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;981H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%<<M8; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%><M9> C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;L<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%;;M>> C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;L981H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%>M9= C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;L>81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%LM9; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;>881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%9MG< C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;K881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=18MLG C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;LL81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%H8MLG C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;H<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%9LM=> C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;H981H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%<M;<  !"#$%&'(')*+%1%,-+.%/+#'0*1,2%\]89:8;:<8;=%1%%=5<>%?^&'T+%G% S%;8  !"#!$%&'($$)*+,'!-$./0,/)+( )*+, C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=<;8188881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%GM;L C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K<81K<8;1H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%<ML< C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K<81K<8<1H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%<ML< C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;;K81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%9MLK C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;<<81H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%;GM== C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K8;188881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%98ML> C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K88188881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%9=ML< C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K<8188881H8H8A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%HM<; C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=;8;188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%KKHMGG C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=<;8188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%>MLG C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K88188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%;;HM>= C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K8;188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%;;HM>= C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*8<:<G:<8;=K<8188881<8;;A0S+%B"$!4'"+1P+)4!'4(%<8;=%HMGL C!"%A0S+%P0"'"0'*%<\\=GGM<H E'4T+#8<:;L:<8;=K8;188881H<H8V+'"$%L9M=K E'4T+#8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;;K81H;<8E4'(%'"6%X4!$-%# %*+'"%'4N+#%;=M9; E'4T+#8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L981H;98E0$$!+$%HMG< E'4T+#8<:;L:<8;=K88188881H<H8V+'"$%L9M=K E'4T+#%;9<M8K E,B,\\%B"M8<:<G:<8;=K88188881HL98;811?PE1;8%<KHML8 E,B,\\%B"M%<KHML8 E !-& 0"#%A T0%AA,8<:<G:<8;=<;8188881HK8L, !"0*%,-'I)+4%/0T0#'*%?+60'%R%3NT4'6+%>8\\8KHM88 E !-& 0"#%A T0%AA,%>8\\8KHM88 3AEB?EF%,UQE@UAC%FAF,E@B,%AA,8<:<G:<8;=K881K8;=1HLL8,-'"-'$$+"%FOE&%04%/0$-'4T+%&4+$$!4+%E4'"$I0##+4%<\\=L>M88 3AEB?EF%,UQE@UAC%FAF,E@B,%AA,8<:<G:<8;=K8;188881HL98,-'"-'$$+"%A0S#%C#'#0 "%e<>%C70#-%O040"T%>LLM88 3AEB?EF%,UQE@UAC%FAF,E@B,%AA,%9\\>;;M88 3QBEF/%Of8<:<G:<8;=;8;188881<88>&@%X'#-%88H8;M89M<8;=%3"0#+6%O'(%<=MH8 3QBEF/%Of%<=MH8 34)'"%A'"6%B"$#0#!#+8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;H<81H9K8&!)*0%T+"(%?+I)+4$-0N%L>8M88 34)'"%A'"6%B"$#0#!#+%L>8M88 3CX*!+X .8<:;L:<8;=K881K8H91HLL8C'IN*0"T%Z'*Z+%H<M>> 3CX*!+X .%H<M>> RFCC,U%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=K881K8;=1HL98FRL8R%4+)!0*6%.0#%;G>M88 RFCC,U%BQ,%;G>M88 OFBCC?Q8<:;L:<8;=;8;1;L9L1H;98, $#!I+$%99>M8; OFBCC?Q%99>M8; i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9L81H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%9<M;8  !"#$%&'(')*+%1%,-+.%/+#'0*1,2%\]89:8;:<8;=%1%%=5<>%?^&'T+%=% S%;8  !"#!$%&'($$)*+,'!-$./0,/)+( )*+, i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<;:<8;=K88188881H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%L\\L;=M8G i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=K88188881H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%;\\HG9M9G i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=K8;188881H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%L\\K9GM<H i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=K88188881H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%<\\HH>ML> i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9L81H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%;;M9< i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9L81H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%;;M9< i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;>881H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%;<M;> i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;>881H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%;8M;L i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=K88188881H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%>;M8G i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=;8;1;9L81H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%98M;= i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,8<:<G:<8;=K881K8H91H9<8+*+#400#(%-'4T+$%9\\9K8M<K i,FA%FQF@`f%BQ,%;G\\K<LMGL \[ 4 8<:;L:<8;=K881K8;=1H;<8@+N'04%D0#%9HMG8 \[ 4 %9HMG8 %;L8\\GG9M<>  !"#$%&'(')*+%1%,-+.%/+#'0*1,2%\]89:8;:<8;=%1%%=5<>%?^&'T+%;8% S%;8 FEBRUARY 2019 WEBSITE ANALYTICS OVERVIEW SESSIONS VS. PAGEVIEWS SessionsPageviews 1,0001,0001,0001,0001,0001,000 3,0003,0003,000 15,932 Sessions vs. 38,702 Pageviews 2,0002,0002,000 Session: The period of time a user is actively 500500500500 engaged with our website, app, etc. 1,0001,0001,0001,0001,0001,0001,0001,0001,000 Pageview: Total # of pages viewed. Repeated views of a single page are counted. ÈFeb 3Feb 5Feb 7Feb 9Feb 11Feb 13Feb 15Feb 17Feb 19Feb 21Feb 23Feb 25Feb 27 HOW ARE THEY FINDING US?NEW VS. RETURNING VISITORWHAT CAN WE LEARN? Chanhassen’s website gains attention from neighboring communities as well as some 7,080 Organic Search 9,523 New Visitors from around the country. Visitors spend very little time on each page, which hopefully 3,723 Direct 3,291 Returning Visitors 582 Social 315 Referral WHAT ARE THEY SEARCHING FOR?WHAT PAGES ARE THEY VISITING? Organic Search Direct Social PagePageviews Search TermTotal Unique Searches Referral 38,702 (Other)1,046 31.8% % of Total: % of Total: 100.00% 100.00%(38,702) 60.5% (1,046) 5,411 1./ (13.98%) 15 1.Pickleball (1.43%) 1,352 2./https://www.governmentjobs.com/careers/chanhassenmn (3.49%) 7 2.Ithilien Pond Maintenance Project (0.67%) 1,298 3./296/Recreation-Center (3.35%) 6 3.pickleball WHERE ARE THEY? AVG TIME ON PAGE(0.57%) 1,287 4./240/Agendas-Minutes-Videos (3.33%) 6 1 minute 34 seconds 4.Snow Removal 1,855 1,073 1.Minneapolis (0.57%) 5./270/February-Festival (15.72%) (2.77%) AVG PAGE LOAD TIME 5 1,468 995 5.map 2.Chanhassen 6./301/Gym-Schedule (0.48%) (12.44%) (2.57%) 3.59 seconds 1,212 5 702 3.Chicago 7./31/Parks-Recreation 6.Rink Attendant Job Description (10.27%) (1.81%) (0.48%) 613 670 HOW OLD ARE THEY? 4.Chaska 5 8./194/Proposed-Developments (5.20%)7.volunteer (1.73%) (0.48%) 557 1,210 588 5.Eden Prairie 1.35-44 9./1467/Galpin-Site---Preliminary-Plat-Rezoning- 5 (4.72%) (28.70%) (1.52%) 8.zoning map (0.48%) 433 985 492 6.Saint Paul 2.25-34 10./vr/modal (3.67%) (23.36%) (1.27%) 4 9.Babysitting 101 (0.38%) 312 918 7.Minnetonka 3.45-54 (2.64%) (21.77%) 4 10.Basketball (0.38%) 236 583 8.Waconia 4.55-64 (2.00%) (13.83%) 224 314 9.Seattle 5.65+ (1.90%) (7.45%) 193 206 10.Bloomington 6.18-24 (1.64%) (4.89%)